This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Robust Design of an Automotive Structure Using Durability CAE
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
There is a trend in the automotive industry to reduce the number of physical prototypes and to rely more on Computer Aided Engineering (CAE) for sizing and final design of vehicle structures. The traditional deterministic approach does not necessarily clarify the degree of variability and conservatism. With small variability in influence parameters and a design factor for final design, the approach may be over conservative resulting in weight and cost penalty. On the other hand, with large variability and the same design factor, the deterministic approach may not satisfy durability requirements. It is important to identify the variability of all factors including road loads and sensitivities of the control parameters, and to minimize their effects on durability so that fatigue life distribution meets the durability requirements. Low cycle fatigue approach is used for all calculations for reliability oriented design that is based on probabilistic rather than deterministic descriptions of design variables. The objective of this study is to develop a method to understand the fatigue influence factors and the effects of their variabilities on a typical automotive shock tower reliability. The study includes determination of fatigue influence factors, Response Surface Model (RSM), and finally the probability/reliability plots for the shock tower model. The CAE process consists of generating systematic computer experimentation matrices using Design Of Experiments (DOE) with (1) Latin Hypercube (LH) sampling and (2) Orthogonal Arrays (OA) within the design ranges. Next, critical finite elements are determined and fatigue life is calculated for each design configuration in the experimentation matrices for the shock tower structure. Fatigue influence factors and Response Surface Models (RSMs) are determined using non-linear regression analysis for Latin Hypercube (LH) sampling and linear regression analysis for Orthogonal Array (OA) method and the results are compared. Finally, a Monte Carlo Simulation method is used to obtain probability/reliability estimation. Based upon the results, fatigue life distributions can be aligned to match the durability requirements by providing appropriate design direction. The method can be extended to various other critical structures and such plots can be generated and used for future design of similar structures.
Recommended Content
Technical Paper | An Excel Based Robust Design Tool for Vehicle Structural Optimization |
Topic
Citation
Agrawal, H., Sudjianto, A., and Juneja, L., "Robust Design of an Automotive Structure Using Durability CAE," SAE Technical Paper 971533, 1997, https://doi.org/10.4271/971533.Also In
References
- Fajdiga M. Kernc J. et al “A Direct Method for Calculation of Probability of Occurance of Stress-Strain States Using Load Collective Analysis” Fatigue Design Symposium Helsinki Sept. 5-8 1995
- Gopalakrishnan R. Agrawal H. N. “Durability Analysis of Automotive Body Structures” SAE International Congress & Exposition Detroit, Michigan March 1-5 1993
- Agrawal H. N. Conle Al Gopalakrishnan Ravi et al “Upfront Durability Analysis for Automotive Sheet Metal Structures” SAE International Congress & Exposition Detroit, Michigan Feb. 26-29 1996
- Wu Y.T. Millwater H.R. Cruse T.A. “An Advanced Probabilistic Structural Analysis Method for Implicit Performance Functions,” AIAA Journal 28 9 1663 1669 1990
- Bates R.A. Wynn H.P. “Tolerancing and Optimization for Model-Based Robust Engineering Design,” Quality and reliability Engineering International 12 119 127 1996
- Lunani M. Sudjianto A. Johnston P. “Generating Efficient Training Samples for Neural Networks using Latin Hypercube Sampling,” Intelligent Engineering System through Artificial Neural Networks 5 209 214 ASME Press 1995
- Kreyszig Erwin “Advanced Engineering Mathematics” Seventh John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
- Bain Lee J. Engelhardt Max “Introduction to Probability and Mathematical Statistics” Second Duxbury Press
- Morrow J. “Fatigue Design Handbook,” SAE 1968
- Smith K. N. Watson P. Topper T. H. “A Stress Strain Function for the Fatigue of Metals,” J. Mater. 5 4 Dec. 1970 767
- Miner M. A. “Cumulative Damage in Fatigue,” Trans. ASME, J. Appl. Mech. 67 Sept. 1945 A159
- Palmgren A. “Die Lebensdauer von Kugellagern,” 68 14 1924 339
- Friedman J.H. “Multivariate Adaptive Regression Splines (with discussion),” The Annals of Statistics 19 1 41 1991