This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
A Repeated-Crash Test Technique for Assessment of Structural Impact Behavior
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published February 24, 1986 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
An economical alternative technique is presented for obtaining vehicle frontal crush characteristics from a series of repeated low speed barrier crashes. Results were analyzed using a technique of linear correlation of residual crush depth with a defined crush energy parameter. The data compared closely with crashes reported in the literature, and suggested that the structure exhibits only a slight strain rate sensitivity. Crush energy is shown to correlate well with dynamic crush depth. Relations among dynamic and residual crush and recovery distance are reported, Velocity restitution is shown to be about constant at 15% over the impact velocity range employed. A force-deflection relation based on the offset force linear harmonic oscillator theory is suggested, shown to agree quite well with data. Repeated crash testing can be an effective method to obtain information needed for development of analytical and predictive tools useful in design and reconstruction.
CitationWarner, C., Allsop, D., and Germane, G., "A Repeated-Crash Test Technique for Assessment of Structural Impact Behavior," SAE Technical Paper 860208, 1986, https://doi.org/10.4271/860208.
- Campbell, K.; “Energy Basis for Collision Severity” SAE Paper No. 740565; 1974.
- McHenry, R.; “Users Manual for the CRASH Computer Program” CALSPAN Report ZQ-5708-V-3; CALSPAN Corporation, Buffalo, NY; January, 1976.
- Strother, C. E., et. al.; “Crush Energy in Accident Reconstruction” Presented at 1986 SAE Winter Annual; Detroit, MI; 1986.
- NHTSA Crash Test File Tapes; NHTSA Office of Crashworthiness Research (NRD 12) Department of Transportation, NASSIF Building 7th and D; S. W. Washinton, D. C. and “Automobile Consumer Information Crash Test Program Vol. I” Prepared for National Highway Traffic Safety Administration; Calspan Corporation, Buffalo, NY: November 1976.
- Levan, W. and Alianello, D.; “New Car Assessment and Standards Enforcement Indicant Testing FMVSS Nos. 212, 219 and 301-75 (80 Citation 35 mph Frontal Barrier Test)” Calspan Report No. 6525-V-3; June 1979.
- Levan, W, and Alianello, D.; New Car Assessment and Standards Enforcement Indicant Testing FMVSS Nos. 212, 219 and 301-75 (80 Citation 40 mph Front Barrier Test)” Calspan Report No. 6525-V-1; June, 1979.
- Levan, W and Alianello, D.; New Car Assessment and Standards Enforcement Indicant Testing FMVSS Nos. 212, 219 and 301-75 (80 Citation 48 mph Frontal Barrier Test)” Calspan Report No. 6525-V-2; June, 1979.
- Calspan Corporation, Report No. 7081-V-5; “35 mph Crash Test Repeatability Program” GM Corp., 1982 Chevrolet Citation, 4-Dr. Hatchback; NHTSA Final Report; April 1983; U.S. Dept. of Transportation.
- “Proceedings of Volvo Workshop on Assessment of Crash Severity” Bjertorp. Sweden; September 11, 1984.
- Kamal, M. K.; “Analysis and Simulation of Vehicle to Barrier Impact” SAE Safety Compendium; SAE Paper No. 700414; SAE, Warrendale, PA; 1970.
- Lips on, Charles and Juvinall, Robert C.; “Handbook of Stress and Strength Design and Material Applications” The Macmillan Company, New York Collier-Macmillan Ltd., London; 1963.
- Shigley, J. E.; “Mechanical Engineering Design” McGraw-Hill Book Company, University of Michigan; 1972; p. 195.
- Tani, M. and Funahashi, A.; “Energy Absorption by the Plastic Deformation of Body Structural Members”; Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc., Warrendale, PA 15096; 1978.
- Ni, C. and Fine, D.; “Predicting Crush Response of Automotive Structural Components” SAE Paper No. 780671; Passenger Car Meeting, Troy Hilton, Troy, MI; June 5-9, 1978.
- Ohkubo, Y., Akamatsu, T., and Shirasawa, K.; “Mean Crushing Strength of Closed-Hat Section Members” SAE Paper No. 740040; Automotive Engineering Congress, Detroit, MI; February 25 - March 1, 1974.
- Prasad, P. and Padgaonkar, A.; “Static-to-Dynamic Amplification Factors for Use in Lumped-Mass Vehicle Crash Models” Ford Motor Company; SAE Paper No. 810475; SAE, Inc.; 1981.
- Saxena, A. and Chatfield, D.; “High Strain Rate Behavior of Some Hot and Cold Rolled Low Carbon Steels” SAE Paper No. 760209; Automotive Engineering Congress and Exposition, Detroit, MI; February 23-27, 1976.
- Aguiar, A.; “Applications of Computer Graphics to Automotive Structural Analysis” SAE Paper No. 760182; Automotive Engineering Congress and Exposition, Detroit, MI; February 23-27, 1976.
- VanKuren R. C. and Scott, J. E.; “Energy Absorption of High Strength Steel Tubes Under Impact Crush Conditions” SAE Paper No. 770213; International Automotive Engineering Congress and Exposition, Cobo Hall, Detroit, MI; February 28-March 4, 1977.
- Herridge, J. T. and Mitchell, R. K.; “Development of a Computer Simulation Program for Collinear Car/Car and Car/Barrier Collisions” Battelle, Columbus Laboratories, 505 King Avenue, Columbus, OH 43201; Department of Transportation, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 400 Seventh Street. S. W. Washington, D. C. 20590; Contract # FH-11-7550; January 15, 1972.
- Herridge, J. T. and Mitchell, R. K.; “Development of a Computer Simulation Program for Collinear Car/Car and Car/Barrier Collisions” Thermal and Mechanical Energy Systems Division, Columbus Laboratories, Battelle Memorial Institute, Columbus, OH; May 2, 1973.
- Lin, K.; “A Rear-End Barrier Impact Simulation Model for Unibody Passenger Cars” General Motors Corp.; SAE Paper No. 730156; SAE, Inc., Warrendale, PA; 1973.
- Thompson, J. E.; “Vehicle Crush Prediction Using Finite-Element Techniques” SAE Paper No. 730157; International Automotive Engineering Congress, Detroit, MI; January 8-12, 1973.
- Shieh, R. C.; “Strain Rate Sensitivity Effects on Crash Response and Dynamic Yield Moment Formulas for Crash Prediction Bumpers” AIAA/ASME/SAE Struct Dyn, and Mater Conf, Proc, Denver, CO; 1975; Sponsored by AIAA, New York, NY; 1975.
- Okuno, A., Nakashima, K., Okada, K., and Takeda, S.; “On an Analytical Crush Energy Management of Automotive Structural Components” SAE Paper No. 830921; Toyo Kogyo Co., Ltd., Japan; 1983.
- Manjoine, M. J.; “Influence of Rate of Strain and Temperature on Yield Stresses of Mild Steel” Journal of Applied Mechanics, East Pittsburgh, PA; December 1944.
- Welch, R. E. et. al.; “Finite Element Analysis of Automotive Structures Under Crash Loadings. Volume II. Technical Report” Prepared for National Highway Traffic Safety Administration; National Technical Information Service, U. S. Department of Commerce; March 1976,
- Monk, M. W. and Guenther, D. A.; “Update of Crash II Computer Model Damage Tables Vol, II; Vehicle Research and Test Center, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, P. O. Box 37, East Liberty, OHJ 43311; U. S. Department of Transportation, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, Washington, D. C. 20590; March 1983.
- Baker, J. S.; Traffic Accident Investigation Manual : The Traffic Institute, Northwestern University, Evanston, IL; 1975; p. 240ff.
- Collins, J. C. and Morris, J. L.; “Highway Collision Analysis” Charles C. Thomas, publisher. Springfield, IL; 1967; p. 138ff,
- Woolley, R. et. al.; “Graphical Solution of Reconstruction Equations” 27th Annual Proceedings. American Association for Automotive Medicine; October 1983.
- Jones, I. S., “Analytical Reconstruction of 12 Staged Collisions Using the CRASH 2 and SMAC Programs” Proc. 25. AAAM, Louisville, KY; October 1979.
- Marquard, E.; “The Mechanics of Vehicle Collisions”; Automobiltechnische Zeitschrift, Vol. 64., No. 5, pp. 141-148; May 1962.
- Emori, R.; “Analytical Approach to Automobile Collisions” SAE paper No. 680016; Automotive Engineering Congress, Detroit, MI; January 8-12, 1968.
- Woolley, R.W. “The IMPAC Computer Program for Accident Reconstruction”. SAE 850254, Detroit, MI, February 1985, p.255.
- Strother, C. “Velocity Histories as an Accident Reconstruction Tool”, SAE 850249, Detroit, MI; February 1985, pp.159 ff.
- Carlson, L.; “Part 581-Bumper Standard Chevrolet Citation NHTSA No, 800125” Mobility Systems Report No. 581-MS-80-10-TR-10; June 1980.
- Struble, Don E,, et al; to be published.
- Federal Register; “Code of Federal Regulations” Parts 571.214, 571.212, 571.301.
- Woolley, R., Warner, C. and Tagg, M.; “Inaccuracies in the GRASK3 Program” SAE Paper No. 850255; February 1985.
- _____, Topcon, Instruction Manual, Geodetic Total Station GTS-3; 65 West Centruy Road, Paramus, New Jersey 07652, U.S.A.
- Smith, G. C.; Survey Conversion and Mapping Program (SCAMP); Collision Safety Engineering, Copyright 1984.
- Christetnsen, H. N.; Movie.BYU; Brigham Young University; 1983.