This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Charles F. Kettering and the Development of Tetraethyl Lead in the Context of Alternative Fuel Technologies
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
This paper discusses the technological and public health context of the 1921 discovery and subsequent development of the anti-knock gasoline additive tetraethyl lead in light of recently released General Motors correspondence files. The discovery has long been seen as a milestone of systematic research and a vital turning point in the development of modern high compression engines. The documents show that the choice of tetraethyl lead over other alternatives took place within the context of a complex controversy.
After leaded gasoline entered the market in 1923 - 24, a fatal refinery accident drew attention to the poisonous nature of the full strength additive and the potential public health risk from fuel containing the diluted additive. Public health advocates claimed that alternatives existed, but industry insisted that tetraethyl lead was the only additive that could be used. The controvery was never resolved because, until the early 1990s, virtually no primary documentary material was available in public archives. Recently released documents support the idea that the original motive for research leading to leaded gasoline was to fortify G. M. against oil shortages (then expected by the 1940s or 1950s) and raise engine compression ratios fo facilitate a transition to alternative fuels (particularly ethyl alcohol). This original motive was not strong enough to shift the balance toward alternative anti-knocks and was apparently discarded when oil supplies proved to be plentiful in the mid-1920s.
Recommended Content
Authors
Topic
Citation
Kovarik, B., "Charles F. Kettering and the Development of Tetraethyl Lead in the Context of Alternative Fuel Technologies," SAE Technical Paper 941942, 1994, https://doi.org/10.4271/941942.Also In
References
- Solberg Carl Oil Power NY New American Library 1976
- Rosner David Markowitz Gerald “A Gift of God?” Dying For Work: Workers Safety and Health in 20th Century America , Bloomington, Indiana Indiana University Press 1989 125
- Blair John M. The Control of Oil NY Vintage Books 1978 Sampson Anthony The Sevan Sisters: The Great Oil Companies and the World They Shaped NY Viking 1975 Ridgeway James Powering Civilization: the Complete Energy Reader NY Pantheon 1982 Yergin Daniel The Prize: The Epic Quest for Oil, Money & Power NY Simon & Schuster 1991
- Hughes Thomas P. “Inventors: The Problems They Choose, The Ideas They Have and the Inventions They Make,” Kelly Patrick et al. Technological Innovation: A Critical Review of Current Knowledge San Francisco San Francisco Press, Inc. 1979 177
- Hounshell David Smith John Science and Corporate Strategy: Du Pont R&D, 1902-1980 New York Cambridge University Press 1988 154 Pratt Joseph A. “Letting the Grandchildren Do It: Environmental Planning During the Ascent of Oil as the Major Energy Source,” The Public Historian 2 4 Fall 1980 35
- Robert Joseph C. Ethyl: A History of the Corporation and the People Who Made It Charlottesville, Va. University Press of Virginia 1983 122 123
- Williamson Harold et al. The American Petroleum Industry. The Age of Energy. 1899-1959 Evanston, III. Northwestern University 1963 414
- Leslie Stuart Boss Kettering New York Columbia University Press 1983 166
- Boyd T.A. Professional Amateur New York E.P. Dutton 1957 Young Rosamond Boss Ket New York Longmans, Green & Co. 1961 162
- Edgar Graham “Tetraethyl Lead,” paper to the American Chemical Society New York Sept. 3-7 1951 Ethyl Corp. Boyd T.A. “Pathfinding in Fuels and Engines,” Society of Automotive Engineers Transactions April 1950 182 183 Nickerson Stanton P. “Tetraethyl Lead: A Product of American Research,” Journal of Chemical Education 31 November 1954 567 Heron S.D. Development of Aviation Fuels . Cambridge, Mass. Harvard University Graduate School of Business Administration 1950 560
- Friedel Robert Israel Paul Edison's Electric Light: Biography of an Invention New Brunswick, N.J. Rutgers University Press 1987 249 Holmes Frederic Lawrence Lavoisier and the Chemistry of Life Madison, Wisconsin University of Wisconsin Press 1985 xv
- Boyd T. A. “The Early History of Ethyl Gasoline,” Report OC-83, Project # 11-3 Research Laboratory Division, GM Corp. Detroit Michigan June 8 1943 GMI Alumni Institute for Industrial History Flint, Mich. Kettering Charles “Transcript of Matter on the Story of Ethyl Gasoline,” dictated in Florida 1945 GMI Alumni Institute for Industrial History Flint, Mich. GMI Champlin Ralph C. Ethyl Corp. Public Relations Dept. “Historical Summary Ethyl Corp. 1923 - 1948,” Third Draft “Green Book,” Detroit 1951 GMI Howard Frank A. “History of the Ethyl Gasoline Corp.,” memo to Mr. William Benhem US Dept. of Justice April 21 1927 Defendants Trial Exhibit No. 274, U.S. v. E.I. Du Pont de Nemours and Co. 235 9 U.S. v du Pont Wescott N. P. Origins and Early History of the Tetraethyl Lead Business . June 9 1936 Du Pont Corp. Report No. D-1013, Longwood ms group 10 418 426 Hagley Museum & Library Wilmington, Del. Origins and Early History
- Boyd T. A. The Early History of Ethyl Gasoline . Report OC-83, Project # 11-3 Research Laboratory Division, GM Corp. Detroit Michigan June 8 1943 GMI Early History
- Hughes “Inventors and the Problems They Chose,” 177 “The Trail of the Arbutus,” Kettering Charles F. Ethyl Corp. or General Motors Aug. 29 1951 GMI
- “A Report of Fuel Research by the Research Division of the Dayton Metal Products Co. and the U.S. Bureau of Mines,” July 27 1918 Midgley unprocessed files GMI
- Jan 7 1918 Mar. 11 1919 GM Research Corp. Chemical Abstracts 13 1919 1636
- Oct. 4 1918 April 29 1924
- “A Report of Fuel Research,” July 27 1918 Midgley unprocessed files GMI
- Clements F.O. Talbott H.E. Feb. 4 1919 Midgley unprocessed files GMI
- April 16 1919 Trial transcript 3500 U.S. v. v du Pont
- Free Alcohol Hearings, US Senate Finance Committee 1906 59
- White David “The Unmined Supply of Petroleum in the United States,” Society of Automotive Engineers annual meeting Feb. 4-6 1919 Smith George Otis “Where the World Gets Oil and Where Will our Children Get It When American Wells Cease to Flow?” National Geographic Feb. 1920 202
- “Declining Supply of Motor Fuel,” Scientific American Mar. 8 1919 220
- Kettering Charles F. “Studying the Knocks,: How a Closer Knowledge of What Goes on In the Cylinder Might Solve the Problems of Fuel Supply,” Scientific American Oct. 11 1919 364
- 1936 Wescott N.P. Origins and Early History GMI
- 1826 1860 Internal Fire Warrenton, Pa. Society of Automotive Engineers 1989 81 Hardenberg Horst Samuel Morey and his Atmospheric Engine SP 922 Warrendale, Pa. SAE Feb. 1992 51
- Giebelhaus Augustus W. “Resistance to Long-Term Energy Transition: The Case of Power Alcohol in the 1930s,” American Association for the Advancement of Science Jan. 4 1979
- Bernton Hal Kovarik Bill Sklar Scott The Forbidden Fuel: Power Alcohol in the 20th Century New York Griffin 1982
- Kovarik Bill Fuel Alcohol: Energy and Environment in a Hungry World . London International Institute for Environment and Development 1982
- Scientific American . April 13 1918 339
- Dixon H.B. “Researches on Alcohol as an Engine Fuel,” SAEJournal , Dec. 1920 521
- Scientific American , Dec. 11 1920 593
- Boyd Early History 75 76
- Oct. 15 1920 July 16 1924
- Kettering Midgley Sept. 14 1920 Midgley files GMI
- Kettering Charles F. Trial transcript 3573 US v. du Pont
- Leslie Boss Kettering 155
- Early History . 54
- Boyd Early History , 60 61 70
- Boyd Early History 54
- Kettering C.F. “The Fuel Problem,” 1921 GMI
- Zimmerschied Kettering Feb. 27 1920 Kettering Zimmerschied March 3 1920 Kettering collection GMI
- Mar. 23 1926
- Hibbert Harold “The Role of the Chemist in Relation to the Future Supply of Liquid Fuel,” Journal of Industrial and Chemical Engineering 13 9 Sept. 1921 841
- Boyd Midgley July 8 1920 Midgley unprocessed files GMI
- “The Discussion” transcript of SAE meeting discussion Indianapolis Oct. 1921 Midgley unprocessed files GMI
- Midgley Thomas “Discussion of papers at semi-annual meeting.” SAE Journal Oct. 1921 269
- Clements F.O. Sept. 9 1921 Midgley unprocessed files GMI
- “To Learn the Truth about Leaded Gas,” Literary Digest April 18 1925 17 New York Times “Scientists to Pass on Tetra-Ethyl Gas,” New York Times May 20 1925 1 The Story of Ethyl Gasoline New York Ethyl Gasoline Corp. 1927 American Petroleum Institute Library Washington, D.C. Boyd T.A. “too much” 1960 Young Rosamond Boss Ket New York Longmans, Green & Co. 1961 1980 Lane John C. Ethyl Corp. “Gasoline and Other Motor Fuels,” Encyclopedia of Chemical Technology New York John Wiley & Sons 1980 656 August 25 December 7 1921
- Young Boss Ket Robert Ethyl 1924
- Hurd Ferris E. Attorney G.M. US v du Pont 7986
- Midgley Wood Joseph L. The Orange Tip Co. Feb. 9 1922 About 50 other identical letters are found in the Kettering collection unprocessed Midgley files GMI
- Midgley Kettering May 23 1922 Midgley unprocessed files GMI
- Midgley Thomas A. Boyd T.A. “Detonation Characteristics of Some Blended Motor Fuels,” SAE Journal . June 1922 451 June 1922 Midgley unprocessed files GMI
- Morrison Midgley July 25 1922 Kettering collection, unprocessed Midgley files GMI
- Midgley Thomas Boyd Thomas “The Application of Chemistry to the Conservation of Motor Fuels,” Industrial and Engineering Chemistry . Sept. 1922 850
- Wescott Origi ns and Early History 4
- Washington Post . July 24 1923
- Sparrow Stanwood W. “Fuels for High Compression Engines,” Report No. 232 U.S. Naval Advisory Committee for Aeronautics 1925
- Midgley Leighton B.G. Lt. Mar. 16 1923 Kettering collection, Unprocessed Midgley files GMI September 1925 Calendar H.L. et. al. “Dopes and Detonation,” Engineering , April 9 1926 475
- Midgley Kettering “Summary of Present Situation on Antiknock Material,” Nov. 20 1922 Factory Correspondence, unprocessed Midgley files GMI
- April 15 1922 Nov. 2 1926 Oct. 4 1922 July 20 1926
- Boyd, Early History 193
- Boyd, Early History 179
- Midgley Allen R.L. Dr. Sept. 9 1922 unprocessed Midgley files GMI
- Midgley Gilbert H.N. Jan 19 1923 unprocessed Midgley files GMI
- Boyd, Early History 164 170
- William M. Clark Stimson A. M. Oct. 11 1922 Stimson A. M. Dyer R. N. Oct. 13 1922 Dyer General Surgeon Oct. 18 1922 Roberts N. General Surgeon Nov. 13 1922 Cumming H.S. Du Pont Pierre Dec. 20 1922 Midgley Thomas Cumming Dec. 30 1922 US Public Health Service Record Group 90, National Archives Washington, D.C.
- Midgley Browne A.W. Dec. 2 1922 unprocessed Midgley files GMI
- Midgley Round G.A. Vacuum Oil Co. Feb. 14 1923 unprocessed Midgley files GMI
- Pratt Joseph A. “Letting the Grandchildren Do It,” 35 Rosner David Markowitz Gerald Dying For Work 123 Fieldner A.C. Bain Dr. Sept. 24 1923 Lind S.C. Fieldner Nov. 3 1923 Dept. of Interior and General Motors all in Record Group .70, 101869, File 725 US Bureau of Mines letters in file 182, General Classified Files 1923 US Bureau of Mines, National Archives Washington DC.
- Boyd, Early History . 268
- du Pont Irenee Sloan June 28 1924 Wescott Origins and Early History , 21
- du Pont Irenee Sloan Alfred Aug 29 1924 Wescott Origins and Early History ,
- “Midge” to “My dear Boss” Kettering March 2 1923 Factory Correspondence, unprocessed Midgley files GMI
- Testimony of Charles F. Kettering US v. Du Pont 3565
- du Pont P.S. du Pont Irenee March 24 1922 “Memo RE: Doping of Fuel,” Wescott Origins and Early History 9
- Bent Silas “Tetraethyl Lead Fatal to Makers,” The New York Times June 22 1925
- Ethyl Gasoline Corp. et al. v. United States, 309 U.S. 436 1940 Dept. of Justice records, National Archives Washington D.C. U.S. v. E.I. Du Pont de Nemours and Co. 126 F. Supp. 235 U.S. v du Pont 1952
- Testimony of W.F. Harrington, US v du Pont 6487
- Robert, 121
- Testimony of Alfred P. Sloan, US v. du Pont 2941
- Wescott Origins and Early History , 20
- Wescott Origins and Early History ,
- Testimony of W.F. Harrington, US v du Pont 648
- Memo in response to Wescott's Origins and Early History from Irenee du Pont June 29 1936 1852 U.S. v Du Pont
- Wescott Origins and Early History , 21
- Hurd Ferris closing statement, US v du Pont 7986
- “Mad Gas Kills One,” New York Times . Oct. 24 1924 1
- “Another Man Dies from Insanity Gas,” New York Times , Oct. 28 1924 1
- Trial testimony 2169 United States v. du Pont, US District Court Chicago Ill. Nov. 18 1952 235
- Wescott, Origins and Early History 22
- “An Episode Without Precedent,” New York Times Oct. 31 1924 18
- Rosner Markowitz “A Gift of God,” 122
- “No Reason for Abandonment,” New York Times Nov. 28 1924 20
- Hamilton Alice Reznikoff Paul Burnham Grace “Tetra Ethyl Lead,” Journal of the American Medical Association May 16 1925 1481 1486
- Testimony of Alfred Sloan, US v du Pont 2941
- Wescott, Origins and Early History , 21
- Hounshell David Smith John Science and Corporate Strategy: Du Pont R&D, 1902-1980 New York Cambridge University Press 1988 154
- Heron S.D. Development of Aviation Fuels . Cambridge, MA Harvard University Graduate School of Business Administration 1950 560
- Kovarik Bill Fuel Alcohol: Energy and Environment in a Hungry World London Earthscan 1982 62
- “European trip,” Nov. 30 1924 GMI
- 1937
- Testimony, Charles Kettering US v Du Pont 3624
- “Experiences with Iron Carbonyl in Germany,” IG Farben, Government Trial Exhibit No. 722, US v du Pont 1953
- Edgar Graham “Tetraethyl Lead,” paper to the American Chemical Society New York Sept. 3-7 1951 Ethyl Corp.
- Fulmer E.I. Hixon R.M. Christensen L.M. Coover W.F. “The Use of Alcohol in Motor Fuels: Progress Report Number I, A Survey of the Use of Alcohol as Motor Fuel in Various Foreign Countries,” May 1 1933 unpublished manuscript Iowa State University archives
- Du Pont Sloan June 26 1925 Government Trial Exhibit 715, US v du Pont, transcript 3631
- Du Pont Sloan June 26 1925 Government Trial Exhibit 715, US v du Pont, transcript 3631 Nickerson “Tetraethyl Lead.” Note that I.G. Farben was a conglomerate of German chemical companies which included BASF, or Badische Analin and Soda Fabrik, and seven other firms which had merged all assets 1924
- Smith William H. Ford Motor Co. Winslow C.E.A. August 15 1925 notes the manufacture of 60,000 gallons per month at the Farben plant. C.E.A. Winslow Papers Yale University archives
- “Liquid Fuels of the Future,” Industrial & Engineering Chemistry . 17 6 April 1925 334 “Synthetic Marvels Arouse Scientists.” New York Times . May 8 1925 22
- “Synthetic Marvels Arouse Scientists,” New York Times . May 8 1925
- Fox Homer S. “Alcohol Motor Fuels,” Supplementary Report to World Trade in Gasoline , Minerals Division, Bureau of Domestic & Foreign Commerce, Trade Promotion Series Monograph No. 20 Washington, D.C Dept. of Commerce May 15 1925
- Wescott, Origins and Early History . March 28 1925
- Midgley Thomas A. Boyd T.A. “Detonation Characteristics of Some Blended Motor Fuels,” Society of Automotive Engineers Journal . June 1922 451 April June July August 1925 Industrial & Chemical Engineering May 1925 Society of Automotive Engineers Journal “Power Alcohol from Tubers and Roots,” SAE Journal May 1925 546
- Sloan Du Pont March 28 1925 Government Trial Exhibit No. 678, U.S. v. du Pont et al. US District Court Chicago 1953
- Roberts, Eihyl 124
- “Work on New Type of Auto and Fuel,” New York Times August 7 1925 “New Auto, Fuel to Save Costs are Announced,” United Press August 6 1925
- Nov. 1 1924 “in deference to public opinion” according to Wescott, Origins and Early History 25
- U.S. Public Health Service Proceedings of a Conference to Determine Whether or Not There is a Public Health Question in the Manufacture. Distribution or use of Tetraethyl Lead Gasoline. PHS Bulletin No. 158 Washington, D.C U.S. Treasury Dept. August 1925 6 PHS Conference
- PHS Conference 106
- PHS Conference 108
- PHS Conference 99
- “U.S. Board Asks Scientists to Find New Doped Gas,”' N.Y. World . May 22 1925 1
- Clayden Ludlow Chief Engineer of Sun Oil Co. “Predicts Double Gasoline Mileage,” New York Sun Jan. 20 1926
- Howard Kettering Sept. 25 1925 Unprocessed Kettering files “Cyclo-Gas” file GMI 1928 1931 Boyd TA “Remarks on Ethyl Gas as Made to the G.M. Technical Committee,” March 19 1931 GMI
- Kettering Archives oral history project, interview Howard Frank A. Sept. 14 1960 GMI
- Niragu Jerome Sept. 1991
- Sayers R.R. Fieldner A.C. et al. “Experimental Studies on the Effect of Ethyl Gasoline and its Combustion Products,” U.S. Bureau of Mines Washington, D.C. U.S.GPO 1927 12
- Winslow C.E.A. “Recommendations for the Drawing Up of a Report on the Use of Lead Tetra-Ethyl Gasoline by the Public,” memo to P.H.S. committee members Dec. 31 1925 Yale University Library, New Haven, Ct.
- Smith W.H. Winslow C.E.A. Box 101 Folder 1800, C.E.A. Winslow papers Yale University Sept. 1925
- “The Use of Tetraethyl Lead Gasoline in its Relation to Public Health,” Public Health Bulletin No. 163, U.S. Public Health Service, Treasury Dept. Washington GPO 1926
- Young Angela Nugent “Interpreting the Dangerous Trades: Worker's Health in America and the Career of Alice Hamilton, 1910-1935,” Brown University 1982
- “Public Health Aspects of Increasing Tetraethyl Lead Content in Motor Fuel,” Report of the Advisory Committee on Tetraethyl Lead to the Surgeon General, PHS publication No. 712 Washington, D.C. Public Health Service March 30 1959 2
- Bernton, The Forbidden Fuel
- “May Take Years to Find Good Gasoline Substitute,” New York Times Oct. 25 14 Associated Press “Gas Substitutes Held Uneconomical,” Detroit Free Press October 2 1925
- Mott CS. Kettering Oral History Project, Interviewed by T.A. Boyd October 19 1960 GMI