This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Estimating Crush Stiffness when Reconstructing Vehicle Accidents
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Energy equivalence calculations from damage deformation have evolved through the years as a principal analysis technique for the accident reconstructionist. The foundation for this analytical technique is the crash test data that has accumulated over the last few decades for specific vehicles crashed into or by barriers. During a reconstruction, the problem that often arises is that crash test data is not available for one of the vehicles involved in the collision. In such a situation, it is customary to use crush stiffness values from vehicles of similar wheel base and weight or abandon the crush energy approach altogether. Alternate approaches to calculating vehicle speeds prior to impact, however, often require the use of other undesirable uncertainties. The ideal situation would be for the reconstructionist to have the facility in each case of utilizing crush energy techniques either as a direct method of analysis or as a check on other methods of choice, such as momentum analysis and estimates based on experience. In the method discussed in this paper, the stiffness coefficients for a vehicle that does not have crash test data available are obtained from the equivalence of the principal force between impacting vehicles. In conjunction with a historical review of the damage deformation analysis, appropriate analytical expressions for the principal force are derived based on the stiffnesses of the opposing vehicle for which crash test data does exist. In this way, crush stiffnesses can be obtained for vehicles that have not been tested, and those stiffnesses used in the reconstruction. Furthermore, with this approach, the degree of involvement of hard points such as wheels and suspension members for side impacts, becomes apparent. The analysis some times dictates the use of stiffness coefficients that are higher than those found in the tabular data. This paper presents the analytical basis of the underlying principal force equivalence, the equations utilized, and examples of the approach in reconstructing vehicle accidents.
Recommended Content
Technical Paper | A Method for Quantifying Vehicle Crush Stiffness Coefficients |
Technical Paper | Heavy Truck Rollover Crashworthiness: Testing Methods and Development of Recommended Practices |
Technical Paper | Crush Energy in Accident Reconstruction |
Citation
Hull, W. and Newton, B., "Estimating Crush Stiffness when Reconstructing Vehicle Accidents," SAE Technical Paper 930898, 1993, https://doi.org/10.4271/930898.Also In
References
- Emori R. “Mechanics of Automobile Collisions,” First International Conference on Vehicle Mechanics Wayne State University Detroit, Michigan July 1968
- Campbell K. “Energy Basis for Collision Severity,” S.A.E. Paper 740565 1974
- McHenry R. “User's Manual for the CRASH Computer Program,” NTIS #PB252115 February 1976
- Strother C. Wooley R James M. “A Comparison Between NHTSA Crash Test Data and CRASH 3 Frontal Stiffness Coefficients,” S.A.E. Paper 900101 February 1990
- Hargen R. Day T. “Vehicle Data Sources for Accident Reconstruction,” S.A.E. Paper 880070 February 1988
- Accident Reconstruction Journal 2 1 January/February 1990
- Day T. Private communication 1991
- Fonda A. “CRASH Extended for Desk and Handheld Computers,” S.A.E. Paper 870044 February 1987
- Hargens R. Day T. “Vehicle Crush Stiffness Coefficients for Model Years 1970-1984,” EDC Library Ref. No. 1043, August” 1987
- McHenry R.R. “Extensions and Refinements of the CRASH Computer Program Part II, User's Manual for the CRASH Computer,” DOT HS-801838 February 1976
- Accident Reconstruction Journal 2 3 May/June 1990
- Smith R. Noga T. “Accuracy and Sensitivity of CRASH,” S.A.E. Paper 821169 presented at the 26th Stapp Car Crash Conference 1982
- Tumbas N. Smith R. “Measuring Protocol for Quantifying Vehicle Damage from an Energy Basis Point of View,” S.A.E. Paper 880072 February 1972