This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
A Parametric Study of Vehicle Interior Geometry, Delta-V, and instrument Panel Stiffness on Knee Injury and Upper Kinetic Energy
Technical Paper
99SC13
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Previous experimental and theoretical studies on isolated human knees have shown that increasing the contact area over the knee during blunt impact can prevent serious knee injury (i.e. joint fracture). Because large contact areas are typically associated with lower stiffness impact interfaces, this suggests that instrument panels could provide some protection to the knee during a car accident. Further, the knee-to-IP contact is one of the first contact events which occur during a head-on crash, thus, one optimal scenario might be to dissipate as much energy as possible at the knee without causing serious knee injury. This would help minimize the kinetic energy in the upper body, possibly reducing the need for more aggressive countermeasures (i.e. air bags) later in the impact event. Our objective in the current study was to determine how different car interior geometries and crash pulses would affect specific occupant responses during a head-on car crash. To study a ‘worst-case scenario’, the occupant was unbelted and there was no airbag. An experimentally validated MADYMO-Pamcrash model was used to study the effect of the following ‘input parameters’ on the risk of knee injury and the kinetic energy of the upper body: instrument panel stiffness, seat height, knee-instrument panel distance, knee flexion angle, toe-pan angle, Instrument panel angle, and crash pulse delta-V. it was found that the risk of knee injury was most sensitive to the IP stiffness, crash pulse delta-V, and the precrash distance between the knee and IP. The kinetic energy of the upper body, however, was sensitive to the seat height and initial knee flexion angle, as well as the delta-V and initial distance between the knee and IP. Regression models were developed which predicted the MADYMO-Pamcrash femur loads, knee contact areas, and upper body kinetic energy as a function of the input parameters described above. These statistical models provide the advantage of a first generation estimate of some key occupant responses without expending resources associated with computer modeling or experimental tests. These data may prove helpful in the future design of multi-component injury prevention systems (air bags and knee bolsters) because one may anticipate specific loads, energies, and injury risks associated with the crash event. In conclusion, the current study identifies key vehicle design and crashworthiness parameters which affect the risk of knee injury and the kinetic energy of the upper body.
Recommended Content
| Technical Paper | Factors Influencing Knee Restraint |
| Technical Paper | Structural Instrument Panel: Synthesis Approach |
| Technical Paper | Acetabulum Injury Investigation of Proposed US-NCAP in OI Mode |
Authors
Citation
Atkinson, P., Benny, J., Sambatur, K., Gudipaty, K. et al., "A Parametric Study of Vehicle Interior Geometry, Delta-V, and instrument Panel Stiffness on Knee Injury and Upper Kinetic Energy," SAE Technical Paper 99SC13, 1999, https://doi.org/10.4271/99SC13.Also In
References
- Adili, A Bhandari, M. Lachowski, R. Kwok, D. Dunlop, R. 1999 Organ injuries associated with femoral fractures: implications for severity of injury in motor vehicle collisions J. Trauma 46 386 91
- Atkinson, P. 1998 A stress based damage criterion to predict articular joint injury from subfracture trauma Ph.D.dissertation Michigan State University
- Atkinson, P. Garcia, J. Ali, H. Altiero, N. Haut, R. 1998 Human knee impact injury thresholds and locations vary with flexion angle and impact interface CDC injury Prevention injury Prevention through Biomechanics Symp. 127 144
- Atkinson, P. Atkinson, T. Haut, R. Eusebi, C. Maripudi, V. Sambatur, K. 1998 Development of injury criteria for human surrogates to address current trends in knee-to-instrument panel injuries 42 nd Stapp Car Crash Conference 13 31
- Atkinson, P. Garcia, J. Altiero, N. Haut, R. 1997 The influence of impact interface on human knee injury: implications for instrument panel design and the lower extremity injury criterion 41 st Stapp Car Crash Conf. 167 180
- Atkinson, P. Haut, R. Eusebi, C. Hill, T. 1999 Application of a Knee Injury Criteria for the Hybrid III Dummy to Address a Variety of Car Crash and Restraint Scenarios International Congress and Exposition :paper 1999-01-0710
- Atkinson, T. Atkinson, P. Buetow, M. Bruining, D Swann, K. Haut, R. 1998 A retrospective study of unintentional knee injuries The Centers for Disease Control and Injury Prevention Injury Prevention through Biomechanics Symp. 91 101
- Backaitis, S.H. Hicks, M.E. Prasad, P. Laituri, T. Nadeau, J. 1995 Variability of Hybrid III Clearance Dimensions within the FMVSS 208 and NCAP Vehicle Test Fleets and the Effects of Clearance Dimensions on Dummy Impact of Responses SAE paper no. 952710
- Bonello, K.J. 1992 Occupant Energy Management technique for Restrain System Analysis and Design Understanding the Physics of the System Worldwide Passenger car Conference and Exposition : SAE paper no. 922083
- Manary, M.A. Reed, M.P. Flannagan, C.A.C. Schneider, L.W. 1998 ATD Positioning Based On Driver Posture and Postion 42 nd Stapp Car Crash Conference : paper 983163
- Melvin, J Stalnaker, R Alem, N Benson, J Mohan, D 1975 Impact Response and Tolerance of the Lower Extremities 19 th Stapp Car Crash Conf. 543 559
- Miller, T. Martin, P. Crandall, J. 1995 Costs of lower limb injuries in highway crashes Proceedings of the international Conf. On Pelvic and Lower Extremity Injuries 47 57
- Nagel, D. Burton, D. Manning, J. 1977 The dashboard knee injury Clin Orthop 126 203 8
- Patrick, L Kroell, C. Mertz, H 1965 Forces on the human body in simulated Crashes 9 th Stapp Car Crash Conf 237 259
- Powell, W Ojala, S Advani, S Martin, R 1975 Cadaver Femur Responses to Longitudinal impacts 19 th Stapp Car Crash Conf 561 579
- Seyer, J. 1997 Lower limb injuries to passenger car occupants Accid. Anal. And Prev. 29 785 791
- Viano, DC Stalnaker, RL 1980 Mechanisms of Femoral Fracture J of Biom. 13 701 15
- Viano, D 1977 Considerations for a femur injury criterion 21st Stapp Car Crash Conference 445 473
- Viano, D. Culver, C. Haut, R. Melvin, J. Bender, M. Culver, R. Levine, R. 1978 Bolster impacts to the knee and tibia of human cadavers and an anthropomorphic dummy 22 nd Stapp Car Crash Conference 403 428
- Newberry, W Haut, R 1996 The effects of subfracture impact loading on the patellofemoral joint in a rabbit model 40th Stapp Car Crash Conference 149 159