This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Comparative Studies of Dummy and Human Body Models Behavior in Frontal and Lateral Impact Conditions
Published October 10, 1999 by The Stapp Association in United States
Annotation ability available
In the past, many studies have been dedicated to the comparison of dummies and human body behavior in different impact conditions. However, the complex boundary conditions generated by a complete restraint system render it difficult to compare both human surrogates in a car environment. Furthermore, the great dispersion among car occupants is an additional difficulty which is difficult to overcome with experimental studies, Computer simulation, as far as a validated human body model is available, gives a unique possibility to assess the influence of some restraint parameters, whilst all remaining parameters are unchanged.
To this end, a 3D finite element human body model validated in many different impact configurations against a large number of biomechanical corridors was used. In order to compare responses, models of Hybrid III and Eurosid 1 dummies were also used. Three typical impact configurations were chosen, both frontal and lateral, using the currently most advanced restraint systems with belt load limiter, pretensioner, knee bolster, frontal and lateral air-bags and pelvis door padding. A comparative study was then carried out by varying some of the restraint system parameters.
This comparative study highlighted significant differences between both human body and dummy models responses in a vehicle crash environment. The results showed that the human body model is more sensitive than the dummy models to the modification of some restraint system parameters such as the load limiter level or the air-bag pressure. Furthermore, as it was done previously by different authors, it was noticed that the deflection criterion was questionable in some situations. However, the dummy models were able to give reasonable trends in most situations and verified that the currently most advanced restraint systems are well optimized with regard to the current biomechanical knowledge.
CitationBaudrit, P., Hamon, J., Song, E., Robin, S. et al., "Comparative Studies of Dummy and Human Body Models Behavior in Frontal and Lateral Impact Conditions," SAE Technical Paper 99SC05, 1999, https://doi.org/10.4271/99SC05.
- Lizée, E Robin, S. al Besnault, B. al Development of a 3D Finite Element Model of the Human Body Proceedings of the 42th Stapp Car Crash Conference 1998 Paper n° 983152
- Lizée, E. al Song, E. al Finite element model of the human thorax validated in frontal, oblique and lateral impacts :a tool to evaluate new restraint systems Proceedings of the International IRCOBI Conference on the biomechanics of impact 1998
- European BRITE DUMOCS Project Final report on Fine HIII dummy model, version 1.0 1995
- Song, E. Mack, P. Tarrière, C. al Finite Element Simulation of the Occupant/Belt Interaction : Chest and Pelvis Deformation Belt Sliding and Submarining Proceedings of the 37th Stapp Car Crash Conference 1993 paper n° 933108
- Horsch, J.D. Melvin, J.W. Viano, D.C. Mertz, H.J. Thoracic Injury Assessment of Belt Restraint Systems Based on Hybrid III Chest Compression Proceedings of the 35th Stapp Car Crash Conference 1991 Paper n° 912895
- Foret-Bruno, J.Y. al Bendjellal, F. al Phalempin al Thoracic Injury Risk in Frontal Car Crashes with Occupant Restrained with Belt Load Limiter Proceedings of the 42th Stapp Car Crash Conference 1998 Paper n° 983166
- European BRITE DUMOCS Project Final report on Eurosid 1 dummy model, version 2 .0 1995
- Yoganandan, N. Skrade, D. Pintar, F. A. Reinartz, J. Sances, A. Thoracic deformation contour in a frontal impact SAE Paper N° 912891 , Proceedings of the 35 th Stapp Car Crash Conference 1991
- Kallieris, D. Stein, K. M. Mattern, R. Morgan, R. Eppinger, R. The performance of active and Passive Driver Restraint Systems in Simulated Frontal Collisions SAE Paper N° 942216 , Proceedings of the 38 th Stapp Car Crash Conference 1994
- Kallieris, D. Rizzeti, A. Matern, R. Morgan, R. Eppinger, R. Keenan, L. On the synergism of the driver air-bag and the three point belt in frontal collisions SAE Paper N° 952700 , Proceedings of the 39 th Stapp Car Crash Conference 1995
- Neathery, R. F. Analysis of chest impact response data and scaled performance recommendations Paper N° 741188 , Proceedings of the 18 th Stapp Car Crash Conference 1974