This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
THE COMPATIBILITY OF MINI CARS IN TRAFFIC ACCIDENTS
Published May 31, 1998 by National Highway Traffic Safety Administration in United States
Annotation ability available
The compatibility problems of the mini car in car-to-car frontal collision and car-pedestrian accident are discussed using accident data and computer simulations.
In our analysis of the accident data in Japan, the number of fatalities was investigated using the vehicle masses and classes. It was found that the cars with identical mass are most compatible since the injuries per accident are minimal and injury risks to the driver in both cars are the same. The analysis of the car class indicated that the mini car and the sports utility vehicle are the most incompatible car types, with low and high aggressivity, respectively.
Our accident analysis in the present study shows that the safety of mini cars is the key point in achieving the compatibility in Japan. Computer simulations using MADYMO were carried out of crashes of mini car into a rigid wall and into a large car. It was found that either stiffening mini car with an optimized restraint system or modifying the large car with additional crush space can reduce the injury risk to the driver in the mini car.
The analysis of car-pedestrian accidents in Japan shows that the mini car has higher aggressivity in relation to the pedestrian than other bonnet-type cars. Computer simulation revealed that the head velocity of the pedestrian at impact is high since the pedestrian head contacts the body of the mini car in the early phase.
CitationMizuno, K. and Kajzer, J., "THE COMPATIBILITY OF MINI CARS IN TRAFFIC ACCIDENTS," SAE Technical Paper 986063, 1998.
- Appel, H. Ni, J. Deter, T. “Grenzen der Passive Sichrheit von Leichten Fahrzeugen” 1994 235 238
- Appel, H. “Compatibility Guideline for Passive Safety, for Active Safety and Even for the Total Transportation System” FISITA1996 1996
- Buzeman D. G. “Car-to-Car and Single Car Crash Compatibility: Individual Effects of Mass, Structure, Stiffness and Geometry” 91-7197-536-5 Chalmers University of Technology 1997
- Evans, L. “Driver Fatalities Versus Car Mass Using a New Exposure Approach” Accident Analysis & Prevention 16 1984 19 36
- Evans, L. Frick, M. C. “Mass Ratio and Relative Driver Fatality Risk in Two-Vehicle Crashes” Accident Analysis & Prevention 25 1993 213 224
- Evans, L. “Driver Injury and Fatality Risk in Two-Car Crashes Versus Mass Ratio Inferred Using Newtonian Mechanics” Accident Analysis & Prevention 26 5 1994 609 616
- Frei, P. Kaeser, R. Hafner, R. Schmid, M. Dragon, A. Wingeier, L. Muser, M. H. Niedere, P. F. Waltz, F. H. “Crashworthiness and Compatibility of Low Mass Vehicles in Collisions” SAE Paper 970122 1997
- Hollowell, W. T. Gabler, H. C. “NHTSA's Vehicle Aggressivity and Compatibility Program” 15th ESV 1996
- IRF “World Road Statistics” Geneva International Road Federation 1995
- Ishikawa, H. Yamazaki, K. Ono, K. Sasaki, A. “Current Situation of Pedestrian Accidents and Research into Pedestrian Protection in Japan” 13th ESV 1991
- Ishikawa, H. “Kinematics of Automobile Collision - Analytical Formulas for One-Dimensional Impact” Journal of JARI 12 1990 25 32
- Ishikawa, H. Kajzer, J. Schroeder, G. “Computer Simulation of Impact Response of the Human Body in Car-Pedestrian Accidents” SAE Paper 933129 1993
- Ishikawa, H. Digges K. Ennis, J. “Restitution Coefficients and Delta-V in Offset Frontal Collisions” Proceedings of JSAE Autumn Convention 1995
- ITARDA “The Relation between Traffic Accidents, Driver and Vehicle” Research Report 1996a
- ITARDA “Report of Accident Investigation and Analysis in 1996” 1996b
- Joksh, H. C. “Velocity Change and Fatality Risk in a Crash - A Rule of Thumb” Accident Analysis & Prevention 25 1993 103 104
- Kaeser, R. Walz F. H. Brunner, A. “Collision Safety of a Hard Shell Low Mass Vehicle” IRCOBI 1992
- Kaeser, R. Muser, M. Spiess, O. Frei, P. Guenat J. M. Wingeier, L. “Passive Safety Potential of Low Mass Vehicles” IRCOBI 1995
- Matsumoto, H. Sakaida, M. Kurimoto, K. “A Parametric Evaluation of Vehicle Crash Performance” SAE Paper 900465 1990
- Maurer, D. Thompson, G. M. Muller, R. Graffe, M. Weyersberg, A “Safety Concepts for Very Small Vehicles, Example: Opel MAXX” 15th ESV 1996
- Mizuno, K. Umeda, T. Yonezawa, H. “The Relationship Between Car Size and Occupant Injury in Traffic Accidents in Japan” SAE Paper 970123 1997
- Mizuno, K. Kajzer, J. “The Compatibility Problems in Collisions Analyzed Using Accident Data” Proceedings of JSAE Spring Convention 1997
- Morris, A. Thomas, P. Taylor A. M. Wallace, W. A. “Mechanisms of Fractures in Ankle and Hind-Foot Injuries to Front Seat Car Occupants” SAE Paper 973328 1997
- NHTSA “Report on International Harmonized Research Agenda” Proceedings of 15th ESV 1996
- Sakurai, T. Aoki, T. “On the Safety Body Structure of Finite Element Method Analysis” 12th ESV 1989
- Tarrière, C. “Accident Research and Experimental Data Useful for an Understanding of the Influence of Car Structural Incompatibility on the Risk of Accident Data” 14th ESV 1994
- Tarrière “Compatibility Issues and Vulnerable Uses” Crashworthiness of Transportation Systems: Structural Impact and Occupant Protection Kluwer Academic Publishers 1997 139 170
- Ventre, P. “Homogeneous Safety Amid Heterogeneous Car Population” 3rd ESV 1972
- Ventre, P. “Proposal for Test Evaluation of Compatibility Between Very Different Passenger Cars” 4th ESV 1973
- Waltz, F. H. Kaeser R. Nieder, P. “Occupant and Exterior Safety of Low Mass Cars (LMC)” IRCOBI 1991
- Yang, J. “Injury Biomechanics in Car-Pedestrian Collisions” 91-7197-527-6 Chalmers University of Technology Göteborg 1997