This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Economic, Environmental and Energy Life-Cycle Assessment of Coal Conversion to Automotive Fuels in China
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
A life-cycle assessment (LCA) has been developed to help compare the economic, environmental and energy (EEE) impacts of converting coal to automotive fuels in China. This model was used to evaluate the total economic cost to the customer, the effect on the local and global environments, and the energy efficiencies for each fuel option. It provides a total accounting for each step in the life cycle process including the mining and transportation of coal, the conversion of coal to fuel, fuel distribution, all materials and manufacturing processes used to produce a vehicle, and vehicle operation over the life of the vehicle. The seven fuel scenarios evaluated in this study include methanol from coal, byproduct methanol from coal, methanol from methane, methanol from coke oven gas, gasoline from coal, electricity from coal, and petroleum to gasoline and diesel. The LCA results for all fuels were compared to gasoline as a baseline case.
Gasoline and diesel fuels derived from petroleum are the lowest cost options. No single coal-derived fuel technology is found to provide the best alternative in terms of all three aspects of energy, the environment and economics. In the near-term, the production of methanol from coal and coke oven gas, supplemented by co-production of methanol from the more than 1,000 ammonia plants in China, is attractive on a regional basis. Although the cost of methanol fuel is higher than that of gasoline or diesel, it is the most attractive of the coal-based fuel options at this time. Coal-based methanol fuels can be made more attractive to the consumer through appropriate subsidies or taxes. The EEE data suggests that electric vehicles, even with advanced nickel metal hydride batteries, are not presently attractive because of high vehicle cost, low energy efficiency and high life-cycle emissions of sulfur dioxide and particulate pollutants.
Recommended Content
Authors
Topic
Citation
Kreucher, W., Han, W., Schuetzle, D., Qiming, Z. et al., "Economic, Environmental and Energy Life-Cycle Assessment of Coal Conversion to Automotive Fuels in China," SAE Technical Paper 982207, 1998, https://doi.org/10.4271/982207.Also In
References
- Little A.D. Full Fuel Cycle Emissions Model Midwest Research Institute, Inc. Hybrid Propulsion Systems Development Program
- AQIRP (Air Quality Improvement Research Program) SAE SP-920, SP-1000 and SP-1117
- Asia Society Workshop on “Asia's Energy Challenges in the 21 st Century May 1 1998
- “China Statistical Yearbook 1996” China Statistical Publishing House 1996
- “Coal and Synfuels Technology” Pasha Publications Arlington, VA 1989
- Coal-Based Syn-liquified Fuels Xinrong Qian et. al. Shanxi Coal Chemistry Institute of Chinese Academy December 1996
- DOE Assessment of Cost and Benefit of Flexible and Alternative Fuel Use in U.S. Transportation Sector 1991
- Economic, Environmental and Energy Life Cycle Assessment of Coal Conversion to Automotive Fuels in Shanxi Province and other Coal Rich Regions in China - Final Report Executive Summary July 1997
- EEE Study on 300,000 Ton/year Methanol from Coal Lidao Huang et. al. Planning Institute of Chemical Industry Ministry January 1997
- EEE Study on 10,000 Ton/year Co-Producing Methanol Project Lidao Huang et. al. Planning Institute of Chemical Industry Ministry January 1997
- EEE Study on Petroleum Extraction, Transportation and Handling Processing Petrochemical Industry Institute of China Petrochemical Industry Group December 1996
- Environment and Energy Assessment and Explanation of Coal Conversion to Vehicle Fuels in China Coal-Rich Regions Ruilan Zhao Aing Zhang Dengqing Liu et. al. February 1997
- EPA Life Cycle Assessment: Inventory Guidelines and Principles 1993
- Fisher Tropsch Process for Gasoline to Coal Modified Shanxi Coal Chemistry Institute
- Kuo, J.C. W. “Gasification and Indirect Liquefaction Science and Technology of Coal and Coal Utilization Cooper B. R. Ellingson W.A. New York Plenum Press 1984
- Xin Li Wenbin Yang “Turning Bane Into Boon,” Window Magazine June 7 1996
- Life Cycle Assessment Report on 300,000 Ton/year Methanol from Coal Bed Gas in Shanxi Province Tainzhong Bai et. al. Hautai Engineering Company (No. 2 Design Institute of Chemical Industry Ministry) January 1997
- Life Cycle Assessment Report on 60,000 Ton/year Methanol from Coke Oven Gas in Shanxi Province Tianzhong Bai et. al. Hautai Engineering Company (No. 2 Design Institute of Chemical Industry Ministry) January 1997
- Life Cycle Assessment Report on 2'300MW Coal-Burning Power Plant Xinrong Qian et. al. Shanxi Coal Chemistry Institute of Chinese Academy of Science December 1996
- Life Cycle EEE Analysis of FFV Fuel Transportation Establishment Lianbao Jiang Shaoping Fang et. al. Automobile Office of Shanxi Province March 1996
- Life Cycle EEE Assessment Report on Coal Transportation and Handling Plant Xinrong Qian et. al. Shanxi Coal Chemistry Institute of Chinese Academy of Science December 1996
- Lumpkin, R.E. “Recent Progress in the Direct Liquefaction of Coal” Science 239 873 877 1988
- National Research Council (NRC) “Assessment of Technology for the Liquefaction of Coal,” National Academy of Sciences Press Washington D.C. 1977
- Proceedings of the 1997 Total Life Cycle Conference Life Cycle Management and Assessment CID 1 1997
- Schuetzle, D. et. al. “China Automotive Technology Workshop Recommendations,” Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 1996
- Schumacher, W.J. “The Economics of Alternative Fuels” SRI International Project No. 6998 Menlo Park, CA 1989
- Sullivan, J.L. et. al. “Life Cycle Energy Analysis for Automobiles,” Proceedings of the 1995 Total Life Cycle Conference SAE International Warrendale, PA October 1995
- U.S. Council for Automotive Research “United States Advanced Battery Consortium,” USCAR Southfield, MI 1993
- U.S. Dept. of Energy US-China Energy and Environment Cooperation Initiative October 1997
- U.S. EPA “Milestones in Automotive Emissions Control,” Environmental Protection Agency August 1994
- Weimin, C. “Liquefied Coal Effort Goes Global,” China Daily Business Weekly May 19-25 1996
- Yang, F. Duan, Z. et. al. “A Review of China's Energy Policy” Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory, University of California December 1994