This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
A Case Study for Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) as an Energy Decision Making Tool: The Production of Fuel Ethanol from Various Feedstocks
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Life Cycle Analysis (LCA) considers the key environmental impacts for the entire life cycle of alternative products or processes in order to select the best alternative. An ideal LCA would be an expensive and time consuming process because any product or process typically involves many interacting systems and a considerable amount of data must be analysed for each system. Practical LCA methods approximate the results of an ideal analysis by setting limited analysis boundaries and by accepting some uncertainty in the data values for the systems considered. However, there is no consensus in the LCA field on the correct method of selecting boundaries or on the treatment of data set uncertainty. This paper demonstrates a new method of selecting system boundaries for LCA studies and presents a brief discussion on applying Monte Carlo Analysis to treat the uncertainty questions in LCA. These techniques are demonstrated using an LCA which compares ethanol fuel produced from three different biological feedstocks. The methodology applied and the results presented by this work will be of primary interest to LCA practitioners, and the ethanol industry.
Alternative automotive fuels are of significant interest to industries and governments worldwide as concern over the emissions of greenhouse gases rises. Combustion of transportation fuels is the single largest source of greenhouse gas emissions in Canada. Additional concerns of fuel production and use include emissions of ground level ozone precursors and acid forming emissions. Ethanol, used as a fuel additive or as neat fuel, is an alternative to conventional gasoline. However, as this work shows, the numerous feedstocks used in producing ethanol differ greatly with respect to their life cycle environmental performance. The paper compares the environmental effects of producing ethanol in Canada using three potential feedstocks: corn, wheat, and poplar trees. The results show corn ethanol to produce 700 kg CO2 Equivalents per 1000 liters of ethanol produced, wheat ethanol to result in 760 kg of CO2 Equiv., and ethanol from poplar trees through a strong acid process to emit 860 kg of CO2. The relative importance of production, transportation, processing and combustion is compared for each ethanol feedstock.
Recommended Content
Ground Vehicle Standard | Alternative Automotive Fuels |
Technical Paper | Gasohol: Technical, Economic, or Political Panacea? |
Technical Paper | Life Cycle Value Assessment (LCVA) Comparison of Conventional Gasoline and Reformulated Gasoline |
Authors
Topic
Citation
Raynolds, M., Checkel, M., and Fraser, R., "A Case Study for Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) as an Energy Decision Making Tool: The Production of Fuel Ethanol from Various Feedstocks," SAE Technical Paper 982205, 1998, https://doi.org/10.4271/982205.Also In
References
- Proceedings - Ethanol in the 21st Century, New Sources, New Uses Sacramento, California April 1-3 1998
- Corn Production, Utilization and Environmental Assessment - A Review Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada, Ottawa 1996
- Arkenol
- Commercial Alcohols
- Coxworth, E. Study of the Effects of Cropping and Tillage Systems on the Carbon Dioxide Released by Manufacturing Inputs to Western Canadian Agriculture: Identification of Methods to Reduce Carbon Dioxide Emission 1 2 3 Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada 1995
- Coxworth, E. Hultgreen, G. Leduc, P. Net Carbon Balance Effects of Low Disturbance Seeding Systems on Fuel, Fertilizer, Herbicide and Machinery Usage in Western Canadian Agriculture 1994
- Deluchi, M.A. Emissions of Greenhouse Gases from the Use of Transportation Fuels and Electricity 1 2 Center for Transportation Research Energy Systems Division, Argonne National Laboratory 1991 1993
- Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Compilation of Air Pollutant Emission Factors Volume 1: Stationary Point and Area Sources Office of Air Quality EPA July 1993
- Ledwell, T. Scoping Study for a Fuel-Ethanol Plant in the Timiskaming Region Eco-Cinergie Inc. 1992
- Mohawk Oil 1998
- Monenco AGRA Inc. Development of a Database for Full Fuel Cycle Emissions From Electric Power Generation in Alberta The Full Fuel Cycle Emissions Analysis Industry/Government Consortium 1994
- Natural Resources Canada Canada's Energy Outlook 1996 2020 NRCan Ottawa 1997
- Raynolds, M. Macintosh, R. Finigan, K. Opportunities in Ethanol - Opportunity Assessment and Economic Development Strategy Pembina Institute for the Municipality of Drayton Valley 1998
- Raynolds, M. Checkel, M.D. Fraser, R. Macintosh, R. Life Cycle Value Assessment (LCVA) for Alternative Transportation Fuel Decisions Proceedings of the 1997 Total Life Cycle Conference - Life Cycle Management and Assessment (Part 1) SAE P-310 Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. Warrendale, PA 1997
- Raynolds, M.A. Checkel, M.D. Fraser, R.A. The Relative Mass-Energy-Economic (RMEE) Method for System Boundary Selection - A Means to Systematically and Quantitatively Select LCA Boundaries International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment September 1998
- Stumborg, M.A. Zentner, R.P. Coxworth, E. Energy Balance of Wheat Conversion to Ethanol - DRAFT Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada, Saskatoon Sask. 1995
- Wang, M. Saricks, C. Wu, M. Fuel-Cycle Fossil Energy Use and Greenhouse Gas Emissions of Fuel Ethanol Produced from U.S. Midwest Corn Argonne National Laboratory Center for Transportation Research 1997