This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Spindt Air-Fuel Ratio Method Generalization for Oxygenated Fuels
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published September 14, 1998 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
A method to deduce the operating air-fuel ratio from the fuel flow rate, fuel characteristics, and emissions was introduced by Spindt in 1965 for conventional (nonoxy-genated) fuels. This study expands the original method to encompass oxygenated fuels. The use of the expanded Spindt Method allows the equivalence ratio to be estimated more accurately at high oxygenated fuel blends. Two generalizations are developed and proposed. One of the methods is shown to provide a 8-10% improvement in equivalence ratio estimation at a 17%wt oxygen typically under the maximum SAE J1088 load condition.
To evaluate the two proposed generalized Spindt Methods, a series of small engines and fuels were emissions tested to determine the utility of the generalized Spindt Methods for analysis of oxygenated fuels. Air-fuel ratio estimates from the proposed Spindt Methods were compared to the original Spindt Method to assess equivalence ratio estimation improvements. Key to the Spindt Method comparisons were the series of emissions tests providing total hydrocarbons, oxygen, carbon monoxide, and nitrogen oxides data from a series of small utility engines over a 0%vol to 50%vol range of oxygenate addition. The oxygenates ethanol and MTBE were used in this study. The seven popular (high volume sales) engines emissions tested were comprised of four 3.7 kW (5 hp) engines (two side valve and two overhead valve) and three 9.3 kW (12.5 hp) engines (two side valve and one overhead valve).
The emissions were measured by a 5-gas analyzer reporting total hydrocarbons, carbon monoxide, nitrogen oxides, oxygen, and carbon dioxide. EPA small engine test procedures, of which the Society of Automotive Engineers J1088 testing specification is a subset, were followed. The fuel flow method option was used, as is the practice of small engine manufacturers in the United States, requiring the use of the Spindt Method to determine equivalence ratios.
CitationBresenham, D., Reisel, J., and Neusen, K., "Spindt Air-Fuel Ratio Method Generalization for Oxygenated Fuels," SAE Technical Paper 982054, 1998, https://doi.org/10.4271/982054.
Emissions in Two-Stroke and Small Four-Stroke Engines
Number: SP-1381; Published: 1998-09-14
Number: SP-1381; Published: 1998-09-14
- Reynolds, R. E. “Changes in Gasoline III” Downstream Alternatives, Inc. Jan. 1996
- Public Law 101-549, 101 st Congress “Clean Air Act Amendments of 1990,” Nov. 15 1990
- Spindt, R. S. “Air-Fuel Ratios from Exhaust Gas Analysis” SAE Paper No. 650507 1965
- Chan, S. H. Zhu, J. “Exhaust Emissions Based Air-Fuel Ratio Model (II): Divergence Analysis and Emission Estimations,” SAE paper 961021 1996
- Brettschnieder, V. J. 6 50277 1979
- Stone, D. R. “Air Flow Measurement in Internal Combustion Engines,” SAE paper 890242 1989
- Xu, R. Y. “A Convenient Technique for Determining Two-Stroke Emission Measurement Accuracy and A/F Ratio,” SAE paper 961804 1996
- Fukui, T. Tamura, Y. Omori, S. Saitoh, S. “Accuracy of A/F Calculation from Exhaust Gas Composition of SI Engines,” SAE paper 891971 1989
- Silvis, W. M. “An Algorithm for Calculating the Air/Fuel Ratio for Exhaust Emissions,” SAE paper 961020 1996
- Bresenham, D. F. College of Engineering and Applied Science University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee 1998
- Heywood, J. B. Internal Combustion Engine Fundamentals McGraw-Hill 1988
- Test Procedure for the Measurement of Gaseous Exhaust Emissions from Small Utility Engines SAE J1088 Recommended Practice 1993
- Douglas, R. “AFR and Emissions Calculations for Two-Stroke Cycle Engines,” SAE paper 901599 1990
- Simons, W. 1985 7 8 257 259