This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Laboratory Testing of Cabin Air Filters for the Removal of Reduced-Sulfur Odors
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published February 23, 1998 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
The next generation of cabin air filters will include the ability to remove not only particulate matter, but odors as well. A key element in the development of odor removal filters is the design of laboratory tests to predict in-service performance. The studies described in this report used a combination of subjective and objective test methods to evaluate a series of odor-removal filters for their ability to remove environmentally significant reduced sulfur compounds. The work was performed in two parts. In the first part the detection, recognition, and annoyance thresholds for hydrogen sulfide and methyl mercaptan were measured using a 37-member odor panel. The second part consisted of a group of tests in which the contaminant concentrations upstream and downstream of six types of filters were measured using an instrumental method. A series of short term contaminant removal tests were conducted with a range of inlet contaminant concentrations reflecting the high end of the range of concentrations likely to be encountered in the real world (50 - 200 ppb). The average removal efficiency ranged from 81-96% for hydrogen sulfide and 78-95% for methyl mercaptan. This study shows that because of the shapes of the concentration versus annoyance curves, a filter becomes effective in reducing annoyance only if it is able to reduce the odorant concentration to a level below the threshold level. In certain concentration ranges, little change in the annoyance level would result from use of low efficiency filters.
CitationOstojic, N., Siegl, W., Lee, S., Marano, R. et al., "Laboratory Testing of Cabin Air Filters for the Removal of Reduced-Sulfur Odors," SAE Technical Paper 980873, 1998, https://doi.org/10.4271/980873.
- Winter, D. “Cabin Filter Business Nothing to Sneeze At”, WARD'S Auto World, July 1994, pp 87-88.
- Jost, K. “Odor-Reducing Particulate Filters”, Automotive Engineering (May) pp 58-59 (1995).
- Lee, S. L.; Siegl, W. O.; Marano, R. S.; Zinbo, M. “Odor Filter Design Process”, Advances in Filtration and Separation Technology, American Filtration & Separations Society, 10, 174-183 (1996).
- Ilkka, S. J.; Neveling, V.; Tang, Y-M. “Practical Aspects of Testing Gas Removal Filters for Cabin Air Filtration”, SAE Paper No. 940320, Society of Automotive Engineers (1994).
- Lohse, P. “Testing of Adsorptive Cabin Air Filters According to DIN 71460 Part 2”, Advances in Filtration and Separation Technology, 9, 164-170 (1995).
- Zinbo, M.; Marano, R. S.; Siegl, W. O.; Lee, S. L., 1996, “A Multi-Mode Laboratory Test Stand for the Evaluation of Vehicle Cabin Air Filters”, Advances in Filtration and Separation Technology, American Filtration & Separations Society, 10, 184-194 (1996).
- Jaroszczyk, T.; Ptak, T. J.; Fallon, S. L.;.Wake, J. “Particulate and Odor Control in Car Ventilation Systems”, SAE Paper No. 930014, Society of Automotive Engineers (1993).
- LeMaitre, N.; Meyer, M.; Burgun, F. “Air Quality and Odors Evaluation for Passengers Compartment”, SAE Paper No. 950016, Society of Automotive Engineers (1995).
- Marttila, O.; Haahtela, T.; Silakoski, I.; Vaittinen, H.; Suominen, O. “The South Karelia Air Pollution Study: Relationship of Outdoor and Indoor Concentrations of Malodorous Sulfur compounds Released by Pulp Mills”, J. Air Waste Manage. Assoc., 44, 1093-1096 (1994).
- Ostojic, N.; “Test Method for Gaseous Contaminant Removal Devices”, ASHRAE Transactions 91(2) 594-614 (1985).
- Dravnieks, A.; Prokop, W. H. “Source Emission Odor Measurement by a Dynamic Forced-Choice Triangle Olfactometer”, J. Air Poll. Cont. Assoc., 25, 28-35 (1975).
- Dravnieks, A.; Prokop, W. H.; Boehme, W. R. “Measurement of Ambient Odors Using Dynamic Forced-Choice Olfactometer”, J. Air Poll. Cont. Assoc., 28, 1124-1130 (1979).
- Verschueren, K. Handbook of Environmental Data on Chemicals, 2nd ed.; Van Norstrand Reinhold Company, New York, 1983.
- Compilation of Odor and Taste Threshold Values Data; Fazzalari, F. A., Ed.; DS48A, ASTM, 1978.
- Ostojic, N. unpublished data, 1995.
- Gescheider, G. A. Physcophysics: Method, Theory, and Application, 2nd Edition, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Publishers, Hillsdale, NJ, 1985, pp 217-26.