This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Driving Simulation
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Recent advances in computing power, computer graphics, and virtual reality systems are leading to important new opportunities for the development and use of driving simulators. These advances in technology are pointing towards a future where human-in-the-loop simulation is increasingly valuable for training, human-factors research, and virtual prototyping.
This paper presents a general literature review of driving simulation, and discusses important components of modern driving simulators. The paper concludes with speculation on the future of driving simulation.
Recommended Content
Authors
- James Gruening - Iowa Center for Emerging Manufacturing Technology, Iowa State University
- James Bernard - Iowa Center for Emerging Manufacturing Technology, Iowa State University
- Chris Clover - Iowa Center for Emerging Manufacturing Technology, Iowa State University
- Kurt Hoffmeister - Iowa Center for Emerging Manufacturing Technology, Iowa State University
Topic
Citation
Gruening, J., Bernard, J., Clover, C., and Hoffmeister, K., "Driving Simulation," SAE Technical Paper 980223, 1998, https://doi.org/10.4271/980223.Also In
References
- Weir, D.H. Clark, A.J. “A Survey of Mid-Level Driving Simulators,” SAE Paper No. 950172
- Bertollini, G.P. Johnston, C.M. et al. “The General Motors Driving Simulator,” SAE Paper No. 940179
- Proceedings of Driving Simulation Conference (DSC'95) Sophia Antipolis, France September 12-13 1995
- Proceedings of Driving Simulation Conference (DSC'97) Ecole Normale Superieure Lyons-France September 8-9 1997
- Haward, D.M. “The Sanders Teacher,” Flight 2 50 10 December 1910 1006 1007
- Link, E.A. “Combination Training Device for Student Aviators and Student Entertainment Apparatus,” 820 1930
- Rolfe, J.M Staples, K.J. “Flight Simulation,” Cambridge Aerospace Series Cambridge University Press 1986
- Dehmel, R.C. 1941
- Wierwille, W.W. “Driving Simulator Design for Realistic Handling,” Proceedings of the Third International Conference on Vehicle Systems Dynamics Sachs H.K. Swets and Zeitlinger B.V., Amsterdam 1975
- Repa, B.S. Wierwille, W.W. “Driver Performance in Controlling a Driving Simulator with Varying Vehicle Response Characteristics,” SAE Paper No. 760779 October 1976
- Repa, B.S. Leucht, P.M. Wierwille, W.W. “The Effect of Simulator Motion on Driver Performance,” SAE Paper No. 820307
- Rogers, S.B. Wierwille, W.W. “The Occurrence of Accelerator and Brake Pedal Actuation Errors during Simulated Driving,” Human Factors 1988 30 1 71 81
- McLane, R.C. Wierwille, W.W. “The Influence of Motion and Audio Cues on Driver Performance in an Automobile Simulator,” Human Factors 1975 17 488 501
- Casali, J.G. Wierwille, W.W. “The Effects of Various Design Alternatives on Moving-Base Driving Simulator Discomfort,” Human Factors 1980 22 741 756
- Casali, J.G. Wierwille, W.W. “Potential Design Etiological Factors of Simulator Sickness and a Research Simulator Specification,” Transportation Research Record 1059 66 74
- Casali, J.G. Frank, L.H. “Perceptual Distortion and Its Consequences in Vehicular Simulation: Basic Theory and Incidence of Simulator Sickness,” Transportation Research Record 1059 57 65
- Frank, L.H. Casali, J.G. Wierwille, W.W. “Effects of Visual Display and Motion System Delays on Operator Performance and Uneasiness in a Driving Simulator,” Human Factors 1988 30 201 217
- Alicandri, E. “HYSIM: The Next Best Thing to Being on the Road,” Public Roads Winter 1994 57 3
- Nilsson, L. “Behavioural Research in an Advanced Driving Simulator-Experiences of the VTI System,” Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 37 th Annual Meeting 1993 612 616
- Hahn, S. Kading, W. “The Daimler-Benz Driving Simulator-Presentation of Selected Experiments” SAE Paper No. 880058
- Drosdol, J. Panik, F. “The Daimler-Benz Driving Simulator-A Tool for Vehicle Development,” SAE Paper No. 850334
- Kading, W. Hoffmeyer, F. “The Advanced Daimler-Benz Driving Simulator,” SAE Paper No. 950175
- Reichelt, W. “Correlation Analysis of Open/Closed Loop Data for Objective Assessment of Handling Characteristics of Cars,” SAE Paper No. 910238
- Daimler-Benz Driving Simulator http://www.daimler-benz.com/repl_e.cgi?pagesrc=/research/text/70610a_e.htm
- Greenberg, J.A. Park, T.J. “The Ford Driving Simulator,” SAE Paper No. 940176
- Artz, B.E. Cathey, L.W. Greenberg, J. et al “A Hardware in the Loop Real Time Driving Simulator for Advanced Brake System Development,” Conference Proceedings DSC 97 173 180 Sept. 1997
- Freeman, J.S. Watson, G. et al “The Iowa Driving Simulator: An Implementation and Application Overview,” SAE Paper No. 950174
- Romano, R.A. Stoner, J.W. Evans, D.F. “Real Time Vehicle Dynamics Simulation: Enabling Tool for Fundamental Human Factors Research,” SAE Paper No. 910237
- Cremer, J. Kearney, J. Papelis, Y. “Driving Simulation: Challenges for VR Technology,” IEEE Computer Graphics and Applications Sept. 1996 16 20
- Broen, N.L. Chiang, D.P. “Braking Response Times for 100 Drivers in the Avoidance of an Unexpected Obstacle as Measured in a Driving Simulator,” Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 40 th Annual Meeting 1996 900 904
- Weir, D.H. Bourne, S.M. “An Overview of the DRI Driving Simulator,” SAE Paper No. 950173
- Allen, R.W. Rosenthal, T.J. “Meeting Important Cuing Requirements with Modest, Real-Time, Interactive Driving Simulations,” SAE Paper No. 940228
- Allen, R.W. Rosenthal, T.J. Parseghian, Z. “Low Cost Driving Simulation for Research, Training, and Screening Applications,” SAE Paper No. 950171
- Allen, R.W. Rosenthal, T.J. et al “A Vehicle Dynamics Model for Low Cost, PC Based Driving Simulations,” Conference Proceedings DSC 97 153 164 Sept. 1997
- http://www.systemstech.com/
- Gillespie, T.D. “Heavy Truck Ride,” Presented at the Society of Automotive Engineers L. Ray Buckendale Lecture 31 Feb. 1985 Report No. SAE SP-607
- Bernard, J.E. Clover, C.L. “Tire Modeling for Low-Speed and High-Speed Calculations,” SAE Paper 950311 1995
- Sayers, M.W. Mousseau, C.W. “Real-time Vehicle Dynamic Simulation Obtained with a Symbolic Multibody Program.” Transportation Systems 1990 108 American Society of Mechanical Engineers 1990 51 58
- Allen, R.W. Rosenthal, T.J. Chrstos, J.P. “A Vehicle Dynamics Tire Model for Both Pavement and Off-Road Conditions,” SAE Paper No. 970559
- Pacejka, H.B. “Tire Characteristics and Vehicle Dynamics,” University Consortium for Continuing Education Nov. 2-4 1988 Washington D.C.
- Salaani, M.K. Chrstos, J.P. Guenther, D.A. “Parameter Measurement and Development of a NADSdyna Validation Data Set for a 1994 Ford Taurus,” SAE Paper No. 970564
- Artz, B.E. “An Analytical Road Segment Terrain Database for Driving Simulation,” Conference Proceedings DSC 95 274 284 Sept. 1995
- Papelis, Y. “Terrain Modeling on High-Fidelity Ground Vehicle Simulators,” Proceedings of Fifth Annual Conference on AI, Simulation, and Planning in High Autonomy Systems (IEEE) 48 54 December 1994
- Turpin, D. Evan, D. “High-Fidelity Road/Tire Interaction Models for Real Time Simulation,” SAE Paper No. 950170
- Turpin, D.R. “Application of High-Fidelity Surface Tire Force Models in Real-Time Simulation,” Conference Proceedings DSC 95 315 332 Sept. 1995
- Bickenbach, H.J. “Training Design and Scenario Control,” Conference Proceedings DSC 95 211 222 Sept. 1995
- Kelada, J. Piroird, J. “Traffic Generation and Scenario Control in the SCANeR Simulator,” Conference Proceedings DSC 95 223 234 Sept. 1995
- Cremer, J. Kearney, J. “Improvisation and Opportunism in Scenario Control for Driving Simulation,” Proceedings of the Second Seminar on Traffic Generation for Driving Simulators 13 December 1994 Paris
- Tran, J. “Pedagogical Environment for Driving Simulators: Traffic Generation and Intelligent Aids to Scenario Control,” Conference Proceedings DSC 95 245 257 Sept. 1995
- Levine, O. H. “Effects of Visual Display Parameters on Driving Performance in a Virtual Environment Driving Simulator,” College of Engineering, Northeastern University Boston, MA 1995
- Pausch, R. van Dam, A. Robinett, W. Bryson, S. “CHI'94 Tutorial Notes: Implementing Virtual Reality,” Boston, MA Association for Computing Machinery
- Cruz-Neira, C. “Virtual Reality Based on Multiple Projection Screens: The CAVE and its Application to Computational Science and Engineering,” College of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science, University of Illinois at Chicago 1995
- McFarland, R.E. “CGI Delay Compensation,” NASA TM 86703 NASA Ames Research Center Jan. 1986
- Gordon, D.A. “Experimental Isolation of Drivers' Visual Input,” Public Roads 33 1966 53 68
- Segal, L. “An Investigation of Automobile Handling as Implemented by a Variable-Steering Automobile,” Human Factors 6 1964 333 341
- Segal, L. “On The Lateral Stability and Control of the Automobile as Influenced by the Dynamics of the Steering System,” ASME Journal of Engineering for Industry August 1966
- Repa, B.S. et al “Study of Vehicle Steering and Response Characteristics in Simulated and Actual Driving,” SAE Paper No. 780011
- Howe, J.G. Rupp, M.Y. et al “Improving Steering Feel for the National Advanced Driving Simulator,” SAE Paper No. 970567
- Yamaguchi, H. et al “Development of an Electronically Controlled Power Steering System,” SAE Paper No. 841198
- Clover, C.L. Luecke, G.R. Troy, J.J McNeely, W.A. “Dynamic Simulation of Virtual Mechanisms with Haptic Feedback Using Industrial Robotics Equipment” The Proceedings of the 1997 International Conference on Robotics and Automation
- Colgate J.E. Brown J.M. “Factors Affecting Z-width of a Haptic Display,” The Proceedings of the 1994 Conference on Robotics and Automation 1994 3205 3210
- Miyamoto, T. Momiyama, F. Fujioka, T. “Steer-Restoring Torque Controlled Driving Simulator for Developing Steering Road Feel,” SAE Paper No. 912690
- Hogan, N. “Controlling Impedance at the Man/Machine Interface,” The Proceedings of the 1989 IEEE Conference on Robotics and Automation 1989 1626 1631
- Hein, C.M. “Driving Simulators: Six Years of Hands-on Experience at Hughes Aircraft Company” Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 37th Annual Meeting 1993 607 611
- Suetomi, T. et al “The Driving Simulator with Large Amplitude Motion System,” SAE Paper No. 910113
- Garrott, W.R. “Sizing the Motion Base of the National Advanced Driving Simulator,” Report No. DOT HS 807 979 March 1993
- Clark, B. Stewart, J.D. “Effects of Angular Acceleration on Man: Thresholds for the Perception of Rotation and the Oculogyral Illusion,” Aerospace Medicine 40 952 956 Sept. 1969
- Reid, L.D. Grant, P.R. “Motion-Base Development Package for NADS,” Transportation Research Center of Ohio East Liberty 1991
- Reid, L.D. Grant, P.R. “Motion Algorithm for Large-Displacement Driving Simulator,” Transportation Research Record 1403 98 106
- Kelada, J.M. Kemeny, A. Lailler, D. “Scenario Control Tools for a Dynamic Truck Simulator,” Conference Proceedings DSC 97 215 225 Sept. 1997
- McLane, R.C. Wierwille, W.W. “The Influence of Motion and Audio Cues on Driver Performance in an Automobile Simulator,” Human Factors 1975 17 488 501
- Bernasch, J. Haenel, S. “The BMW Driving Simulator Used for the Development of a Driver-Biased Adaptive Cruise Control,” Conference Proceedings DSC 95 157 174 Sept. 1995
- Money, K.E. “Flight Simulator Motion Sickness in the Aurora CP 140 FDS,” (Tech Communication No. 80-C-44) Downsview, Ontario, Canada Defence and Civil Institute of Environmental Medicine
- Lilienthal, M.G. Merkle, P.J. “Simulator Sickness in Flight Simulators: A Case Study,” Transporation Research Record 1059 81 86
- Casali, J.G. Frank, L.H. “Perceptual Distortion and Its Consequences in Vehicular Simulation: Basic Theory and Incidence of Simulator Sickness,” Transportation Research Record 1059 57 65
- Frank, L.H. Casali, J.G. “Simulator Sickness: A Review of Its Costs, Countermeasures, and Prediction,” SAE Paper No. 861782
- Casali, J.G. Wierwille, W.W. “The Effects of Various Design Alternatives on Moving-Base Driving Simulator Discomfort,” Human Factors 1980 22 741 756
- Kennedy, R.S. Frank, L.H. “Review of Motion Sickness with Special Reference to Simulator Sickness,” Transportation Research Record 1059 75 80
- O'Hanlon, J.F. McCauley, M.E. “Motion Sickness Incidence as a Function of the Frequency and Acceleration of a Vertical Sinusoidal Motion,” Aerospace Medicine 45 4 1974 366 369
- Kennedy, R.S. Drexler, J.M. Compton, D.E. “Simulator Sickness and Other Aftereffects: Implications for the Design of Driving Simulators,” Conference Proceedings DSC 97 115 123 Sept. 1997
- Casali, J.G. Wierwille, W.W. “Potential Design Etiological Factors of Simulator Sickness and a Research Simulator Specification,” Transportation Research Record 1059 66 74
- National Advanced Driving Simulator University of Iowa, USA
- Iowa Center for Emerging Manufacturing Technology
- National Advanced Driving Simulator Performance Capability Sheet TRW