This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Designing Ranged Sets of Top-Level Design Specifications for a Family of Aircraft: An Application of Design Capability Indices
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Design capability indices provide a metric to assess the capability of a family of designs, represented by a range of top-level design specifications, to satisfy a ranged set of design requirements. Design capability indices can be used to manage design freedom in the early stages of the design process when design requirements for a system may be uncertain. To illustrate the use of design capability indices, the design of a family of General Aviation aircraft is presented: design capability indices are used to simultaneously design a family of three aircraft around a two, a four, and a six seater configuration. The results are compared against two of our previous studies.
Recommended Content
Technical Paper | A Business Aircraft View to the Future |
Technical Paper | THE LIGHT AIRPLANE FOR PRIVATE OWNER |
Technical Paper | “SERVICE EXPERIENCE WITH LIGHT AIRCRAFT ENGINES” |
Authors
Citation
Simpson, T., Allen, J., Mistree, F., and Chen, W., "Designing Ranged Sets of Top-Level Design Specifications for a Family of Aircraft: An Application of Design Capability Indices," SAE Technical Paper 975513, 1997, https://doi.org/10.4271/975513.Also In
References
- Allen, J. K. Krishnamachari, R. S. Masetta, J. Pearce, D. Rigby, D. Mistree, F. 1992 “Fuzzy Compromise: An Effective Way to Solve Hierarchical Design Problems,” Structural Optimization 4 235 262
- Antonsson, E. K. Otto, K. N. 1995 “Imprecision in Engineering Design,” Journal of Mechanical Design (Special 50th Anniversary Design Issue) 117 June 25 32
- Balling, R. J. Free, J. C. Parkinson, A. R. 1986 “Consideration of Worst-Case Manufacturing Tolerances in Design Optimization,” Journal of Mechanisms, Transmissions, and Automation in Design 108 4 December 438 441
- Belegundu, A. D. Zhang, S. 1989 September 17-21 “Robust Mechanical Design Through Minimum Sensitivity,” Advances in Design Automation ( Ravani, B. , ed.) Montreal, Quebec, Canada ASME 19-2 233 239
- Belegundu, A. D. Zhang, S. 1992 “Robustness of Design Through Minimum Sensitivity,” Journal of Mechanical Design 114 June 213 217
- Bradley, S. R. Agogino, A. M. 1994 “An Intelligent Real Time Design Methodology for Component Selection: An Approach for Managing Uncertainty,” Journal of Mechanical Design 116 December 980 988
- Cartuyvels, R. Booth, R. Kubicek, S. Dupas, L. De Meyer, K. 1993 September 7-9 “A Powerful TCAD System Including Advanced RSM Techniques for Various Engineering Optimization Problems,” Conference on Simulation of Semiconductor Devices and Processes (SISDEP'93) Vienna, Austria
- Cartuyvels, R. Dupas, L. 1993 November 8-10 “NORMAN/DEBORA: a Powerful CAD-Integrating Automatic Sequencing System Including Advanced DOE/RSM Techniques for Various Engineering Optimization Problems,” JSPE-IFIP WG 5.3 Design of Information Infrastructure Systems for Manufacturing Workshop Tokyo, Japan
- Chang, T. S. Ward, A. C. 1995 “Conceptual Robustness in Simultaneous Engineering: A Formulation in Continuous Space,” Research in Engineering Design 7 2 67 85
- Chen, R. Ward, A. C. 1992 September 13-16 “Introduction to Interval Matrices in Design,” Design Theory and Methodology - DTM'92 ( Taylor, D. L. and Stauffer, L. A. , eds.) Scottsdale, AZ ASME 42 221 227
- Chen, W. Allen, J. K. Tsui, K.-L. Mistree, F. 1996 “A Procedure for Robust Design: Minimizing Variations Caused by Noise and Control Factors,” Journal of Mechanical Design 118 4 478 485
- Chen, W. Simpson, T. W. Allen, J. K. Mistree, F. 1996 August 18-22 “Use of Design Capability Indices to Satisfy a Ranged Set of Design Requirements,” Advances in Design Automation ( Dutta, D. , ed.), Irvine, CA ASME Paper No. 96-DETC/DAC-1090
- Eggert, R. J. 1991 September 22-25 “Quantifying Design Feasibility Using Probabilistic Feasibility Analysis,” Advances in Design Automation ( Gabriele, G. A. , ed.), Miami, FL ASME 32-1 235 240
- Eggert, R. J. 1995 “Design Variation Simulation of Thick-walled Cylinders,” Journal of Mechanical Design 117 June 221 228
- Eggert, R. J. Mayne, R. W. 1993 “Probabilistic Optimal Design Using Successive Surrogate Probability Density Functions,” Journal of Mechanical Design 115 September 385 391
- Habib, W. Ward, A. C. 1990 “Proving the Labeled Interval Calculus for Inferences on Catalogs,” Design Theory and Methodology - DTM'90 ( Rinderle, J. R. , ed.), Chicago, IL ASME 27 63 68
- Habib, W. Ward, A. C. 1991 September 22-25 “In Pursuit of a Design Mathematics: Generalizing the Labeled Interval Calculus,” Design Theory and Methodology ( Stauffer, L. A. , ed.), Miami, FL ASME 31 279 284
- Ignizio, J. P. 1985 Introduction to Linear Goal Programming Sage University Papers Beverly Hills, CA
- Johnson, N. L. Kotz, S. Pearn, W. L. 1992 “Flexible Process Capability Indices,” Institute of Statistics Mimeo Series Univ. of North Carolina Chapel Hill, NC
- Law, W. S. Antonsson, E. K. 1994 “Implementing the Method of Imprecision: An Engineering Design Example,” Proceedings of the Third IEEE International Conference on Fuzzy Systems (FUZZ-IEEE '94) , IEEE 1 358 363
- Lin, B. T. Ward, A. C. 1992 “Introduction to Design Inferences Over Sets of Intervals,” Design Theory and Methodology - DTM'92 ( Taylor, D. L. and Stauffer, L. A. , eds.), Scottsdale, AZ ASME 42 187 192
- Mistree, F. Hughes, O. F. Bras, B. A. 1993 “The Compromise Decision Support Problem and the Adaptive Linear Programming Algorithm,” Structural Optimization: Status and Promise ( Kamat, M. P. , ed.), AIAA Washington, D.C. 247 289
- Mohandas, S. U. Sandgren, E. 1989 September 17-21 “Multiobjective Optimization Dealing with Uncertainty,” Advances in Design Automation ( Ravani, B. , ed.), Montreal, Quebec, Canada ASME 19-2 241 248
- Myers, R. H. Montgomery, D. C. 1995 Response Surface Methodology: Process and Product Optimization Using Designed Experiments John Wiley & Sons New York
- Nair, V. N. 1992 “Taguchi's Parameter Design: A Panel Discussion,” Technometrics , 34 2 127 161
- NASA 1978 “GASP - General Aviation Synthesis Program,” Ames Research Center
- Ng, K. K. Tsui, K. L. 1992 “Expressing Variability and Yield with a Focus on the Customer,” Quality Engineering , 5 2 255 267
- Nicolai, L. M. 1984 Fundamentals of Aircraft Design , METS Inc. San Jose
- Otto, K. N. Antonsson, E. K. 1993 “Extensions to the Taguchi Method of Product Design,” Journal of Mechanical Design , 115 March 5 13
- Otto, K. N. Antonsson, E. K. 1993 “Tuning Parameters in Engineering Design,” Journal of Mechanical Design , 115 March 14 19
- Otto, K. N. Antonsson, E. K. 1994 “Modeling Imprecision in Product Design,” Proceedings of the Third IEEE International Conference on Fuzzy Systems (FUZZ-IEEE '94) , IEEE 1 346 351
- Parkinson, A. 1995 “Robust Mechanical Design Using Engineering Methods,” Journal of Mechanical Design (Special 50th Anniversary Design Issue) , 117 June 48 54
- Parkinson, A. Sorenson, C. Free, J. Canfield, B. 1990 September 16-19 “Tolerances and Robustness in Engineering Design Optimization,” Advances in Design Automation ( Ravani, B. , ed.), Chicago, IL ASME 23-l 121 128
- Parkinson, A. Sorenson, C. Pourhassan, N. 1993 “A General Approach for Robust Optimal Design,” Journal of Mechanical Design 115 March 74 80
- Phadke, M. S. 1989 Quality Engineering using Robust Design , Prentice Hall Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey
- Pritchard, J. I. Adelman, H. M. Sobieszczanski-Sobieski, J. 1994 September 7-9 “Optimization for Minimum Sensitivity to Uncertain Parameters,” 5th AIAA/NASA/USAF/ISSMO Symposium on Multidisciplinary Analysis and Optimization , Panama City, FL AIAA 1 261 268 Paper No. AIAA-94-4279-CP
- Ramakrishnan, B. Rao, S. S. 1991 September 22-25 “A Robust Optimization Approach Using Taguchi's Loss Function for Solving Nonlinear Optimization Problems,” Advances in Design Automation - Design Automation and Design Optimization ( Gabriele, G. A. , ed.), Miami, FL ASME 32-1 241 248
- Raymer, D. P. 1989 Aircraft Design: A Conceptual Approach AIAA Washington, D.C.
- Rinderle, J. R. Krishnan, V. 1990 September 16-19 “Constraint Reasoning in Concurrent Design,” Design Theory and Methodology - DTM'90 ( Rinderle, J. R. , ed.), Chicago, IL ASME 27 53 62
- Rodriguez, R. N. 1992 “Recent Developments in Process Capability Analysis,” Quality Technology , 24 4 176 187
- Sandgren, E. 1989 September 17-21 “A Multi-Objective Design Tree Approach for Optimization Under Uncertainty,” Advances in Design Automation ( Ravani, B. , ed.), Montreal, Quebec ASME 19-2 249 255
- Sandgren, E. Gim, G. Ragsdell, K. M. 1985 “Optimal Design of a Class of Welded Structures Based on Design for Latitude,” Journal of Mechanisms, Transmissions, and Automation in Design , 107 4 482 487
- Schrage, D. P. 1992 “Concurrent Design: A Case Study,” Concurrent Engineering-Automation, Tools, and Techniques ( Kusaik, A. , ed.), John Wiley & Sons, Inc. New York 535 582
- Simpson, T. W. 1995 December “Development of a Design Process for Realizing Open Engineering Systems,” Woodruff School of Mechanical Engineering, Georgia Institute of Technology Atlanta, GA
- Simpson, T. W. Chen, W. Allen, J. K. Mistree, F. 1996 September 4-6 “Conceptual Design of a Family of Products Through the Use of the Robust Concept Exploration Method,” 6th AIAA/USAF/NASA/ISSMO Symposium on Multidisciplinary Analysis and Optimization Bellevue, WA AIAA 2 1535 1545
- Simpson, T. W. Chen, W. Allen, J. K. Mistree, F. 1997 “Use of the Robust Concept Exploration Method to Facilitate the Design of a Family of Products,” Simultaneous Engineering: Methodologies and Applications ( Roy, U. et al. , eds.), Chapman & Hall New York
- Simpson, T. W. Peplinski, J. Koch, P. N. Allen, J. K. 1997 September 11-14 “On the Use of Statistics in Design and the Implications for Deterministic Computer Experiments,” Design Theory and Methodology Conference - DTM'97 Sacramento, CA ASME Paper No. DETC97/DTM-3881
- Simpson, T. W. Rosen, D. Allen, J. K. Mistree, F. 1997 “Metrics for Assessing Design Freedom and Information Certainty in the Early Stages of Design,” Design Theory and Methodology Conference - DTM'96 ( Wood, K. , ed.) Irvine, CA ASME Paper No. 96-DETC/DTM-1521
- Sobek, D. K., II 1996 “A Set-Based Model of Design,” Mechanical Engineering , 118 7 July 78 81
- Su, J. Renaud, J. E. 1996 September 4-6 “Automatic Differentiation in Robust Optimization,” 6th AIAA/USAF/NASA/ISSMO Symposium on Multidisciplinary Analysis and Optimization , Bellevue, WA AIAA 1 201 215
- Sundaresan, S. Ishii, K. Houser, D. R. 1989 September 17-21 “A Procedure Using Manufacturing Variance to Design Gears with Minimum Transmission Error,” Advances in Design Automation ( Ravani, B. , ed.), Montreal, Quebec ASME 19-2 145 151
- Sundaresan, S. Ishii, K. Houser, D. R. 1991 September 22-25 “Design Optimization for Robustness Using Performance Simulation Programs,” Advances in Design Automation ( Gabriele, G. A. , ed.) Miami, FL ASME 32-1 249 256
- Sundaresan, S. Ishii, K. Houser, D. R. 1993 “A Robust Optimization Procedure with Variations on Design Variables and Constraints,” Advances in Design Automation ( Gilmore, B. J. et al eds.) ASME 65-1 379 386
- Taguchi, G. 1987 System of Experimental Design: Engineering Methods to Optimize Quality and Minimize Costs UNIPUB/Kraus International Publications
- Teng, A. Free, J. Parkinson, A. 1992 September 21-23 “An Approach to Robust Design of Dynamic Systems--Allocation of Variation,” 4th AIAA/USAF/NASA/OAI Symposium on Multidisciplinary Analysis and Optimization Cleveland, OH AIAA 2 810 819
- Vadde, S. Allen, J. K. Mistree, F. 1994 “Compromise Decision Support Problems for Hierarchical Design Involving Uncertainty,” Computers and Structures 52 4 645 658
- Wallace, D. R. 1994 “A Probabilistic Specification-based Design Model: Applications to Search and Environmental Computer-Aided Design,” Massachusetts Institute of Technology Boston, MA
- Ward, A. Liker, J. K. Cristiano, J. J. Sobek, D. K., II 1995 “The Second Toyota Paradox: How Delaying Decisions Can Make Better Cars Faster,” Sloan Management Review 36 3 Spring 43 61
- Ward, A. C. Liker, J. K. Sobek, D. K., II Cristiano, J. J. 1994 September 11-14 “Set-Based Concurrent Engineering and Toyota,” Design Theory and Methodology - DTM'94 Minneapolis, MN ASME 68 79 90
- Ward, A. C. Seering, W. P. 1993 “The Performance of a Mechanical Design ‘Compiler’,” Journal of Mechanical Design , 115 September 341 345
- Ward, A. C. Seering, W. P. 1993 “Quantitative Inference in a Mechanical Design ‘Compiler’,” Journal of Mechanical Design , 115 March 29 35
- Wood, K. L. Antonsson, E. K. Beck, J. L. 1989 September 17-21 “Comparing Fuzzy and Probability Calculus for Representing Imprecision in Engineering Design,” Design Theory and Methodology - DTM'89 ( Elmaraghy, W. H. et al. , eds.) Montreal, Quebec ASME 17 99 105