This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
TBN Retention - Are We Missing the Point?
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Historically, the characterization of fresh and used diesel engine lubricants has been based on a limited number of analytical techniques. One of the most important analyses has always been the total base number (TBN) measurement. Although the TBN measurements are informative, easy, and quick, it can be misleading to base the judgment of an oil's performance solely on one criterion.
This paper offers observations from a field test, showing that some detergent approaches gave unacceptable performance even though the TBNs were at an acceptable level. It is hypothesized that some detergents do not effectively neutralize all acidic species present in the lubricant, thereby reserving their own base while in fact the oil may no longer provide sufficient protection against bearing corrosion. This hypothesis is supported with bench and engine test data. It is recommended that, at a minimum, total acid number (TAN) measurements be included in any analysis. Where time and cost allow, wear metals content, oxidation, soot content, and viscosity should also be evaluated.
Recommended Content
Authors
Citation
van Dam, W., Broderick, D., Freerks, R., Small, V. et al., "TBN Retention - Are We Missing the Point?," SAE Technical Paper 972950, 1997, https://doi.org/10.4271/972950.Also In
References
- Boone Edward F. Fetterman G.P. Schetelich Alan “Low Sulfur Fuel with Lower Ash Lubricating Oils - A New Recipe for Heavy Duty Diesels” SAE Paper No. 922200
- McGeehan, J.A. Shaman E. Couch M.C. Parker R.A. “Selecting Diesel Crankcase Oils to Use With Low-Sulfur Fuel” SAE Paper No. 932845
- Pierz Patrick M. Adams James R. Cusano Carmen M. Thomas Stephanie A. Kauffmann Francois Muller Chris “Incompatibility of High Ash Oil for Engines Run on Low Sulfur Diesel Fuel” SAE Paper No. 961916
- McGeehan J.A. et al “The World's First Diesel Engine Oil Category for Use With Low-Sulfur Fuel: API CG-4” SAE Paper No. 941939
- Schiemann L.F. Andrews C.A. Carrick V.A. Humphrey B.K. Martin J.R. Pocinki S.B. Schmid C.F. Shah M.P. “Developing Heavy Duty Diesel Lubricants to Meet the Extended Service Interval Challenge” SAE Paper No. 952551
- Detroit Diesel Corporation “Fuels and Lubricants Recommendation”
- Caterpillar “Oil and Your Engine”
- Caterpillar “Caterpillar On-Highway Diesel Truck Engines Lubrication Specifications” April 1995
- Bardasz E.A. Carrick V.A. Ebeting V.L. George H.F. Graf M.M. Kornbrekke R.E. Pocinki S.B. “Understanding Soot Mediated Oil Thickening Through Designed Experimentation - Part 2: GM 6.5L” SAE Paper No. 961915
- Yamada Yasuhisa Igarashi Jinichi Inoue Kiyoshi “Effects of Metallic Detergents on the Antioxidant and Antiwear Properties of Zinc Dialkyldithiophosphates” Lubrication Engineering 1992 6 511 518