This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Perforation Corrosion on Automotive Steel - Comparison of Accelerated Indoor Corrosion Test and Field Performance
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published February 24, 1997 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
The use of cyclic corrosion tests which consist of salt spraying, humidifying, and drying phases is desirable in the evaluation of the corrosion performance of automotive body panels. In this work, coupons of zinc-coated steel and of cold rolled steel were exposed to a defined cyclic corrosion test (CCT) which has shown to be suitable for simulating diverse outdoor conditions for evaluating the cosmetic corrosion of precoated steel. Micro-environment data in the gap of lapped panel specimens, such as wetness, corrosion rate of test materials, pH value, chloride content, have been obtained during the CCT test. The galvanic current flowing between a gold electrode and the test materials was measured to monitor the degree of wetness inside the crevice. The results show that the surface of the test materials never became really dry even during the dry period of the CCT cycle. Furthermore, the wetness during wet and dry periods in the crevice increased with increasing number of CCT cycle. Electrochemical Impedance Spectroscopy (EIS) has been used to determine in-situ the corrosion rate of test materials in the crevice during the CCT. EIS measurements suggested that the corrosion performance of the test materials changed greatly with the number of exposure cycles during the wet and dry phases of the CCT. This is probably due to the increase in the degree of wetness and in the chloride content in the crevice geometry. At the end of the cyclic test, corrosion evaluation by visual inspection and microscopic examination has shown good agreement with the EIS and galvanic current measurements. A comparison of the perforation corrosion attack on both zinc coated steel and cold rolled steel during the field exposure and that under CCT exposure shows clearly that this type of accelerated indoor test cannot appropriately simulate conditions for perforation corrosion in actual automotive bodies.
The corrosion products after the CCT test under both crevice and cosmetic conditions were analysed by X-ray diffraction (XRD). In crevice conditions, zincite and hydroxycarbonate were the main corrosion products, whereas hydroxychloride was detected under cosmetic condition for zinc coated steel sheets. These difference are attributed to the different geometries and the different micro-climate conditions.
|Durability of Lap-Shear Adhesive Joints with Coated Steels in Corrosive Environments
|Ground Vehicle Standard
|Overlap Shear Test for Sealant Adhesive Bonding of Automotive Glass Encapsulating Material to Body Opening
|Aerospace Material Specification
|Compound, Cleaning, Foaming, for Aircraft Surfaces
CitationZhu, F., Thierry, D., Kucera, V., and Hedlund, S., "Perforation Corrosion on Automotive Steel - Comparison of Accelerated Indoor Corrosion Test and Field Performance," SAE Technical Paper 971001, 1997, https://doi.org/10.4271/971001.
- VOLVO corporate standard 1994
- Roudabush L.A. Dorsett T.E. “A review of perforation corrosion testing - 1980 to 1990” SAE paper 912285 , SAE publication 250 October 1991
- Dorsett T.E. Davidson D.D “SAE ACAP Division III report - Design of a standard test coupon for perforation corrosion” SAE paper 932366 1993
- Zhu F. Hedlund S, Thierry D. “Application of electrochemical impedance spectroscopy to study the perforation corrosion of automotive materials” Br.Corros. J. 31 2 113 1996
- Keddam M. Hugot-Le-Goff A. Takenouti H. Thierry D. Arevalo M.C. “The influence of a thin electrolyte layer on the corrosion process of zinc in chloride-containing solutions” Corrosion Science 33 8 1243 1992
- Guillaume R. Keddam M. Takenouti H. “In-situ electrochemical investigation of a scratched galvanized steel during a climatic test” Mater. Sci. Forum 44 45 109 1989
- Fiaud C. Keddam M. Kadri A. Takenouti H. “Electrochemical Impedance in a thin surface electrolyte layer. Influence of the potential probe location” Electrochemical Acta 32 3 445 1987
- Stewart K.C. Kolman D.G. Taylor S.R. “The effect of parasitic conduction pathways on EIS measurements in low conductivity media” Electrochemical Impedance: Analysis and Interpretation Scully J.R. Silverman D.C. Kendig M.W. American Society for Testing and Materials Philadelphia 73 1993
- Reinmuth W. H. J. Electroanal. Chem. 34 297 1972
- Mansfeld F. “Evaluation of electrochemical technology for monitoring of atmospheric corrosion phenomena” Electrochemical Corrosion Testing Des Mansfeld F. Bertocci U. ASTM STP 727 21 1981
- Mansfeld F. Kenkel J.V. Corros. Sci. 16 111 1976
- Kurokawa S. Yamato K. Ichida T. “A study on cosmetic and perforation corrosion test procedures for automotive steel sheets” Paper No. 396, Corrosion91 March 1991 Ohio
- Graedel T.E. “Corrosion mechanisms for zinc exposed to the atmosphere” J. Electrochem. Soc. 136 4 193c 1989
- Bernard M. C. Hugot-Le Goff A. Massinon D. Phillips N. “underpaint corrosion of zinc-coated steel sheet studied by in-situ Raman Spectroscopy” Corros. Sci. 35 5-8 1339 1993
- Nakazawa M. Nomura H. Hayashi K. Ito Y. Miyoshi Y. “Perforation Corrosion of automobiles - Field car and laboratory investigation” SAE paper 932367 1993