This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Comparison of Surface Coatings Formed from Carboxylic Acid-Based and Conventional Coolants in a Field-Test Study
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published February 01, 1996 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
Field-test samples cut from radiator tubes in two 1990 Chevy Luminas (3.1L engine) after 100,000 miles were analyzed to determine corrosion layer differences. One car used a carboxylic acid-based inhibitor technology (C1). The other car used a conventional coolant (C2). X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) analysis of the two samples was performed.
Results indicate a significant difference between the two samples. The C1 sample had a thin (<60Å) organic coating bound to the aluminum alloy surface, while the C2 sample had a much thicker (>1000 Å) silicate-rich layer. This resulted in the C2 sample exhibiting “surface charging” behavior. These results relate directly to the metal/insulator (conductor/insulator) characteristics of the two samples, and imply that the heat transfer of the protective coating provided by the carboxylate technology (C1) is significantly better than that of traditional inhibitor technology (C2). A mechanism for the corrosion inhibition of the carboxylate system is discussed, and is supported by scanning electron microscopy (SEM) results.
CitationMowlem, J. and Van de Ven, P., "Comparison of Surface Coatings Formed from Carboxylic Acid-Based and Conventional Coolants in a Field-Test Study," SAE Technical Paper 960640, 1996, https://doi.org/10.4271/960640.
- Washington, D.A. Miller, D.L. Maes, J.-P. Van de Ven, P. Orth, J.E. “Long Life Performance of Carboxylic Acid Based Coolants,” SAE 940500 1994
- Maes, J.-P. Van de Ven, P. “Corrosion Protection of Aluminum Heat Transfer Surfaces in Engine Coolants Using Monoacid/Diacid Inhibitor Technology,” Engine Coolant Testing ASTM Philadelphia 1993 11 24
- Maes, J.-P. Armstrong, R. “Antifreeze and Coolant,” Lubrication 78 2 Texaco Inc. White Plains 1992
- Darden, J.W. Triebel, C.A. Maes, J.-P. Van Neste, W. “Monoacid/Diacid Combination as Corrosion Inhibitors in Antifreeze Formulations,” World-Wide Trends in Engine Coolants, Cooling System Materials and Testing SP-811 SAE 1990 135 152
- Zangwill A. Physics at Surfaces Cambridge University Press New York 1988
- Wagner, C.D. Riggs, W.M. Davis, L.E. Moulder, J.F. Handbook of X-Ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy Muilenberd G.E. Perkin-Elmer Corp. Eden Prairie 1979
- Holman, J.P. Heat Transfer 4th McGraw-Hill New York 1976 24
- Van de Ven, P. Miller, D.L. “Increased Power Input on Aluminum Heat-Transfer Surfaces: The Effect on the Corrosion Protection Provided by Selected Engine Coolants,” ASME Meeting Youngstown April 1996