This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
On the Synergism of the Driver Air Bag and the 3-Point Belt in Frontal Collisions
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
The number of passenger vehicles with combined 3-point belt/driver air bag restraint systems is steadily increasing. To investigate the effectiveness of this restraint combination, 48 kph frontal collisions were performed with human cadavers. Each cadaver's thorax was instrumented with a 12-accelerometer array and two chest bands. The results show, that by using a combined standard 3-point belt (6% elongation)/driver air bag, the thoracic injury pattern remained located under the shoulder belt. The same observation was found when belts with 16% elongation were used in combination with the driver air bag. Chest contours derived from the chest bands showed high local compression and deformation of the chest along the shoulder belt path, and suggest the mechanism for the thoracic injuries. On the other hand, in tests where the air bag was the only available torso restraint, forces were distributed uniformly over the front of the chest; high local compression/deformation and injuries were reduced.
This study asks if it is possible to obtain both the thoracic injury mitigating benefits of an air bag only restraint and the all-impact-direction benefits of the belt from a combination restraint system by adding a force limiter to the shoulder belt. For this reason, tests with force limiters were performed. Initially, the investigation was carried out with Hybrid III dummies using two different levels of force limiters: 4 kN and 5 kN. The force limiter with the level of 4 kN showed, through examination of the chest band contours, a more bag-like uniform compression of the chest, with the belt effect only slightly pronounced. The chest compressions were 4 to 8 cm, and the resultant spinal accelerations were 30 to 40 g's.
By using the same restraint combination and force limiter, comparable vertebral accelerations and chest compressions were measured in cadaver testing. No injuries were found in the cervical spine and only an AIS 1 was observed in the thorax, for the age range of 60 to 65 years. The results also suggest that when a driver air bag is combined with a 3-point belt system that limits the torso belt loop load to 4 kN, additional injury mitigation benefits for both the cervical spine and the thorax are obtained in frontal collisions.
Analytical simulations were also conducted using different size occupants in both the baseline and the optimized belt/air bag restraint and in other crash conditions. These simulations suggest the harmonized belt/air bag also improves safety performance for other than mid-sized male occupants and does not adversely affect the performance of the restraint system in other prevalent crash configurations.
Recommended Content
Authors
Topic
Citation
Kallieris, D., Rizzetti, A., Mattern, R., Morgan, R. et al., "On the Synergism of the Driver Air Bag and the 3-Point Belt in Frontal Collisions," SAE Technical Paper 952700, 1995, https://doi.org/10.4271/952700.Also In
References
- Crandall JR Kuhlmann TP Martin PG Pilkey WD Neeman T 1994 Differing Patterns of Head and Facial Injury with Air Bag and/or Belt Restrained Drivers in Frontal Collisions Advances in Occupant Restraint Technologies 97 109
- Eppinger RH Augustyn K Robbins DH 1978 Development of a Promising Universal Thoracic Trauma Prediction Methodology SAE Paper No. 780891 , Proc. 22nd Stapp Car Crash Conf. 209 268
- Eppinger RH 1989 On the Development of a Deformation Measurement System and Its Application Toward Developing Mechanically Based Injury Indices SAE Paper No. 892426 , Proc. 33d Stapp Car Crash Conf. 21 28
- Foret-Bruno JY Hartemann F Thomas C Fayon F Tarriere C Got C Patel A 1978 Correlation Between Thoracic Lesions and Force Values Measured at the Shoulder of 92 Belted Occupants Involved in Real Accidents SAE Paper No. 780892 , Proc. 22nd Stapp Car Crash Conf. 269 292
- Huelke DF Moore JL Ostrom M 1992 Air Bag Injuries And Occupant Protection J. Trauma 33 6
- Huelke DF Moore JL Compton TW Samuels J Levine R 1994 Upper Extremity Injuries Related to Air Bag Deployments, Advances in Occupant Restraint Technologies Proc. AAAM/IRCOBI 55 78
- Kallieris D Stein KM Mattern R Morgan R Eppinger R 1994 The Performance of Active and Passive Driver Restraint Systems in Simulated Frontal Collisions SAE Paper No. 942216 , Proc. 38th Stapp Car Crash Conf. 165 175
- Kallieris D Mattern R Schmidt G Klaus G 1982 Comparison on 3-Point Belt and Airbag - Knee Bolster Systems. Injury Criteria and Injury Severity at Simulated Frontal Collisions Intern. Research Council on Biokinetics of Impact Cologne, Germany 166 183
- Kompass K 1994 Opportunities and Limits of an Air Bag Optimisation Based on the Passive Requirements of Standard 208 Paper No. 94-S4-O-08, 14th ESV Conf. Munich, Germany
- Langwieder K 1995
- Lau I Viano D 1986 The Viscous Criterion - Bases and Application of an Injury Severity Index for Soft Tissue SAE Paper No. 861882 , Proc. 30th Stapp Car Crash Conf. 123 142
- Mertz HJ Williamson JE Vander Lugt DA 1995 The Effect of Limiting Shoulder Belt Load with Air Bag Restraint SAE Paper No. 950886 185 192
- Otte D 1994 Inten. Symp. on Sophisticated Car Occupant Safety Systems 7-1 7-18 Karlsruhe, Germany
- Robbins DH Melvin JW Stalnaker RL 1976 The Prediction of Thoracic Impact Injuries SAE Paper No. 760822 , Proc. 20th Stapp Car Crash Conf. 699 729
- Schmidt G Kallieris D Barz J Mattern R Klaiber J 1975 Neck and Thorax Tolerance Levels of Belt-Protected Occupants in Head On Collisions SAE paper No. 751149, Proc. 19th Stapp Car Crash Conf. 225 257
- TNO Road-Vehicles Research Institute 1992 MADYMO User's Manual 3D, Version 5.0 Delft, The Netherlands
- TNO Road-Vehicles Research Institute 1992 MADYMO Database Manual, Version 5.0 Delft, The Netherlands
- TNO Road-Vehicles Research Institute 1992 MADYMO Applications, Version 5.0 Delft, The Netherlands
- Yoganandan N Pintar FA Skrade D Chmiel W Reinartz JM Sances A 1993 Thoracic Biomechanics With Airbag Restraint SAE Paper No. 933121 , Proc. 37th Stapp Car Crash Conf. 133 144
- Hybrid III tests were conducted at the Medical College of Wisconsin under DOT NHTSA Grant