This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Determination of Fuel Filter Efficiency Using Optical Particle Counting
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published October 01, 1995 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
To protect components from abrasive wear, modern fuel systems require fine filtration. Many current fuel filter test standards such as SAE J905 and ISO 4020 use gravimetric analysis to determine filter efficiency. Gravimetric analysis can be ambiguous when differentiating between fine filters in terms of efficiency. Furthermore, it is impossible to determine the size rating of a filter using the gravimetric method. Optical particle counting as practiced in other test standards, such as SAE J1858, has proven to be a more useful method of determining filter efficiency. Not only is optical particle counting a precise method, but it also relates efficiency to specific particle sizes. This paper illustrates the feasibility of particle counting fuel filter bottle samples to determine fuel filter efficiency.
In this study, test results determining efficiency derived from both gravimetric and particle count analysis are compared. The results show that filters with similar gravimetric efficiencies can have significantly different particle removal characteristics.
CitationFedorowicz, J., Biesen, M., Holm, C., and Schwandt, B., "Determination of Fuel Filter Efficiency Using Optical Particle Counting," SAE Technical Paper 952556, 1995, https://doi.org/10.4271/952556.
- Gifford, D. C., and Basford, K. A., “Fuel Filters for Aero Gas Turbine Engines”, Filtration & Separation, November/December, 1972, and January/February, 1973.
- Cuenca, Roy M., “Evolution of Diesel Fuel Injection Equipment - The Last 20 Years”, SAE Paper #933015, 1993.
- Roth, Gregg, “Correlation of Fuel Filtration Levels to Fuel Injector Wear and Performance Shifts”, SAE Paper #930021, presented at the SAE International Congress & Exposition, Detroit, Michigan, March 1-5, 1993.
- Bartlett, P. J., “Diesel Fuel Filtration”, Filtration & Separation, pp. 49-51, January/February, 1974.
- Bartlett, P. J., “Diesel Fuel Filter Testing”, SAE Paper #710814, 1971.
- “Fuel Filter Test Methods”, SAE J905, Society of Automotive Engineers, January, 1987.
- “Road Vehicles - Fuel Filters for Automotive Compression Engines - Part 1: Test Methods.”, ISO 4020/1, International Standards Organization, June 1979.
- “Test Method of Fuel Filters for Automobile Diesel Engines”, JIS D 1617, Japanese Industrial Standard, 1979.
- “Hydraulic Fluid Power - Fitters - Multi-Pass Method for Evaluating Filtration Performance of a Fine Filter Element”, ISO 4572, International Standards Organization.
- “Full Flow Lubricating Oil Filters Multipass Method for Evaluating Filtration Performance”, SAE J1858, Society of Automotive Engineers, June, 1988.
- Benyon, L. R., and Cranston, R. W., “Specifications and Testing of Filters and Water Separators”, The Engineer, pp. 331-338, February 26, 1960.
- “Hydraulic Fluid Power - Calibration of Liquid Automatic Particle Count Instruments - Method Using SAE Fine Test Dust”, ISO 4402, International Standards Organization, 1977.
- “Diesel Fuel and Petrol Filters for Internal Combustion Engines - Initial Efficiency by Particle Counting, Retention Capacity and Gravimetric Efficiency”, ISO TR 13353, International Standards Organization, 1994.
- “Fuel Filters - Initial Single Pass Efficiency Test Method”, SAE J1985, Society of Automotive Engineers, March, 1993.
- Hodgkins, D., “The Effect on Diesel Fuel Filtration by Environment, Condition, & Fabrication Techniques”, presented at the Fisia Congress, June 5, 1986.
- Osborne, J. E., “A Microscope Examination of the Process of Diesel Fuel Filtration”, Filtration and Separation, pp. 343-348, July/August, 1975.
- Wheeler, Donald J., Understanding Industrial Experimentation, second edition, SPC Press, 1990.
- Wheeler, Donald J., Tables of Screening Designs, second edition, SPC Press, 1990.
- “Oil Filter Test Procedure”, SAE HS J806, Society of Automotive Engineers, 1993.
- “Hydraulic Fluid Power - Method for Determining the Particulate Count of an Oil Sample from a System (Using Liquid Automatic Counters)”, NFPA/T2.9.11, National Fluid Power Association, 1989.
- Verdegan, Barry M., Stinson, Jeffrey A., and Thibodeau, Laura, “Accurate Methods for Particle Counting”, Proceedings of the 43rd National Conference on Fluid Power”, Chicago, Illinois, October 11-13, 1988.