This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
The Impact of Passenger Car Motor Oil Phosphorus Levels on Engine Durability, Oil Degradation, and Exhaust Emissions in a Field Trial
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published October 01, 1995 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
A 100,000-mile fleet test was carried out on nine 1991 gasoline-powered passenger cars employing an API SH/CD motor oil and two reduced phosphorus analogues. The lower-phosphorus oils have zinc dialkyldithiophosphate (ZDDP) treat rates that fall below the proposed ILSAC GF-2 maximum phosphorus limit (0.11%). Gaseous tail pipe emissions were measured at various intervals according to the EPA FTP City Emissions Test 75 driving cycle. A good correlation between phosphorus level and emissions degradation was obtained when starting emissions levels and oil consumption was accounted for in the analysis.
Few differences were observed between the highest-phosphorus oil (0.11%) and the lower-phosphorus (0.08% and 0.06%) oils in the typical end of test engine cleanliness parameters. There were no significant differences in either valve train or cylinder wear between the oils. The used oils had similar analytical inspections. However, the 0.11% phosphorus oil did have a lower average viscosity increase than the 0.06% phosphorus oil. This was ascribed to lower oxidative thickening for this oil.
CitationCulley, S. and McDonnell, T., "The Impact of Passenger Car Motor Oil Phosphorus Levels on Engine Durability, Oil Degradation, and Exhaust Emissions in a Field Trial," SAE Technical Paper 952344, 1995, https://doi.org/10.4271/952344.
- Giacomazzi R.A. Homfeld M.F. “The Effect of Lead, Sulfur, and Phosphorus on the Deterioration of Two Oxidizing Bead-Type Catalysts,” SAE Paper 730595 1973
- Koenig A. Hellbach H. Doering G. “Fuel, Oil and High Temperature Effects on Noble-Metal Oxidation Catalysts,” SAE 741059 1974
- McConnell R.J. McDonnell T.F. “Fuel and Lubricant Effects on Oxidizing Catalysts,” SAE 730597 1973
- Gallopoulos N.E. Summers J.C. Klimisch R.L. “Effects of Engine Oil Composition on the Activity of Exhaust Emissions Oxidation Catalysts,” SAE 730598 1973
- Bouffard R.A. Waddey W.E. “Lube Effects on Exhaust Gas Oxidation Catalyst Activity,” SAE 740135 1974
- Meyers A.T. “Field Service Compatibility of Ashless and Fully Compounded Engine Oils with Two Bead-Type Oxidation Catalysts,” SAE 750448 1975
- Pless L.G. “Deposits, Wear, and Catalyst Performance with Low Ash and Ashless Engine Oils,” SAE 750900 1975
- Caracciolo F. Spearot J.A. “The Effects of Phosphorus-Containing Engine Oil Additives on Exhaust Oxidation Catalyst Degradation,” SAE 760562 1976
- Spearot J.A. Caracciolo F. “Engine Oil Phosphorus Effects on Catalytic Converter Performance in Federal Durability and High-Speed Vehicle Tests,” SAE 770637 1977
- Monroe D.R. “Phosphorus and Lead Poisoning of Pelleted Three-Way Catalysts,” SAE 800859 1980
- Sugiura K. “Present Status of Japanese Motor Oils and Extension of Oil Drain Intervals,” SAE 780953 1978
- Caracciolo F. Spearot J.A. “Engine Oil Additive Effects on the Deterioration of a Stoichiometric Emissions Control (C-4) System,” SAE 790941 1979
- Ernest M.V. Kim G. “Development of More Active and Durable Automotive Exhaust Catalysts,” SAE 800083 1980
- Adomaitis J.R. Smith J.E. Achey D.E. “Improved Pelleted Catalyst Substrates for Automotive Emissions Control,” SAE 800084 1980
- SAE Fuels and Lubricants Technical Subcommittee 1 Engine Oil/Catalyst and Oxygen Sensor Compatibility Task Force Status Report October 1985
- Inoue K. Kurahashi T. Negishi T. Akiyama K. Arimura K. Tasaka K. “Effects of Phosphorus and Ash Contents of Engine Oils on Deactivation of Monolithic Three-Way Catalysts and Oxygen Sensors,” SAE 920654 1992
- Drury C. Whitehouse S. “The Effect of Lubricant Phosphorus Level on Exhaust Emissions in a Field Trial of Gasoline Engine Vehicles,” SAE 940745 1994
- Ueda F. Sugiyama S. Arimura K. Hamaguchi S. Akiyama K. “Engine Oil Additive Effects on Deactivation of Monolithic Three-Way Catalysts and Oxygen Sensors,” SAE 940746 1994
- Harris S.W. Zahalka T.L. “A Field Test Study of Camshaft Wear in a 2.3L OHC Engine and its Correlation to the Sequence V-D Test,” SAE 831758 1983
- Harris S.W. West C.T. Zahalka T.L. “The Field Performance of API SG Oils,” SAE 892113 1989
- Burrows A.L. Korosec P.S. Malfer D.J. Yatsunami K. “Formulation of Lower Phosphorus Passenger Car Oils,” SAE 860373 1986
- Cousineau T.J. McDonnell, T.F. Jr. Witt D.G. “‘Second-Generation’ SAE 5W-30 Passenger Car Engine Oils,” SAE 861515 1986
- Smolenski D.J. Kabel R.H. “Effect of Engine Oil Zinc Dithiophosphate (ZDP) Additive Type on Cam and Lifter Wear in Taxi Service,” SAE 831760 1983
- Chamberlin W.B. Zalar F.V. “Balancing Crankcase Lubricant Performance with Catalyst Life,” SAE 841407 1984
- February 2 1995 ASTM Passenger Car Engine Oil Classification Panel Ball D.C. Effects of Poisons on Catalyst Performance