This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Aerodynamic Investigation of Wing Tip Sails
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Wing tip sails were investigated to determine potential aerodynamic improvements for a wing having an aspect ratio of 10 and a taper ratio of 0.43. The airfoil section used for the wing was an NLF- 0215 and the wing tip was rounded. Three tip sails were utilized for all investigations with each tip sail having a root chord that was 20 percent tip chord of the wing. The wing sails were mounted at the tip of the wing along the chord line. Looking along the span towards the wing root the orientation of each sail tip was the same as the wing tip. Initial studies used sails constructed from two Wortman airfoils. A generic cambered tip-sail was also investigated. Individual sail angle of attack as well as sail dihedral and anhedral were investigated. PMARC, an aerodynamic paneling code was used to predict lift, induced drag, and viscous drag with the use of a momentum integral analysis. All viscous predictions were calculated for a Re/foot = 2.19 × 106. Lift to induced drag results yield the highest values for the sail geometries that had negative decalage angles between adjoining sails. Sails with positive decalage angles between adjoining sails yielded the lowest lift to induced drag ratios. Sail dihedral and anhedral angle had a marked effect on lift to induced drag ratios. Lift to total drag results are also presented.
Recommended Content
Authors
Topic
Citation
Jarvis, J. and Selberg, B., "Aerodynamic Investigation of Wing Tip Sails," SAE Technical Paper 951432, 1995, https://doi.org/10.4271/951432.Also In
References
- Hoerner, S. F. “Fluid-Dynamic Drag: Practical Information on Aerodynamic Drag and Hydrodynamic Resistance,” S. F. Hoerner Midland Park, NJ 1958
- van Dam, C. P. “Swept Wing-Tip Shapes for Low Speed Airplanes,” SAE Paper 851770 1986
- Vijgen, P. M. H. W. van Dam. C. P. Holmes, B. J. “Sheared Wing-Tip Aerodynamics: Wind Tunnel and Computational Investigation,” Journal of Aircraft 26 3 March 1989 207 213
- Flechner, S. G. Jacobs, P. F. Whitcomb, R. T. “A High Subsonic Speed Wind Tunnel Investigation of Winglets on a Jet Transport Wing,” 1976
- Whitcomb, R. T. “A Design Approach and Selected Wind Tunnel Results at High Subsonic Speeds for Wing-Tip Mounted Winglets,” 1976
- Allen, J. G. “Vortex Drag Reduction Using Wing Tip Sails,” Cranfield Institute of Technology Bedford, England September 1976
- Spillman, J. J. “Use of Wing Tip Sails to Reduce Vortex Drag,” Aeronautical Journal 82 813 September 1978 387 395
- Spillman, J. J. Ratcliff, H. Y. McVitie, A. M. “Flight Experiment to Evaluate the Effects of Wing Tip Sales on Fuel Consumption and Handling Characteristics,” Aeronautical Journal 83 823 July 1979 279 281
- Spillman, J. J. “Wing Tip Sails; Progress to Date and Future Development,” Aeronautical Journal 91 910 December 1987 445 453
- EDS Corporation “Unigraphics,” December 1992
- McDonnell Douglas Corporation “ZON13G-Zonal Interactive Graphics for Grid Generation,” October 1991
- Maskew, B. “Prediction of Subsonic Aerodynamic Characteristics-A Case for Low-Order Panel Methods,” Journal of Aircraft 19 Feb. 1982 157 163
- Norton, F. H. “Effect of Staggering a Biplane,” 1918
- Knight, M. Noyes, R. W. “Wind Tunnel Test on a Series of Biplane Wing Models, Part III. Effects of Change sin Various Combinations of Stagger, Gap, and Decalage,” 1929
- Nenadovitch, M. Publication Scientifique et Techniques du Ministere de L'Air Paris 1936
- Olson, E. C. Selberg, B. P. “Experiemntal Determination of Improved Aerodynamic Characteristics Utilizing Biplane Wing Configureations,” Journal of Aircraft 13 April 1976 256 261
- Rhodes, M. D. Selberg, B. P. “Benefits of Dual Wings Over Single Wings for High Performance Business Airplanes,” Journal of Aircraft 21 Feb. 1984 116 127
- Rokhsaz K. Selberg, B. P. “Dual Wing Systems with Decalage Optimization,” Journal of Aircraft 23 May 1986 444 448