This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Occupant to Roof Contact: Rollovers and Drop Tests
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published February 01, 1995 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
This paper describes an analysis of roof contacts in inverted impacts. The proven methodology of lumped mass modeling is used to evaluate the effect of a number of variables on neck loading. Several parameters were evaluated including roof strength, drop height, head clearance, restraint use and stiffness, roof padding and neck stiffness.
In general, the simulation results agreed well with existing head first impact test data. However, interesting results were obtained when neck stiffness was varied to represent the difference between human-like and Hybrid III spring rates. Biomechanical data generally agrees, independent of test methodology, that the Hybrid III neck is at least 10 times as stiff as a cadaver neck. Using an approximation of the Hybrid III neck stiffness (5.25 KN/cm) generally resulted in initial neck loads exceeding “upper” human tolerance level of 6500 N. Using a neck stiffness of 10 percent of the Hybrid III resulted in neck loads below the “lower” human tolerance level of 4,000 N.
Hybrid III force levels were more or less the same independent of roof stiffness. The lower stiffness neck force levels were similar in magnitude; although, longer in duration, with a relatively weak roof. Since neck injury potential is, apparently, a function of both magnitude and duration, this modeling indicates the potential for a weak roof to increase the likelihood of injury in a rollover collision.
CitationSyson, S., "Occupant to Roof Contact: Rollovers and Drop Tests," SAE Technical Paper 950654, 1995, https://doi.org/10.4271/950654.
Advances in Occupant Protection Technologies for the Mid-Nineties
Number: SP-1077; Published: 1995-02-01
Number: SP-1077; Published: 1995-02-01
- Passenger-Car Roof and Windshield Header Construction : Klove, E. H. Ropers G.W. SAE Technical Paper No. 690069
- Dolly Rollover Recommended Test Procedure : SAE / J2114 April 1993 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA (USA) 1993
- Injury Mechanisms in Rollover Collisions : Hight, Philip V. Siegel, Arnold W. Nahum, Alan M. SAE Transactions 81 1972 SAE Technical Paper No. 720417
- Roof Collapse and the Risk of Severe Head and Neck Injury : Friedman, Donald Friedman, Keith D. 13th Experimental Safety Vehicle Conference Paris, France 1991
- Rollover Testing : Wilson, Richard A. Gannon, R. R. SAE Technical Paper No. 720495
- Rollover Crash Tests - The Influence of Roof Strength of Injury Mechanics : Orlowski, Kenneth F. Bundorf, R. Thomas Moffatt, Edward A. SAE Technical Paper No. 851734
- Rollover and Drop Tests - The Influence of Roof Strength on Injury Mechanics Using Belted Dummies : Balding, G.S. Bundorf, R.T. Kaspzyk, G.S. Moffatt, E.A. Orlowski, K.F. Stocke, J.E. SAE Transactions 99 1990 SAE Technical Paper No. 902314
- Hybrid III - A Biomechanically-Based Crash Test Dummy : Foster, J. King Kortge, James O. Wolanin, Michael J. SAE Transactions 86 1977 SAE Technical Paper No. 770938
- Injury Criteria and Mathematical Analogs for Selected Body Areas : Eppinger, Rolf H. NHTSA July 6 1982
- An Examination of the Correlation Between Vehicle Performance in FMVSS 216 Versus Injury Rates in Rollover Accidents : Plastiras, Joan K. Lange, Robert C. Thomas, Terry M. SAE Technical Paper No. 850335
- Field Studies of Rollover Performance : Mackay, G. Murray Tampen, I.D. SAE Technical Paper No. 700417
- The Effectiveness of Belt Systems in Frontal and Rollover Crashes : Huelke, Donald F. Lawson, Thomas E. Scott, Robert Marsh, Joseph C. IV 86 1977 SAE Technical Paper No. 770148
- Mechanical Analysis of Survival in Falls From Heights of Fifty to One Hundred and Fifty Feet : DeHaven, Hugh War Medicine 2 586 596 July 1942
- Crash Survival Space is Needed in Vehicle Passenger Compartments : Franchini, E. SAE Technical Paper No. 690005
- Occupant Motion in Rollover Collisions : Moffatt, Edward A. Proceedings of 19th Conference of the American Association for Automotive Medicine 1975
- Biomechanical Evaluation of the Axial Compressive Responses of the Human Cadaveric and Manikin Necks : Yoganandan, N. Sances, A. Jr. Pintar, F. 111 Journal of Biomechanical Engineering August 1989
- The Hybrid III Anthropometric Neck in the Evaluation of Head First Collisions : Bishop, Patrick J. Wells, Richard SAE Technical Paper No. 860201
- Biodynamics of the Total Human Cadaveric Cervical Spine : Pintar, F. A. Sances, A., Jr. Yoganandan, N. Reinartz, J. Maiman, D.J. Shu, J.K. Unger, G. Cusick, J.F. Larson, S.J. SAE Technical Paper No. 902309
- The Influence of End Condition on Human Cervical Spine Injury Mechanisms : Myer, B.S. McElhaney, J.H. Nightingale, R.W. Richardson, W.J. Doherty, B.J. SAE Transactions 10 1991 SAE Technical Paper No. 912915
- Global Viewpoints: Ford Mondeo : Jost, K. Birch, S. Automotive Engineering 101 3
- Analysis and Simulation of Vehicle to Barrier Impact : Kamal, M.M. SAE Technical Paper No. 700414
- Validation of the Crash Victim Simulator : Calspan Corporation
- Seat Dynamic Parameters for Ride Quality : Berger, E. Gilmore, J. SAE Technical Paper No. 930115
- Design and Development of Modified Production Vehicle for Enhanced Crash-Worthiness and Fuel Economy - Phase II : Schwartz, R. Forrest, S. MCR Technology; Contract DTNH22-81-C-07085
- Belt Restraint Systems Design Procedure/Performance : “Injury Assessment Values Currently Defined for Evaluating Lap/Shoulder Belted Hybrid III Response Measurements” Mertz, H.J. General Motors Corp. December 1981
- An Investigation of Seat Belt Buckle Dynamic Response to Inertial Loading Conditions : Thomas, T. Limbert, D. Lange, R. Failure Analysis Associates, Inc.
- Rollover Crash Tests to Evaluate Seatbelt Buckle Inertial Loading : Moffatt, E.A. Thomas, T.M. Lange, R.C. Society of Automotive Engineers TOPTEC Dearborn, MI August 1993