This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Experimental Validation of 1-D Modelling Codes for a Pipe System Containing Area Discontinuities
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published February 01, 1995 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
This paper reports on the first phase of an experimental evaluation of four different methods for the mathematical modelling of unsteady gas flow in a pipe system containing an area discontinuity. The four methods under investigation are the non-homentropic method of characteristics, the two-step Lax-Wendroff method with flux corrected transport, the Harten-Lax-Leer upstream difference method and the GPB finite system method.
The experimentation is conducted using the QUB SP (single-pulse) pressure wave generator consisting of a cylinder, connected via a sliding valve to a long duct. The pressure waves it creates closely mimic those to be found in i.c. engines. The initial cylinder pressure may be set to simulate either an induction or an exhaust process. Various ducts are attached to the pressure wave generator to simulate both sudden and gradual area changes. Each duct is sufficiently long as to permit pressure wave observation without superposition effects. Pressure and temperature are recorded at various locations in the apparatus and stored using a high speed data acquisition system.
A computer simulation of the test apparatus has been written for each of the four theoretical methods incorporating the Queen's University of Belfast (QUB) non-isentropic treatment of the boundary conditions. The accuracy of each prediction method is then correlated with the experimental results.
The new non-isentropic formulation of the sudden area change boundary condition is demonstrated to be accurate for each of the sudden enlargements and contractions tested. It is shown that the non-homentropic method of characteristics is unsuitable for predicting flow in steep diffusers, while the GPB finite system method is demonstrated to be the most accurate in this situation.
CitationBlair, G., Kirkpatrick, S., Mackey, D., and Fleck, R., "Experimental Validation of 1-D Modelling Codes for a Pipe System Containing Area Discontinuities," SAE Technical Paper 950276, 1995, https://doi.org/10.4271/950276.
Evaluations in Two-Stroke Engines and Their Emissions
Number: SP-1064; Published: 1995-02-01
Number: SP-1064; Published: 1995-02-01
- Kirkpatrick S.J. Blair G.P. Fleck R. McMullan R.K. “Experimental Evaluation of 1-D Computer Codes for the Simulation of Unsteady Gas Flow Through Engines - A First Phase” SAE International Off-Highway Meeting Milwaukee September 1994 SAE Paper No. 941685 18
- Blair G.P. Kirkpatrick S.J. Fleck R. “Experimental Evaluation of a 1-D Computer Codes for a Pipe Containing Gas of Varying Properties” SAE Automotive Congress Detroit March 1995
- Trengrouse G.H. Soliman M.M. “Effect of Sudden Changes in Flow Area on Pressure Waves of Finite Amplitude” J.Mech. Eng. Sci. 8 2 1966 198 206
- MacClaren J.F.T. Tramschek A.B. Pastrana O.F. “A Study of Boundary Conditions Encountered in Reciprocating Compressor Systems” Compressor Technology Conference 1976
- Benson R.S. Horlock J.H. Winterbone D.E. “The Thermodynamics and Gas Dynamics of Internal Combustion Engines” 1 Clarendon Press Oxford 1982
- Lax P.D. Wendroff B. “Systems of Conservation Laws” Communs. Pure Appl. Math. 15 1960 217 237
- Richtmyer R.D. Morton K.W. “Difference Methods for Initial Value Problems” 2nd John Wiley & Sons, Inc. 1967
- Ikeda T. Nakagawa T. “On the SHASTA FCT Algorithm for the Equation ” Maths. Comput. 33 148 October 1979 1157 1169
- Harten A. Lax P.D. Van Leer B. “On Upstream Differencing and Gudunov-type Schemes for Hyperbolic Conservation Laws” SIAM Rev. 25 1983 35 61
- Gudunov S.K. “A Difference Scheme for Numerical Computation of Discontinuous Solutions of Equations of Fluid Dynamics” Mat. Sb. 47 1959 271 290
- Chen C. Veshagh A. Wallace F.J. “A Comparison Between Alternative Methods for Gas Flow and Performance Prediction of Internal Combustion Engines” SAE International Off-Highway & Powerplant Congress Milwaukee, Wisconsin September 14 - 17 1992 SAE Paper No. 921734 32
- Blair G.P. “An Alternative Method for the Prediction of Unsteady Gas Flow Through the Internal Combustion Engine” SAE International Off-Highway & Powerplant Congress Milwaukee, Wisconsin September 9 - 12 1991 SAE Paper No. 911850 137 162
- Blair G.P. “Correlation of an Alternative Method for the Prediction of Engine Performance Characteristics with Measured Data” SAE International Congress Detroit, Michigan March 1993 SAE Paper No. 930501 20
- Blair G.P. “Correlation of Measured and Calculated Performance Characteristics of Motorcycle Engines” Funfe Zweiradtagung Technische Universitat Graz, Austria 22 - 23 April 1993 5 16
- Blair G.P. Magee S.J. “Non-Isentropic Analysis of Varying Area Flow in Engine Ducting” SAE International Off-Highway & Powerplant Congress Milwaukee, Wisconsin September 13 - 16 1993 SAE Paper No. 932399 77 94
- Blair G.P. “Non-Isentropic Analysis of Branched Flow in Engine Ducting” SAE International Congress Detroit, Michigan March 1994 SAE Paper No. 940395 55 72
- Blair G.P. “The Basic Design of Two-Stroke Engines” SAE Chapter 2 ‘The Theory of Unsteady Gas Flow Through Engines’ 2nd 1995 141
- Kirkpatrick S.J. “An Evaluation of One-Dimensional Simulation Techniques for Predicting Unsteady Gas Flow in Engine Ducting” Dept. Mech. and Manuf. Eng., The Queen's University of Belfast September 1994