This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Intentional Acts of Violence in Motor Vehicles: Suicide and Murder
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Many fatal vehicle crashes are intentional acts to cover an act of suicide or murder. Some experts estimate that this total can be as large as 10% to 25% of all motor vehicle fatals. The stigma attached to suicide causes families to conceal the details, notes, threats, etc. to authorities. Today's society takes vehicle accidents as a matter of fact and injuries resulting from them. Consequently, a staged crash is not always examined in detail to determine the causal factors which include murder. This is particularly true of single vehicle crashes in which the driver, the only occupant, is dead. Police may assume that since the deceased brought about their own demise that no additional investigation is necessary. The unfortunate result of reporting these incidents as “accidents” results in inappropriate insurance payouts which affect rates and inflate the fatal statistics that are used to enact vehicle regulations. The latter can increase the manufacturering costs of vehicles.
The objective of this paper is to make the public aware of the use of a motor vehicle as a means of self destruction and murder by describing a number of actual events. Unfortunately, in most cases public recognition of the intentional act will be after the event has occurred. Insurance carriers and vehicle crash data collectors need to be able to identify and separate these events from their “accident” files. Hopefully, identifying the profiles of suicidal drivers may also lead to the appropriate medical & psychological treatments needed to save the lives of some symptomatic individuals.
Recommended Content
Authors
Topic
Citation
Nelson, W., "Intentional Acts of Violence in Motor Vehicles: Suicide and Murder," SAE Technical Paper 940725, 1994, https://doi.org/10.4271/940725.Also In
References
- Traffic Accident Investigator's Manual for Police” Baker J. Stannard 1963 Northwestern University
- “Traffic Accident Investigation Manual” Baker J. Stannard 1975 The Traffic Institute, Northwestern University
- “Traffic Accident Reconstruction” 2 Fricke Lynn B. 1990 Northwestern University Traffic Institute
- “If you're Over 65 and Feeling Depressed” U. S. Department of Health and Human Services Colt, George Howe THE ENIGMA OF SUICIDE 1991 309
- Motto, J. A. Heilbron, D. C. Juster, R. P. “Suicide Risk Assessment: Development of a Clinical Instrument” World Psychiatric Assoc. 7th World Congress of Psychiatry Vienna, Austria July 10-16 1983
- Goldman, D. A. A ten year test of the Beck Depression Inventory “Test is Called Successful in Predicting Suicides” The NY Times Feb. 10 1985 35
- Patterson, W. M. et al “Evaluation of Suicidal Patients: The SAD PERSONS Scale” 1983 Pyschosomatics 24 4 343 49
- Greist, J. H. et al “A Computer Interview for Suicide-Risk Prediction” 1973 American Journal of Psychiatry 130 12 1327 32
- Haberman, Paul W. Baden, Michael M. “Alcohol and Other Drugs in Suicides, Homicides and Fatal Accidents” 1977 Annual Meeting on Alcohol and Drug Problems Association of North America; Research and Training Section, NIAAA Grant No.: 2-RP1-AA00303
- Heilbroner, David “Rough Justice, Days and Nights of a Young D.A.” 1990 Pantheon Books NY
- U. S. Department of Health and Human Services, Public Health Service, Alcohol, Drug Abuse, and Mental Health Administration, Pamphlet “IF YOU'RE OVER 65 AND FEELING DEPRESSED” 12 DHHS pub. No. (ADM) 90-1653
- The Columbia University College of Physicians & Surgeons Complete Home Guide to Mental Health 1992
- Weiner, I The effectiveness of a suicide prevention program Ment. Hyg 53 357 363 1969
- Lester, D Evaluation of suicide prevention centers International Behavioral Scientist 3 40 47 1971
- Lester, D The myth of suicide prevention Compr. Psychiatry 13 555 560 1972
- Whittemore, K Ten Centers Atlanta Lullwater Press 1970
- Murphy, G.E. Wetzel, R.D. Swallows, C.S. et al Who calls the suicide prevention center: a study of 55 persons calling on their own behalf Am. J. Psychiatry 126 314 324 1969
- Slack, W.V. Hick, G.P. Reed C.E. et al A computer-based medical history system New Engl. J. Med. 247 194 198 1966
- Grossman, J.H. Barnett, G.O. McGuire, M.T. et al Evaluation of computer-acquired patient histories JAMA 215 1286 1291 1971
- Warner, H.R. Experiences with computer-based patient monitoring Anesth. Analg. 47 453 461 1968
- Lewis, F.J. Deller, S. Quinn, M. et al Continuous patient monitoring with a small digital computer Comput. Biomed. Res. 5 411 428 1972
- Bleich, H.L. Computer evaluation of acid-base disorders J. Clin. Invest. 48 1689 1696 1969
- Bleich, H.L. The computer as a consultant New Engl. J. Med. 284 141 146 1971
- Menn, S.J. Barnett, G.O. Schmechel, D. et al Computer program in respiratory failure JAMA 223 308 312 1973
- Ledle, R.S. Lusted, L.B. The use of electronic computers to aid medical diagnosis Proceedings of the Institute of Radio Engineers 47 1960 1965 1959
- Gustafson, D.H. Edwards, W. Phillips, L.D. et al Subjective probabilities in medical diagnosis IEEE Transactions on Man-Machine Systems 10 61 65 1969
- Gustafson, D.H. Kestly, J.J. Greist, J. H. et al Initiated evaluation of a subjective Bayesian diagnostic system Health Serv. Res. 86 204 213 1971
- Jacquez, A. Computer Diagnosis and Diagnostic Methods: Proceedings of the Second Conference on the Diagnostic Process University of Michigan Ann Arbor, Mich. Springfield, Ill Charles C Thomas 1972
- Engle, R.C. Jr Computer-Aided Differential Diagnosis of Hematologic Diseases: Digest of the Seventh International Conference on Medical and Biological Engineering Aug 11-18 1967 Stockholm, Sweden 194
- Slovic, P. Lichenstein, S. Comparison of Bayesian and regression approaches to the Study of information processing in judgment Oregon Research Institute Monograph No 10 Oregon Research Institute 1971
- Van de Ven, A. Delbecq, A. Nominal and interacting groups for committee decision-making effectiveness Journal of the Academy of Management 14 203 212 1971
- Gustafson, D.H. Kestly, J.J. Ludke, R.L. et al Probabilistic information processing implementation and evaluation of a semi-pip diagnostic system Comput Biomed Res
- Gustafson, D.H. Shukla, B.K. Delbecq, A. et al A comparative study of differences in subjective likelihood estimates made by individuals, interacting groups, delphi groups, and nominal groups Organizational Behavior and Human Performance 9 280 291 1973
- Weisman, A.D. Worden, J.W. Risk-rescue rating in suicide assessment Arch. Gen. Psychiatry 26 553 560 1972
- Rinaldo, J.A. Scheinok, P. Rupe, C.E. Symptom diagnosis: a mathematical analysis of epigastric pain Ann. Intern. Med. 59 145 154 1963
- Croft, D.J. Is computerized diagnosis possible? Comput Biomed Res. 5 351 367 1972
- Pipberger, H.V. Klingeman, J.O. Cosma, J. Computer evaluation of statistical properties of clinical information in the differential diagnosis of chest pain Methods Inf. Med. 7 79 91 1968
- Struve, F.A. Klein, D.F. Saraf, K.R. Electroencephalographic correlates of suicide ideation and attempts Arch. Gen. Psychiatry 27 363 365 1972
- Bunney, W.E. Jr Fawcett, J.A. Davis, J.M. et al Further evaluation of urinary 17-hydroxycorticosteroids in suicidal patients Arch. Gen. Psychiatry 21 138 150 1969
- Litman, R.E. Swearingen, C. Bondage and suicide Arch. Gen. Psychiatry 27 80 85 1972
- Resnick, H.L.P. Kaplan HI Freedman AM Sadock BJ Comprehensive Textbook of Psychiatry 3 Baltimore Williams & Wilkins 1980 2085 2098
- Farberow, N.L. Litman, R.E. Resnick, H.L.P. Ruben, H.L. Emergency Psychiatric Care Bowie, Md Charles Press 1975 103 188
- Tuckman, J. Youngman, W.F. A scale for assessing suicide risk of attempted suicides J. Clin. Psycho. 24 17 19 1968
- Guze, S. Robins, E. Suicide and primary affective disorder Br. J. Psychiatry 117 437 463 1970
- Avery, D. Winokur, G. Suicide, attempted suicide and relapse rates in depression Arch. Gen. Psychiatry 35 749 753 1978
- Robins, E. Murphy, G.E. Wilkinson, R.H. et al Some clinical considerations in the prevention of suicide based on a study of 134 successful suicides Am. J. Public Health 49 888 899 1959
- Miles, C.P. Conditions predisposing to suicide: A review J. Nerv. Ment. Disease 164 231 246 1977
- Minkoff, K. Bergman, E. Beck, A.T. et al. Hopelessness, depression and attempted suicide Am. J. Psychiatry 130 455 459 1973
- Patei, N.S. Attempted and completed suicide Med. Sci. Law 14 273 279 1974
- Peterson, A. Arvad, G. Kindler, A. Epidemiological differences between white and nonwhite suicide attempts Am. J. Psychiatry 130 1071 1076 1973
- Ettlinger, R.W. Suicides in a group of patients who had previously attempted suicide Acta. Psychiatr. Scand. 40 363 378 1964
- Porterfield, A.L. Ecological correlates of alcoholism Societal Probs. 5 326 338 1958
- Litman, R.E. Farberow, N.L. Wold, C.I. et al Prediction models of suicidal behaviors Beck, A.T. Resnick, H.L.P. Lettieri, D.J. Prediction of Suicide Bowie, Md. Charles Press 1974 141 159
- Robins, E. Gassner, S. Kayes, J. et al The communication of suicidal intent: A study of 134 consecutive cases of successful (completed) suicide Am. J. Psychiatry 115 724 733 1959
- Rosen, D.H. The serious suicide attempt JAMA 235 2105 2109 1976
- Dorpat, T. Anderson, W.F. Ripley, H.S. The relationship of physical illness to suicide Resnick, H.L.P. Suicidal Behaviors Boston Little Brown 1968 209 219
- Pokorny, A.D. Kaplan, H.B. Suicide following psychiatric hospitalization J. Nerv. Mert. Dis. 162 119 125 1976
- Wenz, F.V. Effect of seasons and sociological variables on suicidal behavior Public Health Rep. 92 233 239 1977
- Stallone, F. Dunner, D.L. Ahearn, .J et al Statistical predictions of suicide in depressives Compr. Psychiatry 21 381 387 1980
- Bedrosian, R. C. Beck, A.T. Cognitive aspects of suicidal behavior Suicide Life Threat Behav. 9 87 96 1979
- Beck, A.T. Kovacs, J. Weissman, A. Assessment of suicidal intention: The scale of suicidal ideation J. Consult. Clin. Psychol. 47 343 352 1979
- Pierce, D.W. Suicidal Intent in Self Injury Br. J. Psychiatry 130 377 385 1977
- Buglass, D. Horton, J. A scale for predicting subsequent suicidal behavior Br. J. Psychiatry 124 573 578 1974
- Farberow, N.L. McKinnon, D. A suicide prediction schedule for neuropsychiatrlc hospital patients J. Nerv. Ment. Dis. 158 408 419 1974
- Weilsman, A.D. Worden, J.W Risk-rescue-rating in suicide assessment Arch. Gen. Psychiatry 26 553 560 1972
- Bagley, C. Greer, S. Clinical and social predictors of repeated attempted suicide: A multivariate analysis Br. J. Psychiatry 119 515 521 1971
- Dressler, D.M. Prusoff, B. Mark, H. et al Clinical attitudes toward the suicide attempter J. Nerv. Mental Dis. 160 146 155 1975
- Maltsberger, J.T. Buie, D.H. Countertransference hate in the treatment of the suicidal patient Arch. Gen. Psychiatry 30 625 633 1974