This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Comparison of Modeling Techniques for Flexible Dummy Parts
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published November 01, 1993 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
Event: Stapp Car Crash Conference
An important requisite for an effective use of numerical tools in occupant safety assessment is that suitable models of crash victims are available. Reliable well validated multibody models of several crash dummies have been developed in the last two decades. Flexible parts are modeled as rigid bodies interconnected by joints that account for the flexibility. Recently the finite element method has been used for modeling such parts. In this paper an alternative method is proposed namely as a flexible body with distributed mass and stiffness.
To evaluate these methods, three models of a rib module of a EUROSID-1 dummy are compared with the rib modeled as:
- a chain of nine rigid bodies interconnected by revolute joints, and torsional springs and dampers,
- one flexible body with the deformation approximated by one predefined displacement mode,
- a finite element model using triangular shell elements with a linear elastic material behavior and mass proportional Rayleigh damping.
The numerical results are validated using EUROSID-1 rib module lateral and oblique impactor tests. In these tests the rib module is fixed vertically on one end and the other end is impacted by a falling mass. The models are evaluated with respect to their modeling capabilities and computational efficiency.
It is concluded that the three models can be used to analyze impacts from relevant directions. The displacement modes for the flexible body model can be obtained from finite element analyses or from experiments. The latter approach does not require a detailed description of the flexible structure and its material behavior. The finite element model requires considerably more computation time as compared to the multibody models.
CitationKoppens, W., Lupker, H., and Rademaker, C., "Comparison of Modeling Techniques for Flexible Dummy Parts," SAE Technical Paper 933116, 1993, https://doi.org/10.4271/933116.
- EUROSID-1 User's Manual TNO Road-Vehicles Research Institute Delft, The Netherlands 1990
- Prasad, P. Chou, C.C. “A Review of Mathematical Occupant Simulation Models” Crashworthiness and Occupant Protection in Transportation Systems AMD 106 95 112 ASME winter annual meeting San Francisco 1989
- Heinz, M. Pletschen, B. Wester, H. Scharnhorst, T. “An Advanced 50 th Percentile Hybrid III-Dummy Database: Validation SAE 910658 International Congress and Exposition Detroit 1991
- Philippens, M. Nieboer, J.J. Wismans, J. “An Advanced Database of the 50th Percentile Hybrid III-Dummy” SAE 910813 International Congress and Exposition Detroit 1991
- Lupker, H.A. de Coo, P.J.A. Nieboer, J.J. Wismans, J. “Advances in MADYMO Crash Simulations” SAE 910879 International Congress and Exposition Detroit 1991
- Kirkpatrick, S.W. Holmes, B.S. Hollowell, W.T. Gabler, H.C. Trella, T.J. “Finite Element Modeling of the Side Impact Dummy (SID)” SAE 930104 International Congress and Exposition Detroit 1993
- Low, T.C. Prasad, P. “Dynamic Response and Mathematical Model of the Side Impact Dummy” 34 th Stapp Car Crash Conference SAE 902321 Orlando 1990
- Koppens, W.P. Sauren, A.A.H.J. Veldpaus, F.E. Campen, D.H. van “The Dynamics of a Deformable Body Experiencing Large Displacements” J. of Applied Mechanics 55 676 680 1988
- MADYMO-3D User's Manual TNO Road-Vehicles Research Institute Delft, The Netherlands 1992
- Lupker, H.A. Helleman, H.B. Fraterman, E. Wismans, J. “The MADYMO Finite Element Airbag Model” 13 th International Conference on Experimental Safety Vehicles Paris 1991
- MADYMO Databases TNO Road-Vehicles Research Institute Delft, The Netherlands 1993