This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
The Seat Belt Syndrome in Children
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Lap belts, fitted to the centre seats of Australian cars for the past twenty-two years, have come under criticism as being injurious to children. The weight of evidence is that lap belts provide substantial protection, though less than three-point belts. A specific injury, the seat belt syndrome (SBS), to abdominal viscera and/or lumbar spine has been particularly associated with lap belts, an association confirmed by a hospital-based study in Melbourne. Roadside observations of belt use and Transport Accident Commission claims permitted the calculation of the incidence of SBS and the relative risks of SBS by seated position. The centre rear seat (lap belt) carried about twice the risk of SBS as outboard rear seats (three-point belts) which in turn have 2.7 times the risk of the outboard front seat. The number of SBS cases in Victoria has increased with penetration of the car fleet by 1971 and later cars. Suggestions are made for improvements in the restraint system.
Recommended Content
Technical Paper | Crash Protection for Rear Seat Occupants |
Technical Paper | Usability Trials of Alternative Child Restraint Attachment Systems |
Technical Paper | The Nature of Seat Belt Injuries |
Authors
Citation
Lane, J., "The Seat Belt Syndrome in Children," SAE Technical Paper 933098, 1993, https://doi.org/10.4271/933098.Also In
References
- Agran P F Dunkle D E Winn D G 1985 Motor vehicle Accident traumaand restraint usage patterns in children less than 4 years of age Pediatrics 76 382 386
- Agran P F Dunkle D E Winn D G 1987 Injuries to a sample of seat-belted children evaluated and treated in a hospital emergency room The Journal of Trauma 27 58 64
- Agran P F Winn D G 1987 Traumatic injuries among children [ILLEGIBLE] belts and lap/shoulder belts in motor vehicle collisions 31st Proceedings, American Association for Automotive Medicine 283 296
- Agran P F Winn D G Dunkle D E 1989 Injuries among 4 to 9 year old restrained motor vehicle occupants by seat location and crash impact site American Journal Diseases of Children 143 1317 1321
- Agran P F Castillo D Winn D G 1990 Childhood motor vehicle occupant injuries American Journal Diseases of Children 144 653 662
- Anderson P A Rivara F P Maier R V Drake C 1991 The epidemiology of seat belt-associated injuries The Journal of Trauma 31 1 60 67
- Corben C W. Herbert D C 1981 Children wearing approved restraints and adult's belts in crashes Traffic Accident Research Unit Report 1/8 1 Department of Motor Transport New South Wales. Australia
- Evans L Frick M C 1988 Seating position in cars and fatality risk American Journal of Public Health 78 11 1456 1458
- Fildes B N Lane J C Lenard J Vulcan A P 1991 Passenger Cars and Occupant Injury Report No. CR 95 Federal Office of Road Safety Canberra
- Garrett J W Braunstein P W 1962 The seat belt syndrome The Journal of Trauma 2 230 238
- Haland Y Nilson G 1991 Seat belt pretensioners to avoid the risk of submarining - a study of lap-belt slippage factors Thirteenth International Technical Conference on Experimental Safety Vehicles
- Hoy G A Cole W G 1992 Concurrent paediatric seat belt injuries of the abdomen and spine Pediatric Surgery International 7 376 379
- Kahane C J 1987 Fatality and injury reducing effectiveness of lap belts for back seat occupants SAE Paper 870486 Restraint Technologies: Rear Seat Occupant Protection. SP-691 45 52
- Krafft M Nygren C Tingvall C 1989 Rear seat occupant protection. A study of children and adults in the rear seat of cars in relation to restraint use and car characteristics 12th International Conference on Experimental Safety Vehicles 2 1145 1149 Journal of Traffic Medicine 1990 18 2 51 53
- Kulowski J Rost W B 1956 In tra-abdominal injury from safety belt in auto accidents Archives of Surgery 73 970 971
- Lane, J C 1992 The child in the center seat Report CR 107 Federal Office of Road Safety Canberra
- Langwieder K. Hummel T 1989 Children in cars - their injury risks and the influence of child protection systems 12th International Conference on Experimental Safety Vehicles. NHTSA, US Department of Transportation 39 49
- Lutter G Kramer F Appel H 1991 Evaluation of child safety systems on the basis of suitable assessment criteria Proceedings IRCOBI Conference 157 169
- Morris J B 1983 Protection for 5-12 year old children SAE Paper 831654 SAE Child injury and restraint Conference Proceedings
- National Transportation Safety Board 1986 Performance of lap belts in 26 frontal crashes Report no. NTSB/SS-86/03 United States Government Washington DC
- Orsay E M Turnbull T L Dunne M Barrett J A Langenberg P Orsay C P 1989 The effect of occupant restraints on children and the elderly in motor vehicle crashes 12th International Technical Conference on Experimental Safefy Vehicles 2 1213 1215
- Partyka S 1988 Lives saved by child restraints from 1982 through 1987 Technical report HS 807 37 1 NHTSA, Department of Transportation
- Rutherford W H Greenfield T Hayes H R Nelson J K 1985 The medical effects of seat belt legislation in the United Kingdom Research Report No. 13 Department of Health & Social Security, Her Majesty's Stationery Office
- Rutledge R Thomason M Oller D Meredith W Moylan J Clancy T Cunningham P Baker C 1991 The spectrum of abdominal injuries associated with the use of seat belts The Journal of Trauma 31 6 820 826
- Tunbridge R J 1989 The long term effect of seat belt legislation on road user injury patterns Research Report 239 Transport & Road Research Laboratory, Department of Transport
- Turbell T 1990 Safety of children in cars - Use of child restraint systems in Sweden Swedish Road & Traffic Research Institute, VTI