This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Risk Analysis for Setting Drinking Water Standards for Long-Term Space Missions
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
In spacecraft life support systems which are partially or fully closed, the air and water systems have sufficient interaction that contaminants in one system may become contaminants in the other. Life support system designers typically consider these media separately. In order to develop plausible and appropriate drinking water contaminant standards for longer-term NASA space missions, we performed a human health risk characterization using toxicological and exposure values typical of space operations and crew. It showed that the greatest waterborne health concern was from acute microbial infection leading to incapacitating gastrointestinal illness. While substantial data gaps exist for toxicities and exposures, ingestion exposure pathways for toxic materials yielded de minimus acute health risks unlikely to affect SEI space missions. Risks of chronic health problems from the relatively short exposures of expected space missions were within acceptable public health limits. A discussion of the interactions between the air and water subsystems in a closed life support system, and the effect on a risk characterization such as this is included.
Our analysis indicates that current Space Station Freedom maximum contamination levels may be unnecessarily strict. We propose alternative drinking water contaminant values consistent with both acceptable short and long-term crew health safety. Since spacecraft drinking water treatment hardware designs are based on achieving drinking water contaminant goals, simplification of those goals allows for reconsideration of treatment designs. Consideration should be given to an integrated design for the air and water life support systems that encompasses protection for cross-media contamination.
Authors
Citation
Macler, B. and Cantwell, E., "Risk Analysis for Setting Drinking Water Standards for Long-Term Space Missions," SAE Technical Paper 932094, 1993, https://doi.org/10.4271/932094.Also In
References
- Bagdigian RM Carter DL Holder DW McGriff CF Roman MC Traweek MS Williams WR 1992 Space Station Freedom environmental control and life support system phase III water recovery test stages 1A, 2A and 3A final report NASA Tech Memo 103564
- Bennett JV Holmberg SD Rogers MF Solomon SL 1987 Infectious and parasitic diseases Am J Prev Med 3 102 114 In Amler RW Dull HB Closing the gap: the burden of unnecessary illness Oxford University Press
- Brockett RM et al 1974 Skylab environmental and crew microbiological studies In The proceedings of the Skylab Life Sciences Symposium I NASA Tech Memo JSC-09275 121 143
- Carter DL Cole H Habercom M Griffith G 1992 Determination of organic carbon and ionic accountability of various waste and product waters derived from ECLSS water recovery tests and Spacelab humidity condensate SAE Technical Paper # 921313 22d International Conference on Environmental Systems SAE International Warrendale, PA
- Carter DL Holder DW McGriff CF 1993 Space Station Freedom environmental control and life support system Phase III water recovery test Stage 7 final report NASA
- Center for Space Environmental Health Interim report June 30 1992
- Code of Federal Regulations 1992 National Primary Drinking Water Regulations, 40 CFR 141 US Office of the Federal Register Washington, DC
- Dias W Bourke R 1991 A risk-based approach to robotic mission requirements Am Inst Aero Astro 91 3013
- James JT Coleman MC 1992 Toxicology of airborne gaseous and particlate contaminants in space habitats In Foundations of Space Biology and Medicine American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics Washington, DC
- Janik DS Sauer RL Thorstenson YR 1987 Medical effects of iodine disinfection products in spacecraft water J Aerospace Transact. 96 689 692
- Janik DS Sauer RL Pierson DL Thorstenson YR 1987 Quality requirements for reclaimed/recycled water NASA Tech Memo 58279
- Limero TF Taylor RD Pierson DL James JT 1990 Space Station Freedom as a “tight building” SAE Tech Paper 901382 SAE International Warrendale, PA
- National Aeronautics and Space Admn 1991 Man-Systems Integration Standards STD 3000 Rev A 4 June 1991
- National Research Council 1977-1989 Drinking water and health 1-9 National Academy Press Washington, DC
- National Research Council 1992 Guideline for developing Spacecraft Maximum Allowable Concentrations for space station contaminants National Academy Press Washington, DC
- National Research Council 1992a Chemical water quality and monitoring requirements of reclaimed water for Space Station Freedom National Academy Press Washington, DC
- Nicogossian AE Huntoon CL Pool SL 1989 Space physiology and medicine 2d Lea and Febiger Philadelphia, PA
- Pierson DL 1982 Medical microbiology of crewmembers and spacecraft during OFT In Pool SL Johnson PC Jr Mason JA Shuttle OFT medical report, NASA Tech Memo 58252 49 52
- Regli S Rose JB Haas CN Gerba CP 1991 Modeling the risk from Giardia and viruses in drinking water J. Am Water Works Assoc 83 76 84
- Rippstein WJ Jr Schneider HJ 1974 Toxicological aspects of the Skylab program In The proceedings of the Skylab Life Sciences Symposium I NASA Tech Memo JSC-09275 157 168
- Roman MC Wilson ME Jackson NE Gauthier JJ Kilgore BA Huff TL Obenhuber DC Terrell DW 1991 Microbial distribution in the environmental control and life support system water recovery test conducted at NASA, MSFC SAE Technical Paper # 911377 21st International Conference on Environmental Systems SAE International Warrendale, PA
- Sauer RL 1982 Potable water In Pool SL Johnson PC Jr Mason JA Shuttle OFT medical report, NASA Tech Memo 58252 72 81
- Shulz JR Eberhardt RN 1992 Space habitat environmental health: A Systems Issues in Space ′92 proceeding Boulder, CO
- U.S. Environmental Protection Agency 1992 Health effects assessment summary tables OERR 9200.6-303 Office of Research and Development, USEPA Washington, DC
- U.S. Environmental Protection Agency 1993 Integrated Risk Information System Office of Research and Development, Environmental Criteria and Assessment Office, USEPA Cincinnati, OH
- Wands RC 1975 Toxicology of the air in closed spaces In Calvin M. Gazenko OG Foundations of space biology and medicine II NASA Washington, DC 65 93
- Wydeven T Golub M 1990 Generation rates and chemical compositions of waste streams in a typical crewed space habitat NASA Tech Memo 102799 National Aeronautics and Space Admn. Washington, DC
- Wydeven T. 1988 A Survey of Some Regenerative Physico-Chemical Life Support Technology NASA Tech Memo 101004 National Aeronautics and Space Admn. Washington, DC
- Wydeven T. 1991 America at the Threshold: Report of the Synthesis Group on America's Space Exploration Initiative US Govt Printing Office Washington, DC
- James John. T. Dr.