This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Emission Control Cost-Effectiveness of Alternative-Fuel Vehicles
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Although various legislation and regulations have been adopted to promote the use of alternative-fuel vehicles for curbing urban air pollution problems, there is a lack of systematic comparisons of emission control cost-effectiveness among various alternative-fuel vehicle types. In this paper, life-cycle emission reductions and life-cycle costs were estimated for passenger cars fueled with methanol, ethanol, liquified petroleum gas, compressed natural gas, and electricity. Vehicle emission estimates included both exhaust and evaporative emissions for air pollutants of hydrocarbon, carbon monoxide. nitrogen oxides, and air-toxic pollutants of benzene, formaldehyde, 1,3-butadiene, and acetaldehyde. Vehicle life-cycle cost estimates accounted for vehicle purchase prices, vehicle life, fuel costs, and vehicle maintenance costs.
Emission control cost-effectiveness presented in dollars per ton of emission reduction was calculated for each alternative-fuel vehicle type from the estimated vehicle life-cycle emission reductions and costs. Among various alternative-fuel vehicle types, compressed natural gas vehicles are the most cost-effective vehicle type in controlling vehicle emissions. Dedicated methanol vehicles are the next most cost-effective vehicle type. The cost-effectiveness of electric vehicles depends on improvements in electric vehicle battery technology. With low-cost, high-performance batteries, electric vehicles are more cost-effective than methanol, ethanol, and liquified petroleum gas vehicles.
Recommended Content
Authors
Topic
Citation
Wang, Q., Sperling, D., and Olmstead, J., "Emission Control Cost-Effectiveness of Alternative-Fuel Vehicles," SAE Technical Paper 931841, 1993, https://doi.org/10.4271/931841.Also In
Alternative Fuels: Alcohols, Hydrogen Natural Gas and Propane
Number: SP-0982; Published: 1993-08-01
Number: SP-0982; Published: 1993-08-01
References
- Office of Technology Assessment (OTA) 1988 Urban Ozone and the Clean Air Act: Problems and Proposals for Change Oceans and Environment Program, Office of Technology Assessment, U.S. Congress Washington, D.C. April
- Lareau T. J. 1990 “The Economics of Alternative Fuel Use: Substituting Methanol for Gasoline,” Contemporary policy Issues 8 138 152
- Fraas A. McGartland A. 1990 “Alternative Fuels for Pollution Control: an Empirical Evaluation of Benefits and Costs,” Contemporary Policy Issues 8 62 74
- Krupnick A. J. Walls M. A. Toman M. A. 1990 The Cost-Effectiveness and Energy Security Benefits of Methanol Vehicles , discussion paper QE90-25 Resources for the Future Washington, D.C. September
- Wang Q. Sperling D. Olsmstead J. 1993 Emission Impacts, Life-Cycle Cost Changes, and Emission Control Cost-Effectiveness of Methanol-, Ethanol-, Liquified Petroleum Gas-, Compressed Natural Gas-, and Electricity-Fueled Vehicles Institute of Transportation Studies, University of California Davis, California May 9
- Croes B. E. Carter W. P. L. 1991 “Protocol for Development of Ozone Reactivity Scale for Low-Emission Vehicles and Clean Fuels Regulation,” California Air Resources Board, Research Division Sacramento, California August
- California Air Resources Board (CARB) 1991 Proposed Reactivity Adjustment Factors for Transitional Low-Emission Vehicles, Technical Support Document Mobile Source Division and Research Division, California Air Resources Board Sacramento, California September 27
- U.S. EPA 1992 Air Chief (Clearing House for Inventories and Emission Factors): Speciate . On-line computer database, Emission Inventory Branch Technical Support Division, Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards, U.S. EPA Research Triangle Park, North Carolina
- Energy Information Administration (EIA) 1991 Annual Outlook for U.S. Electric Power 1991--Projections Through 2010 The U.S. Department of Energy, Energy Information Administration Washington, D.C. July
- Auto/Oil Air Quality Improvement Research Program 1992 “Emissions of Three Dedicated-Methanol Vehicles,” Technical Bulletin 10 June
- Newkirk M. S. Smith L. R. Ahuja M. Albu S. Santoro S. Leonard J. 1992 “Formaldehyde Emission Control Technology for Methanol-Fueled Vehicles: Catalyst Selection,” SAE Technical Paper 920092 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, Pennsylvania
- U.S. EPA 1990 1990 Test Car List--Passenger Cars U.S. EPA, Office of Mobile Sources, Emission Certification Division Ann Arbor, Michigan
- Auto/Oil Air Quality Improvement Research Program 1992 “Emissions and Air Quality Modeling Results from Methanol/Gasoline Blends in Prototype Flexible/Variable Fuel Vehicles,” Technical Bulletin 7 January
- U.S. EPA 1992 1992 Test Car List--Passenger Cars U.S. EPA, Office of Mobile Sources, Emission Certification Division Ann Arbor, Michigan
- Chrysler Corporation 1992 Information contained in Sacramento Bee “The Clean Machine,” Sacramento, Califomia July 24
- Wang Q. DeLuchi M. D. Sperling D. 1990 “Emission Impacts of Electric Vehicles,” Journal of Air and Waste Management Association 40 1275 1284
- Gabele P. A. 1990 “Characterization of Emissions from a Variable Gasoline\Methanol Fuel Vehicle,” Journal of Air and Waste Management Association 40 296 304
- DeLuchi M. A. 1992 Hydrogen Fuel-Cell Vehicles , research report UCD-ITS-RR-92-14 Institute of Transportation Studies, University of Califomia Davis, California September
- Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) 1992 Cost of Owning and Operating Automobiles, Vans, and Light Trucks, 1991 Federal Highway Administration, Office of Highway Information Management, U.S. Department of Transportation Washington, D.C. Jack Faucett Associates Bethesda, Maryland April
- Wang Q. DeLuchi M. A 1992 “Impacts of Electric Vehicles on Primary Energy Consumption and Petroleum Displacement,” Energy 17 351 366
- Gushee D. E. 1992 “Potential Policy Levers for Alternative Fuels: Costs, Energy Security, and Environmental Impacts,” Congressional Research Service the Library of Congress Washington, D.C. April 27
- Osgood L. D. 1991 “Phillips 66 Company Propane (LPG Gas) Alternative Fuel Information,” Development and Technical Service Phillips 66 Propane Company Bartlesville, Oklahoma
- Osgood L. D. 1993 Development and Technical Service Phillips 66 Propane Company Bartlesville, Oklahoma February 10
- California Energy Commission (CEC) 1991 AB 234 Report Update: Cost and Availability of Low-Emission Motor Vehicles and Fuels, Draft California Energy Commission Sacramento, California August
- U.S. EPA 1990 Analysis of the Economics and Environmental Effects of Compressed Natural Gas as a Vehicle Fuel--Volume I: Passenger Cars and Light Trucks, the U.S. EPA, Office of Mobile Sources Ann Arbor, Michigan April
- American Gas Association (AGA) 1989 “An Analysis of the Economic and Environmental Effects of Natural Gas as an Alternative Fuel,” EA 1989-10 American Gas Association Arlington, Virginia December 15
- U.S. EPA 1992 “Inspection/Maintenance Program Requirements; Final Rule,” Federal Register 57 52950 53014
- Wang Q. Sperling D. 1992 Energy Impacts of Using Electric Vehicles in the Southern California Edison Company Service Area Southern California Edison Company Rosemead, California Institute of Transportation Studies, University of California Davis, California May
- Ingalls M. N. Smith L. R. Kirksey R. E. 1989 Measurement of On-Road Vehicle Emission Factors in the California South Coast Air Basin, Volume I: Regulated Emissions Coordinated Research Council, Inc. Atlanta, Georgia Southwest Research Institute San Antonio, Texas June
- Lawson D. R. Grobliki P. J. Stedman D. H. Bishop G. A. Guenther P. L. 1990 “Emissions from In-Use Motor Vehicles in Los Angeles: a Pilot Study of Remote Sensing and the Inspection and Maintenance Program,” Journal of Air and Waste Management Association 40 1096 1105
- National Research Council 1991 Rethinking the Ozone Problem in Urban and Regional Air Pollution National Academy Press Washington, D.C.
- California Energy Commission (CEC) 1992 Electricity Report California Energy Commission Sacramento, California November
- U.S. EPA 1992 Motor Vehicle-Related Air Toxics Study Technical Support Branch, Emission Planning and Strategies Division, Office of Mobile Sources, Office of Air and Radiation, the U.S. EPA Research Triangle Park, North Carolina December
- DeLuchi M. A 1991 Emissions of Greenhouse Gases from the Use of Transportation Fuels and Electricity, Volume 1: Main Text, ANL/ESD/TM-22 1 Center for Transportation Research, Argonne National Laboratory Argonne, Illinois November
- South Coast Air Quality Management District and Southern California Association of Governments 1991 Final 1991 Air Quality Management Plan Diamond Bar California July