This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
The Physics of Throw Distance in Accident Reconstruction
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
In accident reconstruction, the distance a pedestrian has been projected by an impact may be used to provide an estimate of the speed of the striking vehicle. With tyre marks becoming less common, as ABS braking is introduced, the method is gaining in importance.
Speed estimation from throw distance rests on an empirical basis of field studies, which relate the distance projected to the speed of the vehicle. However field studies by themselves provide no understanding of the physical process. That understanding is important in the consideration of the effects of site characteristics, such as gradient or coefficient of friction.
The paper presents the equation of motion for an idealised particle, travelling over a surface where the upward reaction from the surface varies from moment to moment, including times when the particle is airborne and the reaction is zero. A simple formula is derived linking the minimum initial speed, the coefficient of friction and the total distance travelled:-
A series of tests was carried out to check this relationship experimentally. A dummy was projected on an airborne trajectory and the distance travelled was measured. It was found that whilst there were differences from the simple formula, those differences were small. For most practical purposes the simple formula provides a speed estimate of sufficient accuracy.
This speed estimate is for the minimum speed at which the pedestrian must have been projected. The average speed will be slightly higher and the speed of the striking vehicle higher again. Comparison with the results of field studies suggests that these effects add on some 20% or so.
Recommended Content
Technical Paper | The Trajectories of Pedestrians, Motorcycles, Motorcyclists, etc., Following a Road Accident |
Technical Paper | Motorcycle Slide to Stop Tests |
Technical Paper | Comprehensive Analysis Method for Vehicle/Pedestrian Collisions |
Authors
Citation
Searle, J., "The Physics of Throw Distance in Accident Reconstruction," SAE Technical Paper 930659, 1993, https://doi.org/10.4271/930659.Also In
References
- APPEL, H. STÜRTZ, G. GOTZEN, L. “Influence of impact speed and vehicle parameters on injuries of children and adults in pedestrian accidents” Proceedings 2nd International IRCOBI Conference 1976 83 100
- ELSHOLZ, J. July 1969
- KUHNEL, A. “Vehicle pedestrian collision experiments with the use of a moving dummy.” Proceedings of Eighteenth Conference American Association for Automotive Medicine Morton Grove, Il. 1974 223 245
- BAKER, J. S. “Traffic Accident Investigation Manual” The Traffic Institute, Northwestern University Il. 1975 223 227
- CROMACK, J. R. “Parametric analysis in pedestrian, bicycle and motorcycle accident reconstruction” Proceedings Twenty Fifth Annual Conference American Association for Automotive Medicine Morton Grove, Il. 1981 449 460
- GERMAN, A. NOWAK, E.S. GREEN, R. N. “Vehicle dynamics: Free-flight trajectory analysis” Proceedings Twenty Fifth Annual Conference American Association for Automotive Medicine Morton Grove, Il. 1981 435 448
- COLLINS, J. C. “Accident Reconstruction” Charles C. Thomas Springfield, Il. 1979
- FRICKE, L. B. “Traffic Accident Reconstruction” The Traffic Institute, Northwestern University Il. 1990 77 7
- SEARLE, J. A. SEARLE, A. “The trajectories of pedestrians, motorcycles, motorcyclists etc., following a road accident.” SAE Paper 831622 , Proceedings of Twenty Seventh Stapp Car Crash Conference 1983 277 285
- HAIGHT, W. R. EUBANKS, J. J. “Trajectory Analysis for Collisions Involving Bicycles and Automobiles.” SAE Paper 900368 , SP 814 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale Pa. 1990
- ARONBERG, R. “Airborne trajectory analysis derivation for use in accident reconstruction.” SAE Paper 900367 , SP 814 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale Pa. 1990 135 142
- BRATTEN, T. A. “Development of a tumble number for use in accident reconstruction.” SAE Paper 890859 , SP 777 Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale Pa. 1989 185 191