This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Engine Oil Viscosity and Bearing Wear: Field Test Results
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Two programs were conducted to study the relationships between engine oil rheology and crankshaft bearing wear. A Chassis Dynamometer test of four oils in four cars was used to explore and define the key variables affecting bearing wear. These results were used to design a Field Test of nine oils in 45 taxicabs in New York City. The test oils (SAE OW-20 to 20W-20) were formulated to measure the effects of viscosity, viscosity index improver, and detergent inhibitor package. Bearing wear tended to be either low and unremarkable or very high, particularly in the thrust bearings. Oil performance was best expressed as the frequency of excessive wear, rather than by quantitative wear measurement. There were many instances of very high wear in cabs operated with the lowest viscosity oils but none in cabs with higher viscosity oils. Non-Newtonian oils appeared to provide slightly more protection than Newtonian oils of the same HTHS viscosity, and a higher quality adpack also appeared to provide benefits. However, these factors were secondary to the viscosity of the oil. HTHS viscosity was a better predictor of bearing wear performance than oil film thickness.
Recommended Content
Technical Paper | Engine Oil and Bearing Wear |
Technical Paper | Influence of Engine Oil Viscosity on Piston Ring and Cam Face Wear |
Technical Paper | Properties of Engine Bearings Lubricated with Low HTHS Viscosity Oil |
Authors
Citation
Demmin, R., Girshick, F., and Schilowitz, A., "Engine Oil Viscosity and Bearing Wear: Field Test Results," SAE Technical Paper 922342, 1992, https://doi.org/10.4271/922342.Also In
References
- “The Relationship Between High-Temperature Oil Rheology and Engine Operation - A Status Report,” ASTM Data Series DS 62 1985
- “Engine Oil Viscosity Classification,” SAE J300 June 1987
- ASTM Test Method D 4624 “Standard Test Method for Measuring Apparent Viscosity by Capillary Viscometer at High Temperature and High-Shear Rates,”
- ASTM Test Method D 4683 “Standard Test Method for Measuring Viscosity at High Temperature and High Shear Rate by Tapered Bearing Simulator,”
- ASTM Test Method D 4741 “Standard Test Method for Measuring Viscosity at High Temperature and High Shear Rate by Tapered Plug Viscometer,”
- Filowitz M.S. King W.H. Appeldoorn J.K. “Oil-Film Thickness in a Bearing of a Fired Engine,” SAE Paper 820511
- Craig R.C. King, W.H. Jr. Appeldoorn J.K. “Oil-Film Thickness in a Bearing of a Fired Engine, Part II: The Bearing as a Capacitor” SAE Paper 821250
- Spearot J.A. Murphy C.K. Rosenberg R.C. “Measuring the Effect of Oil Viscosity on Oil Film Thickness in Engine Journal Bearings,” SAE Paper 831689
- Van Os N. Garcia-Franco C.A. Gottenberg W.G. Tripp H.A. “The Effect of Lubricant Elasticity on Journal Bearing Performance Under Static Load,” SAE Paper 831690
- Girshick F. Craig R.C. “Oil-Film Thickness in a Bearing of a Fired Engine - Part III: The Effects of Lubricant Rheology,” SAE Paper 831691
- Bates T.W. Williamson B. Spearot J.A. Murphy C.K. “A Correlation Between Engine Oil Rheology and Oil Film Thickness in Engine Journal Bearings,” SAE Paper 860376
- Schilowitz A.M. Waters J.L. “Oil Film Thickness in a Bearing of a Fired Engine - Part IV: Measurements in a Vehicle on the Road,” SAE Paper 861561
- Bates T.W. Benwell S. “Effect of Oil Rheology on Journal Bearing Performance Part 3 - Newtonian Oils in the Connecting-Rod Bearing of an Operating Engine,” SAE Paper 880679
- Spearot J.A. Murphy C.K. “A Comparison of the Total Capacitance and Total Resistance Techniques for Measuring the Thickness of Journal Bearing Oil Films in an Operating Engine SAE Paper 880680
- Deysarkar A.K. “The Bearing Oil Film Thickness of Single and Multi-Grade Oils - Part 1: Experimental Results in a 3.8L Engine,” SAE Paper 880681
- Hoult D.P. Lux J.P. Wong V.W. Billian S.A. “Calibration of Laser Fluorescence Measurements of Lubricant Film Thickness in Engines,” SAE Paper 881587
- Tripp H.A. Berker A. “Oil Film Thickness Measurements in a Dynamically Loaded Journal Bearing - A Comparison of Measured and Calculated Minimum Oil Film Thickness with Newtonian Lubricating Oils,” SAE Paper 881664
- Bates T.W. Fantino B. Launay L. Frene J. “Oil Film Thickness in a Elastic Connecting-Rod Bearing: Comparison Between Theory and Experiment,” STLE Preprint No. 89-AM-2B-1
- Spearot J.A. Murphy C.K. Deysarkar A.K. “Intrepreting Experimental Bearing Oil Film Thickness Data,” SAE Paper 892151
- Clampitt B.H. “Effect of Bearing Surface Characteristics on Bearing Oil Film Thickness,” SAE Paper 892153
- Bates T.W. Toft G.B. “Effect of Oil Rheology on Journal Bearing Performance: Part 4 - Bearing Durability and Oil Film Thickness,” SAE Paper 892154
- Vickars M.A. Rommel H.J. “Factors Influencing Oil Film Thickness in Engine Crankshaft Bearings,” Technische Arbeitstagung Hohenheim West Germany March 30 1990
- Cryvoff S.A. Spearot J.A. Bates T.W. “Engine Bearing Oil Film Thickness Measurement and Oil Rheologh (sic) - an ASTM Task Force Report,” SAE Paper 902064
- Neudörfl P. “The Effect of Polymers in Multigrade Lubricating Oils on Engine Wear,” SAE Paper 760269
- Bell J.C. Voisey M.A. “Some Relationships Between the Viscometric Properties of Motor Oils and Performance in European Engines,” SAE Paper 770378
- Stambaugh R.L. Kopko R.J. Bennett P.A. “The Relationship of Journal Bearing Wear to Multigrade Engine Oil Viscometric Properties,” SAE Paper 770627
- McMillan M.L. Rosenberg R.C. Murphy C.K. “Viscosity Effects on Engine Wear Under High-Temperature High-Speed Conditions,” SAE Paper 780982
- van Os N. Bos A. van Namen D. de Rooij J.C.E.D. “A Study of Lubricating Oil Performance in a Journal Bearing Rig,” SAE Paper 780985
- DeHart A.O. Rosenberg R.C. Hill R.F. Schneider E.W. “A Radiometric Test to Determine the Lubricant Effect on Journal Bearing Load Capacity,” SAE Paper 800361
- Rhodes R.B. Henderson B.M. “The Effects of Engine Oil Viscosity and Composition on Bearing Wear,” SAE Paper 811224
- Flathmann D.E. Barker R.F. Wylie W.S. “Wear Performance of an SAE OW-30 Partial-Synthetic Motor Oil Under High-Speed Driving Conditions,” SAE Paper 821196
- Kotani T. Yamada S. Okumura K. Kobayashi Y. “A Study of Antisiezure Properties of Motor Oils in Crankshaft Bearings,” SAE Paper 821197
- Schneider E.W. Rosenberg R.C. “The Effect of Fuel-Saving Engine Oils on Journal Bearing Load Capacity - A Radiometric Evaluation,” SAE Paper 821205
- Olson D.H. “Relationship of Engine Bearing Wear and Oil Rheology,” SAE Paper 872128
- Heath D.H. Baczet S.K. Sterlekar T.J. “Low Viscosity Oil Studies and the Influence of Radial Clearance on Bearing Distress in a 3.8L Engine,” SAE Paper 880682
- ASTM Test Method D 4951 “Standard Test Method for Determination of Additive Elements in Lubricating Oils by Inductively Coupled Plasma Atomic Emission Spectrometry”
- ASTM Test Method D 445 “Standard Test Method for Kinematic Viscosity of Transparent and Opaque Liquids (and the Calculation of Dynamic Viscosity)”
- “Standard Viscosity-Temperature Charts for Liquid Petroleum Products,” 38TM D 341-87
- Operating Instructions for Optical Elastohydrodynamic Apparatus Cameron-Plint Tribology Ltd. Wokingham, England
- Appeldoorn J.K. ASME Trans. F Journal of Lubrication Technology 90 526 1968