This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Effect of Low-Lubricity Fuels on Diesel Injection Pumps - Part II:Laborator Evaluation
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published February 01, 1992 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
This paper is the second of two that describe the effects of low-lubricity fuels on diesel injection pump performance. The first paper describes the primary failure mechanisms and wear processes in a number of failed pumps removed from both military and civilian vehicles that had been operated on Jet A-1 and diesel fuels. However, the multitude of unregulated parameters in practical operation renders quantitative comparison between different fuels and pump combinations impractical. This paper describes the degradation in pump performance and the wear processes associated with fuels of varying lubricity in the well-defined environment of a pump test stand. The test methodology concentrates on those areas previously demonstrated to be most susceptible to wear. The results indicate that pump durability is reduced by highly refined low-viscosity fuels, but may be successfully counteracted by either improved metallurgy or lubricity additives. The measured wear rate from the full-scale pump stand tests is compared with results from a lubricity measurement technique commonly used in aviation. Based on this comparison, initial criteria for the minimum fuel lubricity requirements of the injection system are suggested.
MANY FUELS PROVIDE a limited range of contact conditions in which successful lubrication is possible. Fuel systems are designed to reflect these needs; however, seemingly minor changes in fuel composition or equipment design may significantly alter component durability. The Part I Field Performance paper (1)* described post-failure disassembly and examination of failed pumps returned from the field. However, in many instances ultimate failure was promoted by a number of causes, and the effects of fuel lubricity could not be isolated.
The surface protection provided by a fuel is not a unique characteristic, but rather is highly dependent on the test environment and mechanical configuration. The selection of a laboratory test to accurately, yet rapidly, simulate field conditions is necessarily a compromise among competing variables. The fuel pump and injection components perform under a variety of contact geometries, pressures, and velocities to cover lubrication conditions from boundary to fully developed hydrodynamic film. However, preliminary tests and calculations reported in Reference 1 indicated that pump seizure was not primarily due to the decreased viscosity of the aviation fuels. As a result, the test series was designed to highlight the effects of oxidative/corrosive wear.
CitationLacey, P. and Lestz, S., "Effect of Low-Lubricity Fuels on Diesel Injection Pumps - Part II:Laborator Evaluation," SAE Technical Paper 920824, 1992, https://doi.org/10.4271/920824.
- Lacey P.I. Lestz S.J. “Effect of Low-Lubricity Fuel on Diesel Injection Pumps --Part I Field Performance,” SAE International Congress and Exposition Detroit, MI 24-28 February 1992
- Norton P.E. “Final Report Development Test I1 (PQT-G) (Desert) of High Mobility Multipurpose Wheeled Vehicle (HMMWV),” U.S. Army Tank-Automotive Command Warren, MI November 1982
- “Stanadyne Injection Pump Specification for Customer Part No. 23500415,” Stanadyne Diesel System Hartford, CT
- American Society for Testing and Materials Standard D 1655 “Aviation Turbine Fuel, Grades Jet A-1/Jet A,” 1989
- Bowden J.N. Westbrook S.R. “A Survey of JP-8 and JP-5 Properties,” Belvoir Fuels and Lubricants Research Facility (SwRI) Southwest Research Institute San Antonio, TX September 1988
- American Society for Testing and Materials Method D 5001-89 “Test Method for Measurement of Lubricity of Aviation Turbine Fuels by the Ball-on-Cylinder Lubricity Evaluator (BOCLE),” American Society for Testing and Materials Philadelphia, PA 1989
- Grabel L. “Lubricity Properties of High-Temperature Jet Fuel,” Naval Air Propulsion Test Center August 1977
- Lacey P.I. Lestz S.J. “Fuel Lubricity Requirements for Diesel Injection Systems,” Belvoir Fuels and Lubricants Research Facility (SwRI) Southwest Research Institute San Antonio, TX February 1991
- Specification MIL-I-25017E. “Inhibitor, Corrosion/Lubricity Improver, Fuel Soluble (Metric),” 15 June 1989
- “Turbine Fuels, Aviation Turbine Kerosene Types,” 22 March 1990
- “Stabilizer Additive Diesel Fuel,” 15 August 1988
- “Fuel Oil, Diesel,” 27 October 1987
- Black B.H. Wechter M.A. “The Lubricity Properties of Jet Fuel as Measured by the Ball-on-Cylinder Lubricity Evaluator,” American Chemical Society, Division of Fuel Chemistry 35 2 1990
- Lacey P.I. “The Relationship Between Fuel Lubricity and Injection System Wear,” Belvoir Fuels and Lubricants Research Facility (SwRI) Southwest Research Institute San Antonio, TX
- Tao F.F. Appeldoorn J.K. “The Ball-on-Cylinder Test for Evaluating Jet Fuel Lubricity,” Trans ., ASLE 11 345 352 1968
- Wei D. Spikes H.A. “The Lubricity of Diesel Fuels,” Wear 111 2 1986
- Appeldoorn J.K. Goldman I.B. Tao F.F. “Corrosive Wear by Atmospheric Oxygen and Moisture,” Trans ., ASLE 12 140 150 1969
- Furey M.J. “Metallic Contact and Friction Between Sliding Surfaces,” Trans ., ASLE 4 1 11 1961
- Archard J.F. “Contact and Rubbing of Flat Sur-faces,” Appl. Phys. 24 981 989 1953
- Biddle T.B. Edwards W.H. “Evaluation of Corrosion Inhibitors as Lubricity Improvers,” AF Wright Aeronautical Laboratories
- Edwards W.H. Biddle T.B. “Determination of Corrosion Inhibitor Content in Aviation Fuels,” March 1987
- Hadley J.W. Blackhurst P. “An Appraisal of the Ball-on-Cylinder Technique for Measuring Aviation Turbine Fuel Lubricity,” STLE 47 5 404 411 1991
- Lowe G.R. Hughes F. February 1987
- Datechefsky G. “History, Development and Status of the Ball-on-Cylinder Lubricity Evaluator for Aero Gas Turbine Fuels,” report prepared under MOD Contract AE12a/193, by the Esso Research Center Abingdon, Oxfordshire, OX 136AE, UK 1991
- Kanakia M.D. Moses C.A. “Study of Mechanisms of Fuel Lubricity,” Belvoir Fuels and Lubricants Research Facility (SwRI) Southwest Research Institute San Antonio, TX August 1989