This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
A Comparison of Frontal and Side Impact: Crash Dynamics, Countermeasures and Subsystem Tests
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Event:
Stapp Car Crash Conference
Language:
English
Abstract
Frontal crashes and near-side crashes were compared and found to be significantly different events. In a frontal crash, the energy to be dissipated from the occupant is constant for a given speed. In a side crash, the energy transferred to a struck-side occupant depends highly on his interaction with the door. That difference has important implications on the choice of countermeasures, injury criteria, and subsystem tests. In a frontal crash, chest and abdominal injuries occur in the “second” impact when the occupant, acting like a free-flight mass, strikes the interior. Padding can absorb some of the free-flight energy, reduce the impact force, and provide earlier and longer contact of the occupant with the interior. The earlier contact decreases the differential velocity of the occupant to the interior, and the longer contact allows more time and greater distance to dissipate the kinetic energy. These improved energy management effects are reflected by lower deflection-based and acceleration-based chest injury criteria in a frontal crash test when padding is added. In a side impact, chest and abdominal injuries occur when the stationary occupant is “punched” by the encroaching door. Padding also provides an earlier and a longer contact of the occupant with the encroaching door, which prolongs the side impact punch. The prolonged punch can actually increase the net energy transferred from the door to the occupant, which may be reflected by higher deflection-based chest injury criteria. Despite the greater energy transfer, padding actually reduces acceleration-based injury criteria, such as TTI(d), in the same side impact crash test. Traditional subsystem tests, such as sled or pendulum tests, can mimic most effects on an occupant of a frontal crash, but they cannot mimic many essential characteristics of a side crash.
Recommended Content
Authors
Citation
Lau, I., Capp, J., and Obermeyer, J., "A Comparison of Frontal and Side Impact: Crash Dynamics, Countermeasures and Subsystem Tests," SAE Technical Paper 912896, 1991, https://doi.org/10.4271/912896.Also In
References
- Anthropomorphic Test Dummy; Side Impact Protection NHTSA Final Rule Federal Register 55 210 1990
- Beebe M.S. What is BIOSID? SAE Paper 900377 SAE International Congress and Exposition 1990
- Brun-Cassan F. Pincemaille Y. Mack P. Tarriere C. Contribution to the Evaluation of the Criteria Proposed for Thorax-Abdomen Protection in Lateral Impact Eleventh ESV Conference Washington, DC 1987
- Campbell K.L. Wasko R.J. Henson S.E. Analysis of Side Impact Test Data Comparing SID and BIOSID SAE Paper 902319 34th Stapp Car Crash Conference 1990
- Cavanaugh J.M. Wasko R.J. 1991
- Cavanaugh J.M. Waliko T.J. Nakgitra A. et al Biornechanical Response and Injury Tolerance of the Thorax in Twelve Sled Side Impacts SAE Paper 902307 34th Stapp Car Crash Conference 1990
- Deng Y.-C. The Importance of the Test Method in Determining the Effect of Door Padding in Side Impact SAE Paper 892429 33rd Stapp Car Crash Conference 1989
- Deng Y.-C. Design Considerations for Occupant Protection in Side Impact - A Modeling Approach SAE Paper 881713 32nd Stapp Car Crash Conference 1988
- Eppinger R.H. Marcus J.H. Morgan R.M. Development of Dummy and Injury Index for NHTSA's Thoracic Side Impact Protection Research Program SAE Paper 840885 , Government/Industry Meeting and Exposition 1984
- Foster J.K. Kortge J.O. Wolanin M.J. Hybrid III - A Biomechanically Based Crash Test Dummy SAE Paper 770938 21st Stapp Car Crash Conference 1977
- Final Regulatory Impact Analysis - New Requirements for Passenger Cars to Meet a Dynamic Side Impact Test NHTSA Plan and Policy Office of Regulatory Analysis Aug 1990
- Hobbs C.A. The Influence of Car Structures and Padding on Side Impact Injuries Twelfth ESV Conference Goteborg, Sweden 1989
- Horsch J.D. Lau I.V. Viano D.C. Andrzejak D.V. Mechanism of Abdominal Injury by Steering Wheel Loading SAE Paper 851724 29th Stapp Car Crash Conference 1985
- Horsch J.D. Petersen K.R. Viano D.C. Laboratory Study of Factors Influencing the Performance of Energy Absorbing Steering Systems SAE Paper 820475 1982
- Biofidelity of BIOSID SID EUROSID Turin, Italy March 1990
- Kroell C.K. Allen S.D. Warner C.Y. et al Interrelationship of Velocity and Chest Compression in Blunt Thoracic Impact to Swine II SAE Paper 861881 30th Stapp Car Crash Conference 1986 Kroell C.K. Pope M.E. Viano D.C. et al Interrelationship of Velocity and Chest Compression in Blunt Thoracic Impact to Swine I SAE Paper 811016 25th Stapp Car Crash Conference 1981
- Kroell C.K. Schneider D.C. Nahum A.M. Impact Tolerance and Response of the Human Thorax SAE Paper 710851 15th Stapp Car Crash Conference 1971
- Lau I.V. Horsch J.D. Viano D.C. Andrzejak D.V. Biomechanics of Liver Injury by Steering Wheel Loading J. Trauma 27 225 235 1987
- Lau I.V. Viano D.C. The Viscous Criterion - Bases and Applications of an Injury Severity Index for Soft Tissues SAE Paper 861882 30th Stapp Car Crash Conference 1986 Lau I.V. Viano D.C. How and When Blunt Injury Occurs: Implications to Frontal and Side Impact Protection SAE Paper 881714 32nd Stapp Car Crash Conference 1989
- Lobdell T.F. Impact Response of the Human Thorax Proceedings of Human Impact Response Measurement and Simulation 1972 1973
- Malliaris A.C. Hitchcock R. Hedlund J. A Search for Priority in Crash Protection SAE Paper 820242 SAE International Congress and Exposition 1982
- Morgan R.M. Marcus J.H. Eppinger R.H. Side Impact - The Biofidelity of NHTSA-s Proposed ATD and Efficacy of TTI SAE Paper 861877 30th Stapp Car Crash Conference 1986
- Preliminary Regulatory Impact Analysis - New Requirements for Passenger Cars to Meet a Dynamic Side Impact Test NHTSA Plan and Policy Office of Regulatory Analysis Jan 1988
- Ridella S.A. Viano D.C. Determining Tolerance to Compression and Viscous Injury in Frontal and Lateral Impacts SAE Paper 902330 34th Stapp Car Crash Conference 1990
- Rouhana S.W. Kroell C.K. The Effect of Door Topography on Abdominal Injury in Lateral Impact SAE Paper 892433 33rd Stapp Car Crash Conference 1989
- Rouhana S.W. Viano D.C. Jedrzejczak E.A. McCleary J.D. Assessing Submarining and Abdominal Injury Risk in the Hybrid III Family of Dummies SAE Paper 892440 33rd Stapp Car Crash Conference 1989
- Viano D.C Evaluation of the Benefit of Energy-Absorbing Material in Side Impact Protection: Part I SAE Paper 872212 31st Stapp Car Crash Conference 1987 Viano D.C Evaluation of the Benefit of Energy-Absorbing Material in Side Impact Protection: Part II SAE Paper 872213 31st Stapp Car Crash Conference 1987 Viano D.C. Evaluation of the SID Dummy and TTI Injury Criterion for Side Impact Testing SAE Paper 872208 31st Stapp Car Crash Conference 1987
- Viano D.C. Evaluation of Armrest Loading in Side Impacts SAE Paper 35th Stapp Car Crash Conference 1991
- Viano D.C. Culver C.C. Evans L. Frick M. Scott R. Involvement of Older Drivers in Multivehicle Crashes Accident Analysis and Prevention 22 177 178 1990
- Viano D.C. Lau I.V. Asbury C. et al Biomechanics of the Human Chest, Abdomen, and Pelvis in Lateral Impact Accident, Analysis and Prevention 21 553 574 1989 Viano D.C. Lau I.V. Andrzejak D.V. et al Biomechanics of Injury in Lateral Impacts Accident, Analysis and Prevention 21 535 551 1989
- Warner C.Y. Strother C.E. Wooley R.L. Application of Kinematic Concepts to Side Impact Injury Analysis SAE Paper 900375 International Congress and Exposition 1990