This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
The Effects of Different In-Vehicle Route Information Displays on Driver Behaviour
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
The paper reports two experiments conducted within the Driver Behaviour and Traffic Safety research strand of the European DRIVE programme. Each experiment was conducted using members of the general public, driving specially adapted road vehicles, in real urban environments. The first experiment, conducted in Loughborough can be seen as a validation of a multi-level evaluation methodology developed within the project as applied to two modes of route information presentation: paper map or text display on LCD screen. The second experiment used similar data collection techniques, but was conducted in Berlin with two real route information systems (LISB and Bosch Travelpilot). Assessing the results of these two experiments shows that there is a greater degree of visual workload associated with drawing information off a map display. This is the result of analysing a combination of measures, including vehicle control data, physiological stress indices, visual attention data and a variety of subjective response measures. This form of information presentation may be less than compatible with the task of navigating a vehicle whilst interacting with the road infrastructures of today.
Recommended Content
Technical Paper | Trends in Vehicle Information Displays in the Multimedia Era |
Technical Paper | Heads Up Display |
Technical Paper | Evaluation of Different ADAS Features in Vehicle Displays |
Authors
Topic
Citation
Parkes, A., Ashby, M., and Fairclough, S., "The Effects of Different In-Vehicle Route Information Displays on Driver Behaviour," SAE Technical Paper 912734, 1991, https://doi.org/10.4271/912734.Also In
References
- Fairclough SH Parkes AM 1990 Drivers Visual Behaviour and In-Vehicle Information HUSAT Research Institute UK
- Rumar K 1988 “In-vehicle information systems.” Int. J. of Vehicle Design 9 4 5 548 556
- Rouse WB 1981 “Human-computer interaction in the control of dynamic systems.” Computing Surveys 13 1
- Michon J A 1985 “A Critical View of Driver Behaviour Models.” Human Behaviour and Traffic Safety Evans L Schwing R S Plenum Press New York
- Parkes AM 1990 “Route guidance devices: Too many, too soon?” SICS Workshop on Navigation and Planning Nässlingen, Sweden September 1990
- Wierwille WW Antin JF Dingus TA Hulse MC 1988 Visual attention demand of an in-car navigation display system Proceedings of Vision in Vehicle Conference Nottingham 1987
- Wierwille WW Hulse M Fischer TJ Dingus T 1989 Visual adaption of the driver to high-demand driving situations while navigating with an in-car navigation system Vision in Vehicles III Conference Aachen, Germany 1989
- Labiale G 1989 “In-car navigation VDUs: A psycho-ergonomic study.” Proceedings of Vision in Vehicles III Conference Aachen, Germany 1989
- Streeter LA Vitello D Wonsiewicz SA 1985 “How to tell people where to go: Comparing navigational aids.” Int. J. Man-Machine Studies 1985 22 549 562
- Parkes AM Coleman N 1990 “Route guidance systems: a comparison of methods of presenting directional information to the driver.” Contemporary Ergonomics, Proceedings of the Ergonomics Society 1990 Annual Conference Lovesy EJ Taylor Francis
- Parkes AM 1991 “Data capture techniques for RTI usability evaluation.” Advanced Telematics in Road Transport, Proceedings of the DRIVE Conference Brussels February 1991 Elsevier, Amsterdam
- HUSAT 1989 Changes in Driver Behaviour Due to Two Modes of Route Guidance Information Presentation A Multi-Level Approach
- Ashby MC Parkes AM Fairclough SH 1991 Route Navigation or Route Guidance? Effects on Driver Behaviour of Two Real Systems used in an Urban Environment HUSAT Research Institute UK
- Parkes AM Ross T Holmes D Fairclough SH 1989 The Mobile Test Facility Developed By HUSAT HUSAT Research Institute UK
- Robertson SA Goodwin PB 1987 Driver Stress and the Process of Highway Design Pilot Investigation of Heart Rate as an Aid to Road System Appraisal using Low Cost Equipment TSU (Transport Studies Unit, Oxford University) February 1987
- Hart SG Staveland LE 1988 “Development of the NASA-TLX (Task Load Index): Results of empirical and theoretical research.” Hancock PA Meshkati N Human Mental Workload North Holland, Amsterdam 139 183
- Parkes AM Martell A 1990 “A usability analysis of a PC-based route planning system Contemporary Ergonomics Proceedings of the Ergonomics Society 1990 Annual Conference Lovesy EJ Taylor Francis