This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Compulsory Periodic Vehicle Inspections
Published November 01, 1991 by Society of Automotive Engineers of Korea in South Korea
Annotation ability available
The systematic investigation of road accidents by multi-disciplinary teams appears to be the most suitable approach to estimating the proportion of accidents that may be attributable to ‘mechanical defects’. These reports invariably conclude that mechanical defects have an insignificant effect on road accident rates.
At current prices an annual vehicle inspection program would cost about $86 million per annum more than the current change of ownership inspection and such a program might lower accident costs by between $9 million and $27 million per annum. At best costs would outweigh benefits 3:1. Periodic inspection thus would not be cost-effective.
The RACV suggests that there are alternative safety programs which are cost-effective, and therefore, the money that would need to be spent on an inspection program may be more effectively spent on other road safety initiatives.
The RACV believes that continued publicity and increased police surveillance of vehicle conditions, (in particular, of tyre condition) registration and driver licensing on a random selection basis would improve vehicle condition and driver behaviour. Such a procedure would be more cost-effective not only because of lower operational cost, but also because of a wider spread of potential road safety benefits.
CitationCase, M., De Forest, R., and Youngman, J., "Compulsory Periodic Vehicle Inspections," SAE Technical Paper 912587, 1991.
- BINTZ, L.J. DAUCHY, C.E. APPLEBY, M.R. 1970 Motor Vehicle Inspection: An Automobile Club of Southern California Study Automobile Club of Southern California
- CARNEGIE-MELLON UNIVERSITY 1975 An Assessment of Pennsylvania's Periodic Motor Vehicle Inspection System Pittsburgh, P.A.
- CCRAM 1978 Report of the Road Accident Research Unit Health Commission of Victoria Melbourne
- CRAIN, W.M. 1980 Vehicle Safety Inspection Systems American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research Washington, D.C.
- FOLDVARY, L.A. 1973 A Review of Vehicle Inspection in Relation to Road Safety AG PS Canberra
- FORS 1989 Road Crash Statistics Australia Department of Transport and Communications Canberra
- GRANDEL, J. 1985 Investigation of the technical defects causing motor vehicle accidents. Field Accidents; Data Collection Analysis, Methodologies and Crash Injury Reconstructions SAE Detroit, MI
- McLEAN, A.J. 1975-1979 Adelaide In-Deplh Accident Study
- McMINN, R.W. 1973 Using Accident Research to Evaluate Periodic Motor Vehicle Inspection New Jersey Division of Motor Vehicles
- MOTOR VEHICLE MANUFACTURERS ASSOCIATION OF THE UNITED STATES, INC. 1982 Laws and Regulations MVMA Detroit, MI
- MURCOTT, J. 1986 Citing Victorian Automobile Chamber of Commerce in Waverley Gazette July 23 1986
- WHITE, W.T. 1988 Should car inspections be less frequent? Proc. Road Traffic Safety Seminar, Road Traffic Safety Research Council Wellington, N.Z.