This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Small Stirling Dynamic Isotope Power System for Multihundred-Watt Robotic Missions
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Free-piston Stirling engine (FPSE) and linear alternator (LA) technology is combined with radioisotope heat sources to produce a compact dynamic isotope power system (DIPS) suitable for multihundred-watt space applications which appears competitive with advanced radioisotope thermoelectric generators (RTGs).
Unlike earlier DIPS concepts based on closed cycle Brayton conversion, the small Stirling DIPS is scaleable to multihundred-watt power levels or lower. The FPSE/LA convertor, which is not subject to the tip clearance to swept area scaling limitation of turbomachinery, remains a high efficiency convertor in sizes ranging from tens of kilowatts down to only a few watts. At multihundred-watt unit size, the FPSE can be directly integrated with the government-furnished General Purpose Heat Source (GPHS) via radiative coupling; the resulting dynamic isotope power system has a size and weight that compares favorably with the advanced modular (Mod) RTG, but requires less than a third the amount of isotope fuel. Thus the FPSE extends the high efficiency advantage of dynamic systems into a power range never previously considered competitive for DIPS. This results in lower fuel cost and reduced radiological hazard per delivered electrical watt.
Having sucessfully flown on several earlier space missions, free-piston Stirling technology has the potential to achieve, as an isotope engine, the high reliability that is required for years of unattended remote operation. Hermetically sealed inside a container, there are typically only two moving parts and no sliding seals of any kind. Incorporating noncontacting gas bearings or flexures, there is no wear between the moving parts. Terrestrially, Stirling engine convertors have demonstrated virtually unlimited service life-in test, one radioisotope heated unit has achieved over 110 000 hr continuous operation.
On Mars the small Stirling DIPS offers the benefit of being able to operate exposed to the atmosphere without degradation. RTG's must be hermetically sealed inside a container to survive.
For these reasons the small Stirling DIPS appears an economical alternative to RTG's. When it is developed, it should prove to be a strong candidate to power the many multihundred-watt robotic missions anticipated within the next three decades for deep space and planet surface exploration.
Authors
Citation
Bents, D., "Small Stirling Dynamic Isotope Power System for Multihundred-Watt Robotic Missions," SAE Technical Paper 912066, 1991, https://doi.org/10.4271/912066.Also In
References
- Shirbacheh M. “The Proceedings of the Radioisotope Power Systems Requirements Workshop,” Jet Propulsion Laboratory Pasadena, CA June 1990
- Hartmann R. “Modular RTG Technology Status,” Proc. 25th IECEC 1 AIChE 1990 235 238
- Skrabek E. “Performance of Radioisotope Thermoelectric Generators in Space” Proc. 7th Symposium on Space Nuclear Power Systems Albuquerque NM January 1990
- USDoE Office of Space/Defense Energy Projects March 1991
- Englehart R. “Mechanics of Space Nuclear Safety,” Space Nuclear Power Systems 2 Orbit Book Co. 1984 497 503
- Bennett G. et al “Development and Implementation of a Space Nuclear Safety Program,” Space Nuclear Power Systems 6 Orbit Book Co. 1987 59 92
- Aftergood S. “A Critical View of Space Nuclear Power,” Space Nuclear Power Systems 8 Orbit Book Co. 1988 39 44
- Johnson R. Stadnik A. “Dynamic Isotope Power Systems (DIPS) for Space Exploration - Technical Information,” Rockwell International Rocketdyne Division document BD 90-27 USDOE under Contract No. DE-AC03-88NE-32129 Canoga Park, CA May 1990
- Dobler F.X. “Mini-BRU/BIPS 1300 W(e) Dynamic Power Conversion System Development, Executive Summary,” AiResearch Division of Garrett Corporation NASA CR-159440 1978
- Bennett G. Janzen J. Lombardo J. Mehner A. “The Dynamic Isotope Power System Technology Program,” Proc. 23rd IECEC 3 ASME 1988 131 136
- Brandewie R. “Lockheed Missiles and Space Company BSTS PowerSystem Definition Study” Rev. 1, RI/RD86-188, Rocketdyne Div. Rockwell International Corporation Canoga Park CA July 1 1986
- Determan W.R. Chung D. Stadnik A. Johnson R.A. “Low Power DIPS for Interplanetary Missions,” Proc. 25th IECEC 1 AIChE 1990 210 215
- Lehrfeld D. Richards W.D. “Stirling Engine Power System Development and Test Results,” Proc. 15th IECEC 3 AIAA 1980 1967 1970
- Chan C. Tward E. Burt W. “Overview of Cryocooler Technologies for Space Based Electronics and Sensors,” Advances in Cryogenic Engineering 35 1990
- Dudenhoeffer J. “Programmatic Status of NASA's CSTI High Capacity Power Stirling Space Power Converter Program,” Proc. 25th IECEC 1 AIChE 1990 40 46
- White M. A. et al “Fully Implantable Stirling Engine for Artificial Heart Power,” Proc. 17th IECEC 4 IEEE 1982 1778 1783
- Berchowitz D. “The Development of a 1 kW Electrical Output Free Piston Stirling Engine Alternator Unit,” Proc. 18th IECEC 2 AIChE 1983 897 901
- Berggren R. Moynihan T. “Free Piston Stirling Engine Experimental Program: Part 1-Baseline Test Summary,” Argonne National Labs June 1983
- Schreiber J. Geng S.M. Lorenz G.V. “RE-1000 Free Piston Stirling Engine Sensitivity Test Results” NASA TM- 88846 1986
- Lane N.W. Berchowitz D.M. Shade D. Karandikar A. “Development of a High Frequency Stirling Engine-Powered 3 kW(e) Generator Set,” Proc. 24th IECEC 5 IEEE 1989 2213 2218
- Cairelli J.E. Geng S.M. Skupinski R.C. “Results from Baseline Tests of the SPRE I and Comparison with Code Model Predictions,” Proc. 24th IECEC 5 IEEE 1989 2249 2256
- Dochat G. Dhar M. “Free Piston Stirling Engine System Considerations for Various Space Power Applications,” Proc. 8th Symposium on Space Nuclear Power Systems Albuquerque NM January 1991
- Bents D. et al “Comparison of Dynamic Isotope Power Systems for Distributed Planetary Surface Applications,” Proc. 8th Symposium on Space Nuclear Power Systems Albuquerque NM January 1991
- Klann J. “Analysis and Selection of Design Conditions for a Radioisotope Brayton-Cycle Space Powerplant,” NASA TN D-4600 1968
- Bents D. et al “Design of Multihundred-watt DIPS for Robotic Space Missions,” Proc. 26th IECEC Boston MA August 1991
- McComas T. “Thermal Analysis of 250 We GPHS/FPSE/Dynamic Isotope Power Source Employing Direct Heat Source Integration,” Proc. 26th IECEC Boston MA August 1991
- Brittain W.M. Skrabek E.A. “SNAP 19 RTG Performance Update for the Pioneer and Viking Missions,” Proc. 18th IECEC 3 AIChE 1983 1056 1061
- Schock A. et al “Mars Rover RTG Study,” Fairchild Report FSC-ESD-217/89/449 Aug. 10 1989 IAF Paper 89-270
- Johnson E. “Post Encapsulation Plutonia Reduction for Galileo Ulysses GPHS Modules; the Module Reduction and Monitoring Facility (MRMF),” Proc. 8th Symposium on Space Nuclear Power Systems Albuquerque NM January 1991
- Slaby J. “Overview of the 1985 NASA Lewis Research Center SP-100 Free-Piston Stirling Engine Activities,” Proc. 20th IECEC 1985 3.180 3.188
- White M.A. et al “Miniature Stirling Engines for Artificial Heart Power” Proc. 18th IECEC Orlando FL August 1983
- Cooke-Yarborough E. “Small Stirling-Cycle Power Sources in Marine Applications,” OCEANS 80 International Conference on Ocean Engineering
- Cooke-Yarborough E. 17 Sept. 1990