This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Media Selection Analysis: Implications for Training Design
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
A comparative analysis of current media selection models was conducted as part of an overall effort to improve key Instructional Systems Development (ISD) steps that would significantly benefit from automation and decision support features. The media selection step within the ISD process was chosen for in-depth evaluation of its automation requirements. The objectives of this study were threefold: (a) to compare and contrast the media selection models in general use by military, contractor, and civilian instructional designers; (b) to identify key features that impact media selection model automation; and (c) to develop a preliminary design of an automated media selection model that incorporates the requirements of as many of the reviewed media selection models as possible.
Authors
Topic
Citation
Sorensen, H., "Media Selection Analysis: Implications for Training Design," SAE Technical Paper 911971, 1991, https://doi.org/10.4271/911971.Also In
References
- Aagard, J.A. Braby, R. 1976 Learning guidelines and algorithms for training objectives TAEG Report No. 23 Orlando, FL Training Analysis and Evaluation Group
- Ace, R.E. 1983 Computer-aided system for developing aircrew training (CASDAT) user's manual Arlington, VA Veda, Inc.
- Allen, W.H. 1971 Instructional media research: Past, present, and future AV Communication Review 19 5 18
- Allen, W.H. 1967 Media stimulus and types of learning Audiovisual Instruction Benson L.D. Bock H.R. Collins T. Dyer R.A. Haley M. Steen L.E. Jr. Selecting media for learning: readings from audiovisual instruction 8 12 Washington, DC Association for Educational Communications and Technology
- Anderson, R.H. 1983 Selecting and developing media for instruction 2nd New York Van Nostrand Reinhold Company
- Bloom, B.S. Engelhart, M.D. Hill, W.H. Furst, E.J. Drathwohl, D.R. 1956 Taxonomy of educational objectives, Handbook I: Cognitive domain New York David McKav
- Boucher, B.G. Gottlieb, M.J. Morganlander, M.L. 1973 Handbook and catalog for instructional media selection Englewood Cliffs, NJ Educational Technology Publications
- Braby, R. 1973 An evaluation of ten techniques for choosing instructional media TAEG Report No. 8 Orlando, FL Training Analysis and Evaluation Group
- Braby, R. Henry, J. Parrish, W. Swope 1978 A technique for choosing cost-effective instructional delivery systems TAEG Report No. 16 Orlando, FL Training Analysis and Evaluation Group
- Branson, R.K. Raynor, G.T. Cox, J.G. Furman, J.P. King, F.J. Hannum, W.H. 1975 Interservices procedures for instructional systems development Pensacola, FL Naval Education and Training Command
- Bretz, R. 1971a The selection of appropriate communications media for instruction: A guide for designers of Air Force technical training programs Report R-601-PR Santa Monica, CA Rand Corporation
- Bretz, R. 1971b A taxonomy of communication media Englewood Cliffs, NJ Educational Technology Publications
- Briggs, L.J. Campeau, P.L. Gagne, R.M. May, M.A. 1967 Instructional media: A procedure for the design of multi-media instruction, a critical review of research, and suggestions for future research Pittsburgh American Institutes for Research
- Briggs, L.J. Wager, W.W. 1981 Handbook of procedures for the design of instruction 2nd Englewood Cliffs, NJ Educational Technology Publications
- Cavert, C.E. 1972 A model for the selection of appropriate media in a technology based learning system Benson L.D. Bock H.R. Collins T. Cornell R.A. Dyer P.E. Haley M. Steen, L.E. Jr. Selecting media for learning: Reading from audio-visual instruction 27 28 Washington, DC Association for Educational Communications and Technology
- Ely, D. 1980 Guidelines for media production Cincinnati, OH US Environmental Protection Agency
- Gagne, R.M. 1985 The conditions of learning and theory of learning 4th New York Holt, Reinhart, and Winston
- Gagne, R.M. Briggs, L.J. Wager, W.W. 1988 Principles of instructional design 3rd Fort Worth Holt, Rinehart, & Winston
- Gagne, R.M. Reiser, R.A. Larson, J. 1981 A learning-based model for media selection: Description ARI Research Product 81-25a Tallahassee, FL Center for Educational Technology, Florida State University
- Gerlach, V. Ely, D.P. 1971 Teaching and media Englewood Cliffs, NJ Prentice-Hall, Inc.
- Gibbons, A.S. O'Neal, A.F. Farrow, D.R. Axtell, R.H. Hughes, J.A. 1981 F-16 training media mix F-16 Development Report No. 31 San Diego, CA Courseware, Inc.
- Goodman, R.I. 1971 Systematic selection Audiovisual Instruction 37 38 Handbook for designers of instructional systems 1978 Washington, DC Department of the Air Force
- Hays, R.T. Singer, M.J. 1989 Simulation fidelity in training system design New York Springer-Verlag
- Heinich, R. Molenda, M. Russell, J.D. 1989 Instructional media and the new technologies of instruction Third New York Macmillan
- Herlihy, D. Iceton, J. Oneal, J. Guptill, R. 1985 Man integrated systems technology (MIST) user's guide Wilmington, MA Dynamics Research Corporation
- Hostetter, W. Cross, J. Hinton, W.M. 1981 AV-8B Media Selection Model Alexander, VA Allen Corporation
- Hritz, R.J. Harris, H.J. Smith, J.A. Purifoy, G.R.. Jr. 1980 Maintenance training simulator design and acquisition: Handbook of ISD procedures for design and documentation Volume 1 Valencia, PA Applied Science Associates, Inc.
- Hritz, R.J. Purifoy, G.R., Jr. 1980 Maintenance training design and acquisition Valencia, PA Applied Science Associates, Inc.
- Instructional systems development AF Manual 50-2 1979 Washington, DC Department of the Air Force
- Instructional systems development 1981 Quantico, VA United States Marine Corps, Marine Corps Development and Education Command
- Interactive courseware management plan TRADOC Circular 351-86-1 1986 Ft Monroe, VA US Army Training and Doctrine Command
- Jay, J. 1986 Media selection analysis for 19K BNCOC ARI Research Note 86-65 Cambridge, MA Scientific Systems
- Jorgensen, C. Kubala, S. Davis, J. Atlas, M. 1981 How to use the training efficiency estimation model (TEEM) ARI Working Paper 01-81 Ft Bliss, TX US Army Research Institute for the Behavorial and Social Sciences
- Krathwohl, D. R. Bloom B.S. Masia, B.B. 1964 Taxomony of educational objectives. handbook II: Affective domain New York David McKay
- Kemp, J.E. Dayton, K.K. 1985 Planning and producing instructional media 5th New York Harper & Row
- Kribs, H.D. Mark, L.J. 1982 An evaluation of media selection NPRDC Special Report 82-13 San Diego Instructional Science and Development, Inc.
- Kribs, H.D. Simpson, A.C. Mark, L.J 1983 Automated instructional media selection (AIMS) San Diego Instructional Science and Development, Inc.
- Levie, W.H. 1975 How to understand instructional media Viewpoints 51 5 25 42
- Lonigro, J.K., Jr. Eschenbrenner, A.J., Jr. 1973 A model for selecting media in technical/vocational education Audiovisual Instruction 27 32
- Lumsdaine, A.A. 1963 Instruments and media of selection Gage N.L. Handbook of research on teaching Chicago Rand-McNally 1963
- Lumsdaine, A.A. May, M.A. 1965 Mass communication and educational media Annual Review of Psychology , 16 475 535
- Main, R. Paulson, D. 1988 Guidelines for the development of military training decision aids San Diego Navy Personnel Research and Development Center
- Matlick, R.K. Rosen, M.H. Berger, D.C. 1980 Cost and training effectiveness analysis performance guide Springfield, VA Litton Mellonics Systems Development Division
- McConnell, J.T. 1974 Benson L.D. Bock H.R. Collins T. Cornell R.A. Dyer P.E. Haley M. Steen, L.E. Jr. Selecting media for learning: Readings from audio-visual instruction 22 26 Washington, DC Association for Educational Communications and Technology
- Melton, W.T. 1988 The development of an educational media selection system for officer training in the US Army Ann Arbor, MI UMI Dissertation Information Service
- Merideth, P. 1965 Toward a taxonomy of educational media AV Communication Review 13 374 384 Military specification: Requirements for training system development 1979
- O'Brien, L.H. 1983 User's guide: Media selection program Wilmington, MA Dynamics Research Corporation
- Procedures manual: 3306th Test and Evaluation Squadron 1987 August
- Reiser, R.A. 1981 A learning-based model for media selection: Development ARI Research Product 81-25c Tallahassee, FL Center for Educational Technology, Florida State University
- Reiser, R.A. Gagne, R.M. 1982 Characteristics of media selection models Review of Educational Research 52 499 512
- Reiser, R.A. Gagne, R.M. 1983 Selecting media for instruction Englewood Cliffs, NJ Educational Technology Publications
- Reiser, R.A. Gagne, R.M. Wager, W.W. Larsen, J.Y. 1981 A learning-based model for media selection: Media selection flowchart and user's guide ARI Research Product 81-25c Tallahassee, FL Center for Educational Technology, Florida State University
- Romiszowski, A.J. 1988 The selection and use of instructional media 2nd London Kogan Page Saettler, P. 1968 Design and selection factors Review of Educational Research 17 115 128
- Salomon, G. Snow, R.E. 1968 The specification of film attributes for psychological and educational research purposes AV Communication Review 16 225 244
- Simpson, E.J. 1972 The classification of educational objectives in the psychomotor domain The Psychomotor Domain Volume 3 Washington Gryphon House
- Software product specification for the learning objectives classification tool (LOC Tool) 1989 Wilmington, MA Dynamics Research Corporation
- Spangenberg, R.W. Riback, Y. Moon, H.L. 1973 The state of knowledge pertaining to selection of cost-effective training methods and media HumRRO Technical Report 73-13 Alexandria, VA Human Resources Research Organization
- Sorensen, H.B. 1990 U.S. joint service systems approach to training design Proceedings of the 1990 International Training Equipment Conference Birmingham, England April
- Sorensen, H.B. 1987 Computer-assisted instructional systems development/logistic support analysis for C-17 aircraft Proceedings of the 9th Interservice/Industry Training Systems Conference 14 19 Wash, DC
- Sorensen, H.B. Park, J.S., Jr. Awtry, P. 1990 Training systems for maintenance (TRANSFORM) media selection and target population description decision analysis
- Tosti, D.T. Ball, J.R. 1969 A behavioral approach to instructional design and media selection AV Communications Review 17 5 25
- Training analysis support computer system: User's guide 1987 San Diego, CA Logicon, Inc.
- Wilson, E.B. Papay, J.P. Prototype training technology application-decision support system (TTA-DSS) Advanced Technology
- Wulfeck, W.H. Ellis, J.A. Richards, R.E. Wood, N.D. Merrill, M.D. 1978 The instructional quality inventory: I. Introduction and overview San Diego, CA Navy Personnel and Development Center