This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Plane Strain Deep Drawing: Finite Element Modeling and Measurements
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Plane strain, deep drawing experiments were performed to obtain precise strain information for comparison with membrane section-analysis finite element modeling (FEM) results obtained using a FEM program, SHEET-S. Strains on both outer and inner specimen surfaces and draw-in displacements were carefully measured at various punch heights, for varying blank holder loads, and for three square-punch edge radii representing r/t ratio (radius/sheet thickness) of 3, 6, and 9. SHEET-S, a rigid-viscoplastic section analysis finite element program, for plane strain stretching and deep drawing with general tooling shape, has developed and tested by plane strain deep drawing of strips. Simulations and experiments are in good agreement for the large r/t ratios, but deteriorate for r/t ≈ 3, especially for low blank holder loads. Bending and unbending at these locations appear to dominate the deformation modes, causing significant differences from the strains predicted by the membrane FEM. A simple bending modification of membrane FEM results was necessary and introduced through t/2R correction, which gave good prediction of peak surface strains in cases of r/t ratio large than 6.
Authors
Citation
Wang, C. and Wagoner, R., "Plane Strain Deep Drawing: Finite Element Modeling and Measurements," SAE Technical Paper 910774, 1991, https://doi.org/10.4271/910774.Also In
References
- Hollomon J.H. Trans. ASME 162 1945 268
- Voce E. J .Inst. metals 74 1948 537
- Hill R. Proc. Roy.. Sci. London 1948 281
- Lankford W.T. Snyder S.C. Bauscher J.A. Trans. ASME 1950 42 1179
- Whiteley W.T. ‘Fundamental of deformation processing’ Proc. 9th Sagamore Army materials Res. Conf. 1962 183 189
- Keeler S.P. SAE paper no. 650535 1965
- Goodwin G.M. SAE Paper no. 680093 1968
- Ghosh A.K. J. Eng. Mater. Tech., (Trans. ASME, H) 1977 99 264
- Lee C.H. Kobayashi S. Elastoplastic Analysis of Plane Strain And Axisymmetric Flat Punch Indentation by the Finite Element Method Int. J. Mech. Sci. 12 1976 349 370
- Wang N.-M. Bundiansky B. Analysis of Sheet Metal Stamping by the Finite Element Method J. Appl. Mech., Trans. ASME 45 1978 73 82
- Zienkiewicz O.C. Onate E. Heinrich J. C. “Plastic Flow in Metal Forming, I.Couple Thermal; II.Thin Sheet Forming” Applications of Numerical Methods to Forming Processes Armanand H. Jones R.F. Jr. 28 ASME, NY 1078
- Gotoh M. Ishise F. A Finite Element Analysis of Rigid-plastic Deformation of Flange in a Deep-drawing Process Based on a Fourth-degree Yield function-II Int. J. Mech. Sci. 22 1980 367
- Tang S.C. Large Elasto-plastic Strain Analysis of Flanged Hole Forming Computers and Structures 13 1981 363 370
- Wang N.-M. “A Rigid-plastic Rate-sensitive FEM for Modeling Sheet Metal In-plane Stretching” General Motors Research Publication, GMR-4079 General Motors Research Laboratories Warren, Michigan June 1982
- Stoughton T.B. “Finite Element Modeling of 1008 AK Sheet Steel Stretched over a Rectangular Punch With Bending Effects” Computer Modeling of Sheet Metal Forming Process Wang N.-M. Tang T.C. 1985 143 160
- Tang S.C. Gress J. Ling P. “Sheet Metal Forming Modeling of Automobile Body Panels” Proc. 15th IDDRG Cong. 1988 185 194
- Germain Y. Chung K. Wagoner R.H. “A Rigid-visco-plastic Finite Element Program for Sheet Metal Forming Analysis” Int. J. Mech. Sci. 31 1989 1 24
- Frey W.H. Wenner M.L. “Development and Applications of a One-dimensional Finite Element Code for Sheet Metal Forming Analysis. Proc. of ASME Symposium on Interdisciplinary Issues in Materials Processing and Manufacturing Boston,MA Dec. 16
- Wagoner R.H. Wang C-T. Nakamachi E. “Quick Analysis of Sheet Metal Forming Using Sectional FEM” the 1st Japan Int. SAMP Symposium and Exhibition Nov. 28 Dec. 1 1989 Nippon Convention Center Chiba, Japan
- Wang C-T. Wagoner R.H. “Finite Element Analysis and Experimental Investigation of Square Punch Stretching and Draw-in Processes” Scientific Report for NSF Engineering Research Center of Net Shape Manufacturing The Ohio State University 1990 Report No. ERC/NSM-S-90-5
- Keum Y. T. Wang C-T. Wagoner R.H. “SHEET-S Version 2.0: Industrial Trial and User's Guide” Scientific Report of NSF Engineering Research Center of Net Shape Manufacturing The Ohio State University 1990 Report No. ERC/NSM-S-90-9
- Keum Y.T. Wang C.-T. Saran M. Wagoner R.H. “Practical Die Design Via Section Analysis” Int. Journal Mechanical Science
- Lee J. K. Chondhry S. “Plane Strain Finite Element Analysis of Sheet Forming Processes with Bending Effects” Report No. ERC/NSM-S-8934 The Engineering Research Center for Net Shape Manufacturing, the Ohio State University July 1989
- Keeler S.P. “Circular Grid System: A Valuable Aid for Evaluating Sheet-metal Formability” Sheet Metal Ind. Sept. 1968 6333
- Ayres R. Brewer E.G. Holland S. W. “Grid Circle Analyzer - Computer Aided Measurement in Deformation” SAE Trans., No. 790741 88 3 1979 2630 2634
- Knibloe J.R. M.S. Thesis the Ohio State University 1988
- Wagoner R.H. “Constitutive Equations for Sheet Forming Analysis” Computer Modeling of Sheet Metal Forming Process Wang N-M. Tang T.C. 1985 77 92
- Hill R. Math. Proc. Camb. Phil. Sci. 85 1979 179
- Hill R. Proc. Roy. Sci. London 1948 281
- Nine H.D. J. Appl. Metalworking 2 1982 193 199