This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Residual Injuries to Occupants Protected by Restraint Systems
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published September 01, 1989 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
This paper examines the distribution of injuries to belted occupants involved in frontal crashes, using data from the National Accident Sampling System. Similar studies of data from Canada, Britain, and Federal Republic of Germany are summarized. The studies are consistent in showing that head and chest injuries continue to be the most harmful to belted occupants. For restrained drivers, liver injuries contribute a significant level of harm among chest/abdominal injuries. Other significant lesions of nearly equal weight are arterial, heart, lung/pulmonary, skeletal, and crushing injuries. Brain injuries are by far the most harmful head injury, followed by skull fracture and facial fracture. The diverse distribution of injuries, and the wide variation in occupant sizes and injury tolerances are significant considerations in optimizing restraint systems for maximum injury reduction in real crashes.
Injury patterns for air bag restraints are also examined, based upon test data and field data. To date the air bags in service are performing as designed, and no patterns of serious injuries have emerged.
CitationDigges, K., Vernon, R., and Morris, J., "Residual Injuries to Occupants Protected by Restraint Systems," SAE Technical Paper 891974, 1989, https://doi.org/10.4271/891974.
- Finkelstein M. “United States Government Status Report,” presented at the 12th ESV Conference Goteborg, Sweden May 1989
- National Center for Statistics and Analysis “Occupant Protection Facts,” NHTSA June 1989
- Public Records available at NHTSA
- Malliaris A. C. Hitchcock R. Hedlund J. (NHTSA) “A Search for Priorities in Crash Protection,” SAE Paper 82024 Feb 1982
- Digges K. Haffner M. Cohen D. Eppinger R. “Crash Injury Analysis of Measurement Needs for an Improved Anthropomorphic Test Device,” Proceedings of the 1988 IRCOBI Conference 361 371 1988
- Rutherford W.H. Greenfield T. Hayes H.R.M. Nelson J.K. “The Medical Effects of Seat Belt Legislation in the United Kingdom,” HSMO Research Report 13 1985
- Harms P. Renouf P. Thomas P. Bradford M. “Injuries to Restrained Car Occupants: What are the Outstanding Problems?,” Proceedings of the 11th ESV Conference 183 200 1987
- Dalmotas D.J. “Mechanisms of Injury to Vehicle Occupants Restrained by Three-Point Seat Belts,” 24th Stapp Car Crash Conference” SAE 801311 1980
- Schmidt G. “Injury Patterns of Fatally Impacted Car Front Passengers in Regard to the Three-Point Seat Belt and Related Occupant Injury Modes,” SAE Paper 870225 Feb. 1987
- Otte D. Sudcamp N. Apple H. “Residual Injuries to Restrained Car Occupants in Front and Rear Seat Positions,” Proceedings of the 11th ESV Conference 211 219 1987
- Danner M. Langweiter K. Hummel T. “Experience from the Analysis of Accidents with a High Belt Usage Rate and Aspects of Continued Increase in Passenger Safety,” Proceedings of the 11th ESV Conference 201 210 1987
- Jonsson A. Clemedson C. Sundqvist A. Arbevo E. “Dynamic Factors Influencing the Production of Lung Injury in Rabbits Subjected to Blunt Chest Wall Impact,” Aviation, Space, and Environmental Medicine 50 4 325 337 1979
- Backaitis S. Roberts V. (NHTSA) Occupant Injury Patterns in Crashes with Air Bag Equipped Government Sponsored Cars,” Proceedings of the 31th Stapp Car Crash Conference, SAE Paper 872216 Nov 1987
- Kallina I. Schreier F. Zeidler F. (Daimler-Benz AG) “Can the Air Bag Efficiency be Derived from Real World Accidents?” Presentation at the 31st Stapp Car Crash Conference Nov 1987 (not published by SAE, available in the NHTSA Docket)
- Munson R. “The Passive Restraint Approach,” presented at the 12th ESV Conference Goteborg, Sweden May 1989
- Brinkley J.W. et al “Impact Tests of Near-Production Air Cushion Restraint,” U.S. Department of Transportation Report, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, No. HS-802-248 February 1977
- Digges K. “Summary of Recent Crash Tests of 1973 Chevrolets,” NHTSA Docket Submission Oct. 1977
- Cheng R. et al “Injuries to the Cervical Spine Caused by a Distributed Frontal Load to the Chest,” 26th Stapp Car Crash Conference 1 40 SAE 821155
- Digges K. Cohen D. Stucki L. (NHTSA) “The Application of Crash Victim Simulation Models in Assessing Injury Reduction Priorities,” Proceedings of the 1986 IRCOBI Conference Zurich Sept. 1986