This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Basilar Skull Fractures Produced by Facial Impacts - Case Histories and a Review of the Literature
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Basilar skull fractures have previously been described as the result of cranial vault impacts. Such fractures resulting from impacts to the chin, face and/or orbital areas (non-cranial vault areas) have not been adequately documented. These types of fractures and the motor vehicle incidents in which the injuries were sustained will be described according to the type of crash and vehicles involved. Data on the tolerance levels of the basilar region of the skull are sparce at best. Case histories of non-cranial vault impacts, presented in a variety of crash types, document that facial impacts can be the sole cause of basilar skull fractures. A historical review of the basilar skull fracture literature is presented.
Recommended Content
Authors
- Donald F. Huelke - Dept. of Anatomy and Cell Biology, University of Michigan Medical School
- William S. Smock - Dept of Anatomy, University of Louisville Medical School
- Peter M. Fuller - Dept of Anatomy, University of Louisville Medical School
- George R. Nichols - Dept. of Pathology, University of Louisville Medical School
Citation
Huelke, D., Smock, W., Fuller, P., and Nichols, G., "Basilar Skull Fractures Produced by Facial Impacts - Case Histories and a Review of the Literature," SAE Technical Paper 881711, 1988, https://doi.org/10.4271/881711.Also In
References
- Bell, C. “Surgical Observations,” Longmans London 1816
- Forgues, L.D. “Mecanisme des Fractures du Crane,” These de Strasbourg 1869
- Couderec, J.A. “Sur Ses Fractures du Crane,” These de Paris 1850
- Hewett, P. “Lectures on the Anatomy, Injuries and Diseases of the Head” Med. Times & Gaz 16 27 1858
- Bryant, T. “The Injuries and Diseases of the Nervous System,” Guy's Hosp. Ren. 20 59 1859
- Gurlt, E. “Handbuch der Lehre von den Knochenbruchen,” G. Crote Hamburg 1862
- Chauvel, F. “Essai sur les Fractures du Crane,” These de Paris 1864
- Chipault, A. Braquehaye, J “Etudes Graphiques sur les Fractures Indirectes de la Base du Crane (Definition et Mecanisme),” Arch. Gen, de Med, 4 176 292 1895
- Bennett, Dr. “Fractures of the Cranium,” Reports of Societies, Pathological Society of Dublin B.M.J. 1 326 Jan. 1875
- Petit, C.H. “Fracture de la Colonne Vertebrate: Fracture Indirecte de la Base du Crane; Fracture Incomplete de la Premiere Piece du Sternum,” Bull. Soc. Anat de Paris, 10 62 1875
- Bergmann Von “Verletzungen und Chirurgische Krankheiten des Kopfes” In Pithaand Billroth : Handbuch der Aligemernen und Speciellen, Ferdin and Suke Stuttgart 3 1873
- Laurand, G. “Fracture du Crane, Probabiement par Contre-Coup: Rupture de L'Artere Miningee Moyenne,” Bull. Soc. Anat. De Paris 4 721 1879
- Schranz, J. “Untersuchungen uber die Entstehung von Schadelbruchen,” Med. Jahrb. Wien 291 1881
- Hermann, N. “Experimentelle und Casuistische Studien uber Fracturen der Schadelbasis,” Inaug. Dissert. Dorpat 1881
- Von Wahl, E. “Ueber Fracturen der Schadelbasis,” Samml. klin. Vortr 228 1945 1969 1883
- Von Bergmann, E. “Indirekte Schussfrakturen der Schadelbasis,” Centralbl. f. Chir. 113 117 1880
- Korber, B. “Gerichtsarztliche Studien uber Schadeifracturen nach Einwirkung Stumpfer Gewalten,” Duetsche Ztschr. F., Chir 29 544 1889
- Heer, A. “Ueber Schadeibasisbruche,” Beitr. z. Klin. Chir. 9 1892
- Von Nes Ueber Schadeibasisbruche,” Deutsche Ztschr. f. Chir . 44 593 1897
- Phelps, C “A Clinico-Pathological Study of the Injuries of the Head,” New York, M. J. 57 29 1893
- Phelps, C. “Traumatic Injuries of the Brain and its Membranes,” D. Appleton & Company New York 1897
- Phelps, C. “Analytical and Statistical Review of One Thousand Cases of Head Injury,” Ann. Sura 49 449 477 593 613 50 1909 511 541 655 714 1909
- Von Bergmann, Ernst Von Bruns, P. Von Mikulicz, J. “A System of Practical Surgery,” Bull William T. Martin Walton Lea Bros. & Co. Philadelphia 1904
- Stierlin, R. “Schadelbasisfraktur mit Lahmungen im Gebiete des X und XII Hirnnerven,” Arch, f. klin. , Chir. 61 130 1900
- Vance, B.M. “Fractures of the Skull: Complications and Causes of Deaths: A Review of 512 Necropsies and of 61 Cases Studied Clinically,” Arch. Surg . 14 1023 1092 1927
- LeCount, E.R. Hockzema, J. “Symmetrical Traumatic Fractures of the Cranium; Symmetrical Fragmentation: Comments on Their Mechanism,” Arc. Surg 29 171 226 1934
- Moritz, A.R. “Mechanical Injuries of the Skeletomuscular System,” The Pathology of Trauma 2nd Lea & Febiger Philadelphia 340 390 1954
- Merignargues, G. Got, C. Tarriere, C. et al. “Les Fractures Circulaires de la Base du Crane au Cours des Accidents de la Route,” La Nouvelle Presse Medicale 4 31 2245 2248 Sept. 1975
- Reimann, W. “Zur. Mechanikder Schadelbasis Ringbruchen,” Dtsch. Z. Gesemte Gerichtl. Med. 51 601 608 1961
- Spasic, P. Rezic, A. “Ein Beitrag zur Kenntnis des Entstehungsmechanismus der Schadelbasisringbruche,” Z. Rechtsmedizin 67 324 328 1970
- Nagy, L. Haferland, W. “Extension Fracture des Schadel Basis bei Sturz Helmgessductztem Kopf,” Dtsch. Z. Ges. Gerichtl. Med. 66 9 12 1969
- Patscheider, H. “Zur Entsiehung von Ringbruchen des Schadelgrundes,” Dtsch. Z.Ges. Gerichtl. Med. 52 13 21 1961
- Voight, G.E. Skold, G. “Ring Fractures of the Base of the Skull,” J. of Trauma 14 6 494 505 June 1974
- Skold, G. Voight, G.E. “Spinal Injuries in Belt-Wearing Car Occupants Killed by Head-On Collisions,” Injury 9 2 151 167 Nov. 1977
- Shanahan, D.F. “Basilar Skull Fractures in U.S. Army Aircraft Accidents,” Aviation. Space and Environmental Medicine 54 7 628 631 July 1983
- Gurdjian, E.S. Webster, J.E. Lissner, H.R. “Studies on Skull Fracture with Particular Reference to Engineering Factors,” Am. J. of Surgery 57 736 742 Nov. 1949
- Gurdjian, E.S. Webster, J.E. Lissner, H.R. “Observations on Prediction of Fracture Site in Head injury,” J. of Radiology 60 226 235 Feb. 1953
- Hodgson, V.R. “Tolerance of the Facial Bones to impact,” Am. J. of Anatomy 120 113 122 Jan. 1967
- Hodgson, V.R. Brinn, J. Thomas, L.M. et al. “Fracture Behavior of the Skull Frontal Bone Against Cylindrical Surfaces,” Proc. 14th Stapp Car Crash Conf. SAE New York 341 355 1970
- Hodgson, V.R. Thomas, L.M. “Comparison of Head Acceleration Injury Indices in Cadaver skull Fracture” Proc. 15th Stapp Car Crash Conf SAE New York 190 206 1971
- Versus impact Surface Curvature,” Wayne State University Detroit, Mi DOT Contract No. HS-146-2-230-19
- Melvin, J.W. Evans, F.G. “A Strain Energy Approach to the Mechanics of Skull Fracture,” Proc. 15th Stapp Car Crash Conf SAE New York 666 685 1971
- Newman, J.A. “Head injury Criteria in Automotive Crash Testing,” Proc. 24th Stapp Car Crash Conf SAE Warrendale, PA. 701 747 1980
- Roberts, V.L. McElhaney, J.H. “Review of Head Injury Tolerance to Direct impact,” Intern. Conf, Biokinetics of impacts Lyon-Bron 241 251 1973
- Travis, L.W. Stalnaker, R.L Melvin, J.W. “Human Temporal Bone impact Trauma,” Proc. 20th A m,. Ass n , for Auto. Med. T Morton Grove, IL 382 393 1976
- Young, J.W. Fisher, R.G. Price, G.T. et al. “Experimental Trauma of Occipital impacts,” Proc. Intern. Conf. Biokinetics of impacts Lyon-Bron 271 283 1973
- Rawling, LB. “Fracture of the Skull” The gurg. of the Skull and Brain. Frowde O.V.P. Oxford Univ. Press London 68 134 1912
- Harvey, F.H. Jones, A.M. ““Typical” Basilar Skull Fracture of Both Petrous Bones: An Unreliable indicator of Head impact Site.” J. Foren. Set 25 280 286 1980
- Savei'eva, T.A. Matyshev, A.A. “O Mekhanizme Obrazovaniia KoPtsevidnvkh Perelomov Oshovaniia Cherepa,” Sud. Med. Expert. 14 47 48 1971
- Lau, I.V. t Viano, D.C. Gamero, F. “Invalidity of Speculated Injury Mechanism in Autopsy Reports.” General Motors Research Laboratories 24 Aug. 1987
- Felizet, G. “Reserches Anatomiques et Experimentales sur les Fractures du Crane,” Angien interne des Hopitaux de Paris Paris 13 1873
- Messerer, O. “Experimentelle Untersuchungen uber Schadelbruche,” M. Rieger Munich 1884
- Messerer, O. “Ueber Elasticitat und Festigkeit der Menschlichen,” Knoche. Stuttgart, J.G. Cotta Stuttgart 1880
- Messerer, O. “Ueber die Gerichtlich-Medizinische Bedeutung Verschiedener Knochenbruche - Formen,” Friedreich's Bl. f. Gerichtl., Med. 36 81 1885
- Alem, N.M. Nusholtz, G.S. Melvin, J.W. “Head & Neck Response to Axial Impacts,” Proc. 28th Stapp Car Crash Conf. SAE Warrendale, PA 275 299 1984
- Clemens, H.J. Burow, K. “Experimentelle Untersuchungen zur Verletzungsmechanic der Halswirbersauie beim Frontal-unt Heckaufprall,” Arch. Orthop. Unfall-Chir. 116 145 74 1972
- Schmidt, G. “Die Belastbarkeit des Halses und der Schadelbasis bei Indirecktem Trauma,” Internal, Conf. on Biokenetips of impact. Proc. Organisma Nationale de Securite, Routiere, Laboratoire, des Chocs Lyon-Bron 116 145 1973