This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Energy Loss in Vehicle Collisions
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Reconstruction methods typically are based upon impact velocity changes computed by one of two approaches. These are damage based or crush measurement techniques and impulse and momentum equation solutions. Crush measurement techniques have an analytical foundation based to a large extent on point mass collision theory, limited primarily to collisions of vehicles with a common final velocity at the contact surface. Impulse and momentum methods can treat a full, 2-dimensional collision with arbitrary restitution and friction coefficients. As such their analytical foundation is much broader than damage based or crush measurement methods. The energy loss relationship and the tangential correction factor form an important part of the crush measurement methods. These two relationships are derived in a more general fashion than has been available.
These two approaches are compared in this paper. The comparison focuses on the ability to accurately calculate energy loss. Data from some of the RICSAC experimental collisions is analyzed using the crush measurement model and the impulse and momentum model. The latter gives consistently low estimates of energy loss with accuracies ranging from −33% to 0%. The crush measurement model gives energy loss estimates which range from −55% to 109% of the experimental values. Though the crush measurement technique accuracy depends directly upon the ability to estimate of energy loss, the method appears to be less accurate in this respect than the impulse and momentum method.
Recommended Content
Technical Paper | Improving Witness Contributions to Reconstruction and Animation |
Authors
Topic
Citation
Brach, R., "Energy Loss in Vehicle Collisions," SAE Technical Paper 871993, 1987, https://doi.org/10.4271/871993.Also In
References
- Baker, J.S. Fricke, L.B. The Traffic-Accident Investigation Manual Northwestern U. Evanston 1986
- McHenry, R.R. “A Comparison of Results Obtained With Different Analytical Techniques for Reconstruction of Highway Accidents,” paper No. 750893 , SAE Warrendale, PA 15096
- Hess, R.L. “Microcomputer Programs Useful for Aspects of Accident Reconstruction,” Paper No. 800174 , SAE Warrendale, PA 15096
- Day, T.D. Hargens, R.L. “Differences Between EDCRASH and CRASH3,” Paper No. 850253 , SAE Warrendale, PA 15096
- Guenther, D.A. Wiechel, J.F. “Damage Algorithm for Determination of Speed,” Proceedings of the 1986 ASME Conference on Computers in ME Chicago August 1986
- Ishikawa, H. “Computer Simulation of Automobile Collision-Reconstruction of Accidents,” Paper 851729 , SAE Warrendale, PA 15096
- Fonda, A.G. “CRASH Extended for a Handheld Computer,” SAE International Congress Detroit February 1987
- Limpert, R. “Motor Vehicle Accident Reconstruction and Cause Analysis,” The Michie Company 1978
- Woolley, R.L. “The ‘IMPAC’ Computer Program for Accident Reconstruction,” Paper No. 850254 , SAE Warrendale, PA 15096
- Brach, R.M. “Impact Analysis of Two-Vehicle Collisions,” Paper 830468 , SAE Warrendale, PA 15096
- Anon. CRASH3 Users Guide and Technical Manual U.S. Dot NHTSA Washington, DC 29590
- Strother, C.E. et al “Crush Energy in Accident Reconstruction,” Paper No 860371 , SAE Warrendale, PA 15096
- Brach, Raymond M. Brach, R. Matthew “A Review of Impact Models for Vehicle Collisions,” Paper No 870048 , SAE Warrendale, PA, 15096
- Brach, R.M. “Momentum and Energy Analysis of Automobile Collisions,” Trans. Structural Impact and Crashworthiness Elsevier Appl. Sci. Publ. 1984
- Brach, Raymond M. “Least Squares Collision Reconstruction,” Paper No. 870429 , SAE Warrendale, PA, 15096
- Smith, R.A. Noga, J.T. “Examples of Staged Collisions in Accident Reconstruction,” ASME NY. 1980
- Jones, I.S. Baum, A.S. “Research Impact for Computer Simulation of Automobile Collisions, Volume IV, Staged Collision Reconstructions,” DOT HS-805040 December 1978
- Woolley, R.L. “Inaccuracies in the CRASH3 Program,” Paper No 850255 , SAE Warrendale, PA 15096
- Peters, G.A. Peters, B.J. Automotive Engineering and Litigation 1 Garland Publishing New York 1984