This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
On the Health Hazards of Particulate Diesel Engine Exhaust Emissions
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Recently, the issue of potential health hazards by Diesel exhaust emissions - in particular, lung cancer risk by inhalation of Diesel soot - has been addressed improperly in SAE publications. Some unqualified statements portrayed Diesel soot as an actual human health risk of measurable proportions for the general public, and the present situation was referred to as alarming. Such contentions will be rebutted in this paper, and an attempt is made to put the health aspects of Diesel exhaust emissions and any associated lung cancer risk into proper perspective.
Evidence is presented for common urban levels of general particulate air pollution containing all the Diesel soot to which the public is exposed to have no significant relation to the prevalence of lung cancer in urban areas. Furthermore, epidemiological studies of occupational exposure to Diesel exhaust emissions are demonstrated to be either negative or inconclusive. At best, such studies gave some very weak and disputed results indicating that, if existing, lung cancer risk from ambient airborne concentrations of Diesel soot must be extremely low. The same conclusion can be drawn from an indirect approach of deriving lung cancer risk by a comparative potency method.
The implication that a potential health hazard may result from Diesel soot inhalation came entirely from in vitro and in vivo laboratory exposures. The most recent in vivo laboratory efforts are briefly described, and it is shown that final answers are not yet available. However, there is a body of experimental evidence about mutagenic and carcinogenic properties of some components of Diesel soot exhausts, and, although this applies also to extracts of particulate urban pollution and to condensates of gasoline engine exhaust, this might be the limited foundation on which “regulatory scientists” could base their decision to label Diesel soot a potential carcinogen no matter how low the actual human risk may be.
Although publicly perceived as a health protection measure, the U.S. Emission Standards for particulate Diesel exhaust are not based on potential health hazards but have been promulgated exclusively on the basis of environmental aspects. It would be inconsistent then to mandate them for reasons of human health risks.
Recommended Content
Authors
Topic
Citation
Stöber, W., "On the Health Hazards of Particulate Diesel Engine Exhaust Emissions," SAE Technical Paper 871988, 1987, https://doi.org/10.4271/871988.Also In
SAE 1987 Transactions Alternative Engines and Engine Components and Systems
Number: V96-5; Published: 1988-09-01
Number: V96-5; Published: 1988-09-01
References
- Abel und J. Misfeld Ergebnisse der Epidemiologie des Lungenkrebses Umweltbundesamt Berichte 3 1 187 1986
- Albert R.E. Lewtas J. Nesnow S. Thorslund T.W. Anderson E. Comparative potency method for cancer risk assessment: application to diesel particulate emissions Risk Analysis 3 101 117 1983
- Brightwell J. Fouillet X. Cassano-Zoppi A.-L. Gatz R. Duchosal F. Neoplastic and functional changes in rodents after chronic inhalation of engine exhaust emissions Carcinogenic and Mutagenic Effects of Diesel Exhaust Ishinishi N. et al. 471 485 Elsevier Science Publ. Amsterdam 1986
- Cuddihy R.G. Griffith W.C. McClellan R.O. Health risks from light-duty diesel vehicles Environmental Science & Technology 18 14A 21A 1984
- Commission for the Investigation of Health Hazards of Chemical Compounds in the Work Area, Maximum Concentrations at the Workplace and Biological Tolerance Values for Working Materials 1986 Report No. XXII Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft, VCH-Verlagsgesellschaft mbH Weinheim 1986
- Federal Register, Part II, Office of Science & Technology Policy Chemical carcinogens; a review of the science and its associated principles, February 1985. 10372 10442 Washington, D.C. March 14 1985
- Federal Register, Part II, Environmental Protection Agency Guidelines for carcinogen risk assessment 33992 34003 Washington, D.C. September 24 1986
- Garshick E. Schenker M.B. Munoz A. Smith T.J. Woskie S. Hammond K. Speizer F.E. Diesel exhaust exposure and lung cancer in US railroad workers 4th Health Effects Institute Annual Conference Seabrook Island S.C. February 8 - 12, 1987 A case-control study of lung cancer and diesel exhaust exposure in railroad workers (EPA grant report R-807515) Speizer F.E. Smith T. Thilly W. Health effects of exposure to diesel exhaust (EPA grant report R-807515)
- Hall N.E.L. Wynder E.L. Diesel exhaust exposure and lung cancer A case-control study. Environmental Research 34 1984
- Hammond E.C. Selikoff I. Lawther P. Seidman H. Inhalation of benzpyrene and cancer in man Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 271 116 124 1976
- Harris J.E. Potential risk of lung cancer from diesel engine emissions Report to the Diesel Impacts Study Committee Assembly of Engineering, National Research Council 1 62 National Academy of Sciences Washington, D.C. 1981
- Health Effects Institute Societal implications and research issues for diesel use 4th Health Effects Institute Annual Conference Seabrook Island, S.C. February 8 - 12. 1987
- Heinrich U. Stöber W. Pott F. Long-term diesel exhaust inhalation studies with hamsters Health Effects of Diesel Engine Emissions: Proceedings of an International Symposium 2 1026 1047 1980
- Heinrich U. Peters L. Funcke W. Pott F. Mohr U. Stöber W. Investigation of toxic and carcinogenic effects of Diesel exhaust in long-term inhalation exposure of rodents Toxicological Effects of Emissions from Diesel Engines Lewtas J. 225 242 Elsevier Science Publ. New York 1982
- Heinrich U. Muhle H. Takenaka S. Ernst H. Fuhst R. Mohr U. Pott F. Stöber W. Chronic effects on the respiratory tract of hamsters, mice and rats after long-term inhalation of high concentrations of filtered and unfilteted diesel engine emissions Journal of Applied Toxicology 6 383 395 1986
- Hsieh L.L. Wong D. Heisig V. Santella R.M. Mauderly J.L. Mitchell C.E. Wolff R.K. Jeffrey A.M. Analysis of genotoxic components in diesel engine emissions Carcinogenic and Mutagenic Effects of Diesel Exhaust Ishinishi N. et al. 223 232 Elsevier Science Publ. Amsterdam 1986
- Jasanoff S. Scientific information and regulatory decision making 4th Health Effects Institute Annual Conference Seabrook Island, S.C. February 8 - 12, 1987
- Kawabata Y. Iwai K. Udagawa T. Tukagoshi K. Higuchi K. Effects of Diesel soot on unscheduled DNA synthesis of tracheal epithelium and lung tumor formation Carcinogenic and Mutagenic Effects of Diesel Exhaust Ishinishi N. et al. 213 222 Elsevier Science Publ. Amsterdam 1986
- Kotin P. Falk H.L. Thomas. M. Aromatic hydrocarbons II. Presence in the particulate phase of gasoline-engine exhaust and the carcinogenicity of exhaust extracts A.M.A. Arch. Indust. Hyg. & Occup. Med. 9 164 177 1954
- Kotin P. Falk H.L. Thomas M. Aromatic hydrocarbons III. Presence in the particulate phase of diesel-engine exhaust and the carcinogenicity of exhaust extracts A.M.A. Arch. Indust. Health. 11 113 120 1955
- Lawther P.J. Waller R.E. Henderson M. Air pollution and exacerbations of bronchitis Thorax 25 525 539 1970
- Lee K.P. Trochimowicz H.J. Reinhardt C.F. Pulmonary response of rats exposed to titanium dioxide (TiO 2 ) by inhalation for two years Toxicol. Appl. Pharmacol. 79 179 192 1985
- Leiter J. Schimkin M.B. Shear M.J. Production of subcutaneous sarcomas in mice with tars extracted from atmospheric dusts Journal Natl. Cancer Inst. 3 155 165 1942-43
- Lodge J.P. A rational basis for national ambient air standards for particulate matter Aerosol Science and Technology 5 459 468 1986
- Martin J.C. Daniel H. Le Bouffant L. Short- and long-term experimental study of the toxicity of coal-mine dust and of some of its constituents Inhaled Particles IV Walton W.H. 1 361 372 Pergamon Oxford 1977
- Mauderly J.L. Jones R.K. McClellan R.O. Henderson R.F. Griffith W.C. Carcinogenicity of diesel exhaust inhaled chronically by rats Carcinogenic and Mutagenic Effects of Diesel Exhaust Ishinishi N. et al. 397 409 Elsevier Science Publ. Amsterdam 1986
- McClellan R.O. Health effects of diesel exhaust: A case study in risk assessment American Industrial Hygiene Assoc. Journal 47 1 13 1986 a
- McClellan R.O. Conclusions and recommendations: Toxicological effects of emissions from diesel engines Carcinogenic and Mutagenic Effects of Diesel Exhaust Ishinishi N. et al. 529 534 Elsevier Science Publ. Amsterdam 1986 b
- özkaynak H. Spengler J.D. Garsd A. Thurston. G.D. Assessment of population health risks resulting from exposures to airborne particles Aerosols Lee S.D. et al. 529 534 Lewis Publ. Chelsea, Michigan 1986
- Pepelko W.E. EPA studies on the toxicological effects of inhaled Diesel engine emissions Toxicological Effects of Emissions from Diesel Engines Lewtas J. 529 534 Elsevier Science Publ. New York 1982
- Raffle P. The health of the worker British Journal of Industrial Medicine 14 73 80 1957
- Schenker M.B. A. Munoz and F.E. Speizer, Lung cancer and occupational exposures to diesel exhaust: A pilot study of railroad workers Health Issues Related to Metal and Nonmetallic Mining Wagner W.L. et al. 529 534 Butterworth Publ. Boston 1983
- Stöber W. Experimental induction of tumors in hamsters, mice and rats after long-term inhalation of filtered and unfiltered diesel engine exhaust Carcinogenic and Mutagenic Effects of Diesel Exhaust Ishinishi N. et al. 529 534 Elsevier Science Publ. Amsterdam 1986
- Takemoto K. Yoshimura H. Katayama H. Effects of chronic exposure to diesel exhaust on the development of lung tumors in di-isopropanol-nitrosamine-treated F344 rats and newborn C57BL and ICR mice Carcinogenic and Mutagenic Effects of Diesel Exhaust Ishinishi N. et al. 529 534 Elsevier Science Publ. Amsterdam 1986
- Vostal J.J. Factors limiting the evidence for chemical carcinogenicity of diesel emissions in long-term inhalation experiments Carcinogenic and Mutagenic Effects of Diesel Exhaust Ishinishi N. et al. 529 534 Elsevier Science Publ. Amsterdam 1986
- Waller R.E. Trends in lung cancer in London in relation to exposure to diesel fumes Health Effects of Diesel Engine Emissions: Proceedings of an International Symposium 2 529 534 1980
- Walsh M.P. The Commission proposal for control of Diesel particulate European Environment Bureau July 2 1986
- Walsh M.P. The benefits and costs of Diesel particulate Control; V: Methanol fuel for the in-use urban bus SAE Technical Paper Series No. 870013 529 534 Washington, D.C. 1987
- Walsh M.P. Worldwide developments in motor vehicle pollution control - a 1937 overview SAE Technical Paper Series No. 871072 529 534 Washington, D.C. 1987
- Wolff R.K. Henderson R.F. Snipes M.B. Sun J.D. Bond J.A. Mitchell C.E. Mauderly J.L. McClellan R.O. Lung retention of Diesel soot and associated organic compounds Carcinogenic and Mutagenic Effects of Diesel Exhaust Ishinishi N. et al. 529 534 Elsevier Science Publ. Amsterdam 1986
- Wolff R.K. Henderson R.F. Snipes M.B. Griffith W.C. Mauderly J.L. Cuddihy R.G. McClellan R.O. Alterations in particle accumulation and clearance in lungs of rats chronically exposed to diesel exhaust Fundam. and Appl. Toxicol. 9 154 166 1987
- Wong O. Morgan R.W. Kheifets L. Larson S.R. Whorton M.D. Mortality among members of a heavy construction equipment operators union with potential exposure to diesel exhaust emissions British Journal of Industrial Medicine 42 435 448 1985