This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Restraint System Effectiveness as a Function of Seating Position
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Drawing on provincial data files maintained by Transport Canada, the injury experience of passenger vehicle occupants as a function of occupant seating position, reported restraint use and occupant age is examined. Particular attention is given to the issue of rear seat lap belt effectiveness. Estimates of restraint system effectiveness are derived using a variety of approaches. These range from direct comparisons of the relative injury/fatality rates of restrained and unrestrained occupants in reportable accidents to double-pair comparisons based on “subject” and “control” occupants in fatal accidents.
Available Canadian data suggest that the use of three-point seat belts by front seated occupants and the use of lap belts by rear seated occupants substantially reduces the likelihood of serious or fatal injury. The likelihood of serious injury or death among front seated occupants is reduced by 40%-55% through the use of a three-point seat belt, and among rear seated occupants by 20-50% through the use of a lap belt. Three-point seat belts were observed to be slightly more effective in frontal impacts than in non-frontal impacts. The situation is reversed in the case of lap belts. The degree to which the effectiveness estimates may be exaggerated either by exposure differences between restrained and unrestrained occupants or by inaccuracies in police-reported restraint use is discussed.
Recommended Content
Technical Paper | The Effectiveness of Rear-Seat Lap-Belts in Crash Injury Reduction |
Technical Paper | Crash Protection for Rear Seat Occupants |
Technical Paper | The Seat Belt Syndrome in Children |
Authors
Citation
Dalmotas, D. and Krzyzewski, J., "Restraint System Effectiveness as a Function of Seating Position," SAE Technical Paper 870489, 1987, https://doi.org/10.4271/870489.Also In
References
- National Transportation Safety Board Safety Study: Performance of Lap Belts in 26 Frontal Crashes, NTSB/SS-86/03, PB86-917006 Washington, D.C. 1986
- Dalmotas, D.J. Dance, D.M. Gardner, W.T. Gutoskie, P.A. Smith, G.A. Current Activities in Canada Relating to the Protection of Children in Automobile Accidents, Road Safety and Motor Vehicle Regulation Directorate SAE Paper 840529 Society of Automotive Engineers 1984
- Road Safety Leaflet CL 8308 (E) Transport Canada Ottawa December 1983
- Final Regulatory Impact Analysis. Amendment to FMVSS No. 208 National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, Office of Planning and Analysis July 11 1984
- Evans, L. The Effectiveness of Safety Belts in Preventing Fatalities, Transportation Research Development General Motors Research Laboratories, Research Publication GMR-5088 June 24 1985
- Evans, L. Rear Seat Effectiveness in Preventing Fatalities, Operating Systems Research Department General Motors Research Laboratories, Research Publication GMR-5465 June 24 1986 92
- Scherz, R.G. Fatal Motor Vehicle Accidents of Children Passengers from Birth Through 4 Years of Age in Washington State Pediatrics 68 4 1981
- Knoop, J.C. Costenoble, K. Ball, J.T. Northrop, G.M. Statistical Evaluation of the Effectiveness of Child Restraints Report No. Dot-Hs-805-660 Centre for the Environment and Man September 1980
- O'Day, J. Flora, J. Alternative Measures of Restraint System Effectiveness: interaction with Crash Severity Factors Society of Automotive Engineers SAE Paper 820798 1982
- Evans, L. Wasielewski, P. Risky Driving Related to Driver and Vehicle Characteristics Accident Analysis and Prevention 15 121 136 1983
- Evans, L. Belted and Unbelted Driver Accident involvement Rates Compared, Operating Systems Research Department General Motors Research Laboratories, Research Publication GMR-5419 May 21 1986
- Evans, L. Double-Pair Comparison - A New Method to Determine How Occupant Characteristics Affect Fatality Risk in Traffic Crashes General Motors Research Laboratory Publication 1985a
- Statistisearch. An Analysis of Seat Belt Usage in Ontario, May 1978 Ministry of Transportation and Communications Ontario October 1978
- Seat Belt Usage and Driver Attitude Survey, May 1981 Ministry of Transportation and Communications, Policy Planning and Research Division 1981
- The 1979 Ontario Roadside BAC Survey: Summary Report Interministerial Committee on Drinking-Driving February 1980
- Dalmotas, D.J. Mechanisms of Injury to Vehicle Occupants Restrained by Three-Point Restrained Occupants SAE Paper 801311 Proceedings of the 24TH Stapp Car Crash Conference Troy, Michigan October 15-17 1980
- Backaitis, S.H. Dalmotas, D.J. injury Patterns and injury Sources of Unrestrained and Three-Point Belt Restrained Car Occupants in injury-Producing Frontal Collisions Proceedings of the 29th Annual Conference of the American Association for Automotive Medicine Washington, D.C. October 7-9 1985