This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Motor Vehicle Occupant Fatalities in Four States with Seat Belt Use Laws
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Seat belt use laws in New York, Michigan, New Jersey, and Illinois reduced front seat occupant fatalities by an estimated 16, 10, 6 and five percent respectively, during the months in 1985 they were in effect. Only the reduction for New York was statistically significant, but the similarity between the pattern of fatality reductions and the pattern of increases in seat belt use lends credibility to the estimates. Each reduction was less than expected given the known effectiveness of seat belts and the observed rates of use in noncrash populations, suggesting again that seat belt use laws are less successful in increasing belt use among those who are more likely to be in crashes. Pedestrian fatalities were unaffected by the laws, indicating that “risk compensation” was not a factor modifying the success of the laws.
Recommended Content
| Technical Paper | Assessment of Seat Belt Usage-Methods/Results/ Recommendations |
| Technical Paper | The Effectiveness of Rear-Seat Lap-Belts in Crash Injury Reduction |
Authors
Citation
Lund, A., Zador, P., and Pollner, J., "Motor Vehicle Occupant Fatalities in Four States with Seat Belt Use Laws," SAE Technical Paper 870224, 1987, https://doi.org/10.4271/870224.Also In
References
- National Highway Traffic Safety Administration 1981-1985 Fatal Accident Reporting System 1980-1984 Washington, DC US Department of Transportation
- Goodell-Grivas, Inc. 1985 Restraint System Usage in the Traffic Population Springfield, VA National Technical Information Service
- Williams, A.F. Lund, A.K. 1986 Seat belt use laws and occupant protection in the United States American Journal of Public Health 76 1438 1442
- Williams A.P. Wells J. Lund, A.K. 1986 Shoulder belt use in four states with belt use laws Insurance Institute for Highway Safety Washington DC
- Wagenaar A. 1986 Direct Observation of Seat Belt Use in Michigan: December 1985 Univ. Michigan Transportation Research Institute
- Poldvary, L.C. Lane, J.C. 1974 The effectiveness of compulsory wearing of seat belts in casualty reduction Accident Analysis and Prevention 6 69 81
- Department of Transport (Great Britain) 1985 Compulsory Seat Belt Wearing London HMSO Publications Centre
- Fisher, F.B. Jr., 1980 Effectiveness of Safety Belt Usage Laws National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, U.S. Department of Transportation Washington, DC
- Pierce, J. 1979 Safety benefits of the seat belt legislation and speed limit reduction in Ontario Proceedings of the American Associ ati on of Automotive Medicine
- Jonah, B.A. Lawson, J. 1984 The effectiveness of the Canadian mandatory seat belt use laws Accident Analysis and Prevention 16 5/6 433 450
- Lund, A.K. Pollner, J. Williams, A.F. Preliminary estimates of the effects of mandatory seat belt use laws Accident Analysis and Prevention
- Williams, A.F. O'Neill, B. 1979 Seat belt laws: Implications for occupant protection Warrendale, PA Society for Automotive Engineers Technical Series Paper # 790683
- Preusser, D.F. Williams, A.F Lund, A.K. Seat belt use among New York bar patrons Journal of Public Health Policy
- Insurance Institute for Highway Safety 1986 Seat belt use claims: Some too good to be true Status Report 21 4 1
- Box, G.E.P. Jenkins, G.M. 1970 Time Series Analysis Forecasting and Control London Holden-Day
- Brick J.M. Edmonds H.J. Lago A.F. 1986 New Jersey State Observational Survey of Safety Belt Usage NHTSA, US DOT Washington DC
- Institute for Traffic Safety Management and Research 1985 Evaluation of New York State's Mandatory Occupant Restraint Law: Observational Surveys of Safety Restraint Use in New York State Albany, NY
- National Highway Traffic Safety Administration 1984 Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard; Occupant Crash Protection; Final Rule (48 CFR Part 571) Federal Register 49 138 28962 29010
- Evans, L. 1986 The effectiveness of safety belts in preventing fatalities Accident Analysis and Prevention 18 3 229 241
- Jonah, B.A. Grant, B.A. 1985 Long-term effectiveness of selective traffic enforcement programs for increasing seat belt use Journal of Applied Psychology 80 257 263
- Williams, A.F. Preusser, D.F. Blomberg, R.D. Lund, A.K. Results of a seat belt use law enforcement and publicity campaign in Elmira, New York Accident Analysis and Prevention
- Peltzman, S. 1975 The effects of automobile safety regulation Journal of Political Economy 83 4 677 725
- Wilde, G. J. S. 1982 Critical issues in risk homeostasis theory Risk Analysis 2 4 249 258
- Lund, A.K. Zador, P. 1984 Mandatory belt use and driver risk taking Risk Analysis 4 1 41 53
- O'Neill, B. Lund, A.K. Zador, P. Ashton, S. 1985 Mandatory belt use and driver risk taking: An empirical evaluation of the risk-compensation hypothesis Evans L. Schwing R.C. Human Behavior and Traffic Safety New York Plenum Press 93 107