This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Evaluating the Subjective Workload of Directional Orientation Tasks with Varying Display Formats
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published October 13, 1986 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
An experiment was conducted to investigate the impact of various flight-related tasks on the workload imposed by the requirement to compute new headings, course changes and reciprocal headings. Nine instrument-rated pilots were presented with a series of heading-change tasks in a laboratory setting and in a single-place instrument trainer. Two levels of difficulty of each of three tasks were presented verbally (numeric values embedded in simple commands), spatially (headings were depicted on a graphically drawn compass) and combined (each of the previous displays were given simultaneously). In the instrument- trainer setting problems were presented orally by one of the experimenters and no effort was made to manipulate display types. Performance was measured by evaluating the speed (response times) and accuracy (percent correct and time outs) of the responses. The workload experienced by the pilots under each experimental condition was determined by responses to a standard set of bipolar rating scales. These subjective measures reflected the differences between levels of difficulty and types of tasks, but were generally insensitive to the manipulation of display type. The performance measures, however, displayed significant differences for all manipulations. Problems presented in the combined and alpha display formats, were done significantly faster and with significantly greater accuracy than problems in the compass format alone suggesting that the pilots were primarily using the alpha information contained in the combined display to perform the calculations. Workload ratings for the compass-only laboratory condition and the instrument trainer portion of the study were virtually identical across all conditions.
CitationMiller, R., Bortolussi, M., and Hart, S., "Evaluating the Subjective Workload of Directional Orientation Tasks with Varying Display Formats," SAE Technical Paper 861640, 1986, https://doi.org/10.4271/861640.
- Childress, M.E. Hart, S.G. Bortolussi, M. 1982 The Reliability and Validity of Flight Task Workload Ratings Proceedings of the 26th Annual Meeting of the Human Factors Society Seattle, Wa. Human Factors Society 319 323
- Hart, S.G. Battiste, V. Lester, P. 1981 POPCORN: A complex Supervisory Control Simulation for Workload and Performance Research Proceedings of the Twentieth Annual Conference on Manual Control. NASA CP-2341 Washington, D.C. National Aeronautics and Space Administration 431 451
- Hart, S. G. Bortolussi, M. R. 1984 Pilot Errors as a Source of Workload- Human Factors 26 5 515 556
- Kantowitz, B. H. Hart, S.G. Bortolussi, M. R. 1983 Measuring Pilot Workload in a Moving Base Simulator I.: Asynchronous Secondary Choice-reaction Task Proceedings of the Human Factors Society 27th Annual Meeting Norfolk, Va. 319 323
- Kantowitz, B. H. Hart, S. G. Bortolussi, M. R. Shively, R. J. Kantowitz, S. C. 1984 Measuring Pilot Workload in a Moving Base Simulator II.: Building Levels of Workload Proceedings of the Twentieth Annual Conference on Manual Control. NASA CP-2341 Washington, D. C. National Aeronautics and Space Administration 359 372
- Miller, R. C. Hart, S. G. 1984 Assessing the Subjective Workload of Directional Orientation Tasks Proceedings of the Twentieth Annual Conference on Manual Control. NASA CP-2341 Washington, D. C. National Aeronautics and Space Administration 85 96