This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Evaluation of Camshaft and Lifter Wear, Deposits, and Oil Thickening with Low-Phosphorus Engine Oils in Taxicab Service
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published October 01, 1986 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
A 160 000-km taxi test was run to determine the effects of low-phosphorus engine oils on engine durability. Camshaft and lifter wear, deposits, and oil-thickening were evaluated in thirty vehicles with oil-change intervals purposely extended to increase test severity. Three SAE 5W-30, SF, low-phosphorus (≈0.06 mass percent) oils and two SAE 10W-30, SF/CC, normal-phosphorus (≈0.11 mass percent) oils were evaluated.
Overall engine durability and performance was satisfactory with two of the three low-phosphorus, and one of the normal-phosphorus oils, and unsatisfactory (because of high wear) with the other oils.
These results demonstrate that low-phosphorus oils can be provided if further phosphorus reduction is necessary to protect emission control systems, and that current normal-phosphorus oils must be properly formulated to protect engines.
CitationSmolenski, D. and Kabel, R., "Evaluation of Camshaft and Lifter Wear, Deposits, and Oil Thickening with Low-Phosphorus Engine Oils in Taxicab Service," SAE Technical Paper 861516, 1986, https://doi.org/10.4271/861516.
- Caracciolo F., Spearot J. A., “Effects of Phosphorus-Containing Engine Oil Additives on Exhaust Oxidation Catalyst Degradation,” SAE Paper 760562.
- Spearot J. A., Caracciolo F., “Engine Oil Phosphorus Effects on Catalytic Converter Performance in Federal Durability and High-Speed Vehicle Tests,” SAE Paper .770637.
- Minamitani H., Ikuyama A., Machida C., Kawashima K., Matsudaira Y., Furui J., “Effects of Engine Oil Additives on the Activity of Exhaust Gas Catalysts,” J. Japan Petrol. Inst., 21, No. 2, pp. 116-120, 1978.
- Shelef M., Otto K., Otto N. C., “Poisoning of Automotive Catalysts,” Advanced Catalysis, Vol. 27, p. 311, 1978.
- Brazier A. D., Elliot J. S., “The Thermal Stability of Zinc Dithiophosphates,” J. Inst. Petroleum, 53, 518, February, 1967.
- Rounds F. G., “Some Factors Affecting the Decomposition of Three Commercial Zinc Organodithiophosphates,” ASLE Transactions 18, 2, 79-89, 1973.
- Baldwin B. A., “Relationship Between Surface Composition and Wear: An X-Ray Photoelectron Spectroscopic Study of Surfaces Tested with Organosulfur Compounds,” ASLE Preprint, 75-LC-2D-4, 1975.
- Bennett P. A., Kabel R. H., “The Antiscuff Performance of Metal Organodithiophosphate,” ASLE Journal, Vol. 19, 1963.
- Coy R. C., Jones R. B., “The Thermal Degradation and EP Performance of Zinc Dialkyldithiophosphate Additives in White Oil,” ASLE Preprint No. 79-LC-2B-1, 1979.
- Baldwin B. A., “Wear Mitigation by Antiwear Additives in Simulated Valve Train Wear,” ASLE Preprint No. 81-LC-6A-1, 1981.
- Howard J. A., Ohkatzu Y., Chenier J. H. B., Ingold K. V., “Metal Complexes as Antioxidants. I. The Reaction of Zinc Dialkyldithiophosphates and Related Compounds with Peroxy Radicals,” Can. J. Chem., Vol. 51, 1973.
- Burn A. J., Cecil R., Young V. O., “Peroxide-Decomposing Antioxidants. Mechanism of the Decomposition of Cumene Hydroperoxide in the Presence of Zinc Di-isopropyl Dithiophosphate,” J. Inst. Petroleum, 57, 558, 1971.
- Smolenski D. J., Kabel R. H., “Effect of Engine Oil Zinc Dithiophosphate (ZDP) Additive Type on Cam and Lifter Wear in Taxi Service,” SAE Paper 831760.
- SAE Recommended Practice, Engine Oil Performance and Engine Service Classification -- J183 AUG84, SAE Handbook.
- SAE Recommended Practice, Engine Oil Viscosity Classification - SAE J300 APR84, SAE Handbook.
- Coordinating Research Council Manuals 4 (January 1969), 9 (June 1971), and 12 (September 1976) for rating engine deposits, varnish, and sludge, respectively, Atlanta, Georgia.
- Pless L. G., “Deposits, Wear, and Catalyst Performance with Low-Ash and Ashless Engine Oils,” SAE Paper 750900.
- Helwig J. T., Council K. A. SAS (Statistical Analysis System) User's Guide, 1979 ed. SAS Institute, Cary, North Carolina.
- SAE Recommended Practice, Engine Oil Tests -- SAE J304 JUN82, SAE Handbook.
- Japanese Automotive Standard JASO M 328-83.
- Torii K., Chida H., Otsubo K., Tsusaka Y., “Antiwear Properties of Engine Oils -- Effects of Oil Additives on Valve Train Wear,” SAE Paper No. 770635.
- Arnold R. F. personal communication, September 14, 1982.
- “1985 Annual Book of ASTM Standards,” American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM), Section 5, Volumes 5.01, 5.02.
- Blane R. L., “Oxidative Stability of Oils and Greases,” DuPont Application Brief, TA41 (1974).
- Walker J. A., Tsang W., “Characteristics of Lubricating Oils by Differential Scanning Calorimetry,” SAE Paper 801383.