This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
A Comparison of Methanol and Dissociated Methanol Illustrating Effects of Fuel Properties on Engine Efficiency—Experiments and Thermodynamic Analyses
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Methanol, a popular alternative fuel candidate, can theoretically be dissociated on-board a vehicle into a 2/1 molar mixture of hydrogen (H2) and carbon monoxide (CO) having a 14 percent greater heating value than that of methanol vapor. In this study, engine efficiency and fuel consumption with methanol vapor and dissociated methanol (simulated by a 2/1 mixture of Ha and CO) were compared in a single-cylinder engine at equivalence ratios (Φ’s) ranging from 0.5 to 0.9 and compression ratios (CR’s) from 11 to 14. Whan compared at the same Φ and CR, the reduction in fuel consumption for dissociated methanol compared to methanol (3-7 percent) was smaller than would be expected based on heating value alone. Indicated thermal efficiency with dissociated methanol was only 0.89-0.55 times that with methanol.
Thermodynamic analyses were conducted to isolate the factors responsible for lower efficiency with dissociated methanol. The largest factor was dissociated methanol’s lower molecular weight (10.68 compared to 32.04 for methanol), causing an increase in compression work. Also, the higher heating value of dissociated methanol caused an increase in heat losses from the engine. Factors opposing the loss in efficiency with dissociated methanol were its faster burning rate and higher heat capacity per unit mass.
Recommended Content
Authors
Topic
Citation
Brinkman, N. and Stebar, R., "A Comparison of Methanol and Dissociated Methanol Illustrating Effects of Fuel Properties on Engine Efficiency—Experiments and Thermodynamic Analyses," SAE Technical Paper 850217, 1985, https://doi.org/10.4271/850217.Also In
References
- Benson, J. D. “What Good are Octanes?,” Chamtech 16 22 1976
- Gray, C. Jr. “Methanol - The Transportation Fuel of the Future,” Order No. 820-0021, presented at 48th Midyear Refining Meeting American Petroleum Institute Los Angeles, CA 1983
- “Removing Barriers to the Market Penetration of Methanol Fuels,” Report No. GAO/RCED-84-35 U.S. General Accounting Office Gaithersburg, MD 1983
- Gallopoulos, N. E. “U.S. Automotive Fuels - 1982 Shapes a New Outlook,” SAE Paper No. 821251 , Toronto, Ontario 1962
- Menrad, H. Decker, G. Weidman, K. “Alcohol Fuel Vehicles of Volkswagen,” Paper No. 820968 , West Coast International Meeting, SAE, San Francisco, CA 1982
- Lindner B. Sjostrom, K. “Operation of an Internal Combustion Engine Under Lean Conditions with Hydrogen Produced in an Onboard Methanol Reforming Unit,” V International Alcohol Fuel Symposium on Alcohol Fuels Technology Auckland, New Zealand 1982
- Inagaki, T. Hirota, T. Ueno, Z. “Combustion and Emission of Gaseous Fuel from Reformed Methanol in Automotive Engine,” Proceedings of 3rd International Symposium on Alcohol Fuels Technology Asilomar, CA 1979
- Hirota, T. “Study of the Methanol-Reformed Gas Engine,” JSAE Review 1981
- Purohit G. Houseman, J. “Methanol Decomposition Bottoming Cycle for IC Engines,” SAE Paper No. 790427 , Detroit, Michigan 26 1979
- Finegold, J. Karpuk, M. McKinnon, J. Passamaneck, R. “Demonstration of Dissociated Methanol as an Automotive Fuel: System Performance,” SERI/TP-731/1178 Solar Energy Research Institute Golden, Colorado 1981
- “Decomposed Methanol workshop Report - Alternative Fuels utilization Contractors’ Coordination Meeting,” U.S. Department of Energy Report No. CONF-8306135 1983
- Bechtold, R. L. Timbario, T. J. Ecklund, E. E. “The Theoretical Limits and Practical Considerations of Decomposed Methanol as a Light-Duty Vehicle Fuel,” Paper A-5, VI International Symposium on Alcohol Fuels Technology Ottawa, Canada 1984
- Finegold J. G. Glinsky, G. P. “Dissociated Methanol Vehicle Test Results,” Paper A-21, VI International Symposium on Alcohol Fuels Technology Ottawa, Canada 1984
- Yoon, H. Stouffer, M. R. Dudt, P. J. Burke, F. P. Curran, G. P. “Methanol Dissociation for Fuel Use,” Presented at the AIChE Symposium on “Methanol: Emerging Fuel and Chemical Feedstock,” 1984 AIChE Spring National Meeting 1984
- Cowley S. W. Gebhard, S. C. “The Catalytic Decomposition of Methanol into Syngas for Use as an Automotive Fuel,” Proceedings of the 8th Symposium of the Rocky Mountain Fuel Society Salt Lake City, Utah 1983
- Lange’s Handbook of Chemistry Twelfth Edition McGraw-Hill, Inc. New York, New York 1979 9 1
- Anthonissen E. Wallace, J. S. “Dissociated Methanol Engine Testing Results Using H 2 -CO Mixtures,” 18th Intersociety Energy Conversion Engineering Conference Orlando, Florida 1983
- Lalk, T. R. McCall, D. M. McCanlies, J. M. “Evaluation of Dissociated and Steam-Reformed Methanol as Automotive Fuels,” U.S. Department of Energy Report DOE/NBB-0064, DOE/NASA/0142-1, NASA CR-168242 1984
- Adams, T. G. “A Comparison of Engine Performance Using Methanol or Dissociated Methanol as the Fuel,” XX FISITA Conference, Vienna, SAE P-143 4.151 4.157 1984
- Edo T. Foster, D. “A Computer Simulation of a Dissociated Methanol Engine,” Paper A-19, VI International Symposium on Alcohol Fuels Technology Ottawa, Canada 1984
- Swain M. R. Swain, M. N. “A Computer Model for Waste Heat Recovery in Methanol Fuel Engines,” Paper A-59, VI International Symposium on Alcohol Fuels Technology Ottawa, Canada 1984
- Stivender, D. L. “Development of a Fuel-Based Mass Emission Measurement Procedure,” SAE Paper No. 710604 1971
- Finegold, J. G. “Reformed Methanol Vehicle System Considerations,” Proceedings of the 18th Intersociety Energy Conversion Engineering Conference Orlando, Florida 1983
- Young M. B. Lienesch, J. H. “An Engine Diagnostic Package (EDPAC) - Software for Analyzing Cylinder Pressure-Time Data,” SAE Paper No. 780967 , Toronto 1978
- Krieger R. B. Borman, G. L. “The Computation of Apparent Heat Release for Internal Combustion Engines,” ASME Diesel and Gas Power Division 39th Conference Proceedings, Paper No. 66-WA/DGP-4 1967
- National Advisory Committee for Aeronautics “Basic Considerations in the Combustion of Hydrocarbon Fuels with Air,” Report 1300, Lewis Flight Propulsion Laboratory Cleveland, Ohio 1959
- Matekunas, F. A. “Spark Ignition Engines-Combustion Characteristics, Thermodynamics, and the Cylinder-Pressure Card,” General Motors Research Laboratories Report GMR-4660, Presented to Central States Section The Combustion Institute Minneapolis, Minnesota 1984
- Mascetti G. J. Roessler, W. U. “Combustion Losses in Automotive Spark Ignition and Diesel Engines,” Report to the U.S. Department of Energy, No. DOE/CS/50286-2 1982
- Mattavi, J. N. Groff, E. G. Lienesch, J. H. Matekunas F. A. Noyes, R. N. “Engine Improvements Through Combustion Modeling,” Combustion Modeling in Reciprocating Engines Mattavi J. N. Amann, C. A. Plenum Press New York, New York 537 587 1980
- Lienesch, J. H. “Engine Simulation Identifies Optimal Combustion Chamber Design,” Proceedings of the XVII FISITA International Congress Hamburg, West Germany 4 199 209 1980
- Obert, E. F. Concepts of Thermodynamics McGraw-Hill Book Company New York, New York 1960
- Sung N. W. Patterson, D. J. “Theoretical Limits of Engine Economy with Alternative Automotive Fuels,” Energy Research 7 121 127 1983
- Taylor, C. F. The Internal-Combustion Engine in Theory and Practice John Wiley & Sons New York, New York 40 106 1960
- Obert, E. F. Internal Combustion Engines Third Edition International Textbook Company Scranton, Pennsylvania 166 290 1970
- Starkman, E. S. Newhall H. K. Sutton, R. D. “Comparative Performance of Alcohol and Hydrocarbon Fuels,” Part of SAE Publication SP-254, “Alcohols and Hydrocarbons as Motor Fuels,” 1964
- Hardenberg, H. O. Schaefer, A. J. Metsch, H. I. “Fuel Vaporization Improves Fuel Economy of Alcohol-Burning SI Engines” SAE Paper No. 821189 , Part of SP-527, Toronto, Ontario 1982
- Fukushima, T. Nakamura, H. Sakai, T. “Exhaust Emission Control of S.I. Engines by Engine Modification - The SEEC-T System,” SAE Paper No. 770224 1977
- Stebar, R. F. “General Motors View of Hydrogen as an Automotive Fuel,” GMR-3647, General Motors Research Laboratories Warren, Michigan 1981
- Brinkman, N. D. “Ethanol Fuel - A Single-Cylinder Engine Study of Efficiency and Exhaust Emissions,” SAE Paper No. 810345 , Part of SP-480, Detroit, Michigan 1981
- Bahn, G. S. “Approximate Thermochemical Tables for Some C-H and C-H-O Species,” NASA Contractor Report NASA CR-2178 1973