This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Crashworthiness Rating System and Accident Data: Convergences and Divergences
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published February 01, 1984 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
The goal of this paper is to examine the validity of the Crashworthiness Rating Method (part of the New Car Assessment Program -NCAP - created by NHTSA) with reference to real-life accident data. A program was set up to verify the quality of predictive characteristics of vehicle models' real passive safety protection based on 35 mph crash tests against a 0° barrier.
The Crashworthiness Rating Method was applied in the French context because seat belt use has been mandatory in France for over 10 years, and we have access to real-life accident files whose size and categories (type of vehicle model, crushed area, obstacle struck, seat occupied, age, and use of seat belt) allowed us to select cases appropriately and thoroughly. Additionally, the vehicle models which are representative of the French vehicle fleet were tested as if they were part of the NCAP.
The results of crashworthiness rating tests expressed by criteria obtained on dummies and also by the OPSEM or the GILLIS index, were compared with accident statistics results expressed in the form of the fatality rate and the social cost index.
None of the comparisons made (including vehicle model rating) showed any significant convergence between the NCAP-type tests and accident statistics.
The discussion of the reasons for these divergences takes into account the conditions themselves of the NCAP test and the interpretations to which it lends itself, as well as the irrationality of the whole procedure of the method, whose very premises disregard the most basic lessons of accidentology.
CitationThomas, C., Hartemann, F., Foret-Bruno, J., Tarrière, C. et al., "Crashworthiness Rating System and Accident Data: Convergences and Divergences," SAE Technical Paper 840200, 1984, https://doi.org/10.4271/840200.
- Hackney J. Quarles V. The New Car Assessment Program - Status and Effect Presentation at the Ninth Experimental Safety Vehicle Conference Kyoto, Japan October 1982
- U.S. Department of Transportation The Car Book National Highway Traffic Safety Administration Washington, D.C. January 1981
- Consumers Union Which Cars are Safest? Consumer Reports April 1980
- Consumers Union Which Cars Do Best in Crashes? Consumer Reports April 1981
- Consumers Union Progress on a Safer Car. Consumer Reports April 1982
- Consumers Union Crash Tests Begin to Pay Off. Consumer Reports April 1983
- Nirmel, Chittaranjan N. Historical Crashworthiness Ratings February 22 1980
- Carlson W.L. “The Use of Accident Data for Crashworthiness Ratings” NHTSA-8-0756 report
- Campbell, B.J. A Comparison of NHTSA Car Safety Ratings with Injuries in Highway Crashes University of North Carolina Highway Safety Research Center, Highway Safety Highlights 15 3 1982
- Grush E.S. Marsh J.C. IV South N.E. “Comparison of High Speed Crash Test Results with Fatality Rates” 27th Annual Proceeding of AAAM October 3-6 1983 San Antonio, Texas (U.S.A.)
- Backaitis S.H. “A Methodology to Rate Vehicles for Occupant Protection Capabilities” International Automative Ratings Symposium Lancaster, Pennsylvania (U.S.A.) December 1980
- Lestrelin D. Tarriere C. Walfisch G. Fayon A. Got C. Patel A. Hureau J. “Proper Use of HIC Under Different Typical Collision Environments” Proceedings of 9th International Technical Conference on Experimental Safety Vehicles November 1982 Kyoto (Japan)
- Gillis J. “The Crash Test Index” Gillis and Associates April 1983
- American Association for Automotive Medicine “The Abbreviated Injury Scale” Proceedings of 24th AAAM Conference October 1980 Rochester, N.Y.
- Le Net M. “Le Prix de la Vie Humaine” Notes et Etudes documentaires n° 4455 9 fevrier 1978 La documentation francaise
- Versace J. Berton R.J. Determination of Restraint Effectiveness Airbag Crash Test Repeatability Presentation to the Society of Automotive Engineers, Automotive Engineering Congress and Exposition, SAE 750395 February 1975
- National Highway Traffic Safety Administration Statistical Analysis of Crash Test Variability - Dummy Responses Eighteenth NHTSA/Industry Technical Meeting Washington, D.C. April 1983
- Landwehr Wayne A. Dr. “General Comments on the NHTSA Repeatability Test Series” Industry - Government Meeting Ann Arbor, Michigan October 12 1983
- “Renault Presentation to NHTSA Crashworthiness Rating Repeatability Meeting” Industry - Government Meeting Ann Arbor, Michigan October 11-12 1983
- Gauvin B. “Relevance and Feasibility of Vehicle Passive Safety Ratings” Proceedings of 9th International Technical Conference on Experimental Safety Vehicles November 1982 Kyoto, Japan