This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Phase Change Water Recovery Techniques: Vapor Compression Distillation and Thermoelectric/Membrane Concepts
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Two techniques are being considered for the recovery of water from urine and from other waste waters as part of regenerative life support a-board the projected Space Station. One is the Vapor Compression Distillation (VCD) process while the other is based on a thermoelectric/membrane evaporation concept. Both use a phase change recovery process, and both try to minimize the energy input per unit mass of water recovered by using the heat released from condensation as the heat of evaporation for steam generation, i.e., operate at a Coefficient of Performance (COP) of greater than unity. The VCD process compresses steam to achieve the desired temperature differential to transfer the heat of condensation to the evaporation site, while the thermoelectric/membrane concept uses the Peltier effect. This paper describes a projected Water Reclamation System (WRS) of the Space Station's Environmental Control/Life Support System (ECLSS), in general, and defines in detail the two phase change concepts culminating in a comparison of these competing technologies. The analyses are based on current Space Station ground rules and requirements. The subsystem schematics, configurations and their operation are defined, including sizing of components, to form the basis of the comparison. Total equivalent weights for each subsystem, based on fixed hardware weight and power and heat rejection penalties are presented. The VCD process has a clear advantage over the thermoelectric/membrane concept even when operating at 305 K (90 F) versus 339 K (150 F). The thermoelectric concept is 26% heavier, has a 56% higher total equivalent weight and needs over twice the energy per unit mass of water recovered. The data and results presented and conclusions drawn are based on test experience at Life Systems and on information available in the literature.
Authors
Citation
Schubert, F., "Phase Change Water Recovery Techniques: Vapor Compression Distillation and Thermoelectric/Membrane Concepts," SAE Technical Paper 831122, 1983, https://doi.org/10.4271/831122.Also In
References
- Quattrone, P. D. “Extended Mission Life Support Systems,” Paper presented at the Case for Mars Conference Boulder, Colorado June 1981
- Johnson Space Center “Space Station Systems Requirements and Characteristics,” Book 3 November 1982
- Johnson Space Center “Space Station Systems Definition,” Book 5, Draft October 1982
- Boeing Aerospace Company “Space Operations Center,” NASA Contract No. 9-16151 January 1982
- NASA Johnson Space Center “Space Operations Center: A Concept Analysis,” Volume I and II, JSC-16277 November 1979
- NASA Johnson Space Center “Development of an Advanced Preprototype Vapor Compression Distillation Water Recovery Subsystem” Contract NAS9-16374 July 1981
- Johnson Space Center “Regenerative Life Support Evaluation (RLSE) Performance and Interface Specification;” June 1976
- Ellis, G. S. Wynveen, R. A. Schubert, F. H. “Development of a Preprototype Vapor Compression Distillation Water Recovery Subsystem,” Final Report, Contract NAS9-15267, ER-312-4 Life Systems, Inc. Cleveland, OH August 1979
- Lantz, J. B. Davenport, R. J. Wynveen, R. A. Cooper, W. J. “Development of a TOC/COD Analyzer for Process Applications,” Chemistry in Water Reuse 1 Cooper, W. J. Ann Arbor Science Publishers, Inc. 1981
- Davenport, R. J. Lantz, J. B. “Evaluation of an Electrochemical Organic Content Analyzer for Army Water Supply Technology,” Final Report (Analyzer Evaluation), Contract DAMD17-79-C-9058, TR-391-4 Life Systems, Inc. Cleveland, OH April 1980
- Lantz, J. B. Winkler, H. E. Schubert, F. H. Jensen, F. C. “Development of an Advanced Combined Iodine Dispenser/Detector,” Paper No. 77-ENAs-30 Intersociety Conference on Environmental Systems San Francisco, CA July 1977
- Colombo, G. V. Greenley, D. R. “Advanced Microbial Check Valve Development,” Final Report, Contract No. NAS9-15854 Umpqua Research Company Mrytle Creek, OR June 1980
- NASA Johnson Space Center “Potable Water Specification,” SD-W-002 May 1970
- Carlisle, R. F. Romero, J. M. “Space Station Technology Readiness,” Paper presented at the ASME Phoenix, AZ November 1982
- Thompson, C. D. Ellis, G. S. Schubert, F. H. “Preprototype Vapor Compression Distillation Subsystem Development,” Paper No. 81-ENAs-25 Intersociety Conference on Environmental Systems San Francisco, CA July 1981
- Johnson, K. L. Reysa, R. P. Fricks, D. H. “Application of Improved Technology to a Preprototype Vapor Compression Distillation (VCD) Water Recovery Subsystem,” Paper No. 81-ENAs-10 Intersociety Conference on Environmental Systems San Francisco, CA July 1981
- Reveley, W. F. Nuccio, P. P. “Design and Parametric Testing of the Space Station Prototype Integrated Vapor Compression Distillation Water Recovery Module,” Paper No. 75-ENAs-37 Intersociety Conference on Environmental Systems San Francisco, CA July 1975
- Johnson, K. L. “Development of a Preprototype Vapor Compression Distillation Water Recovery Subsystem,” LMSC-D626941 Lockheed Missiles and Space Company, Inc. Sunnyvale, CA November 1978
- Johnson, K. L. Nuccio, P. P. Reveley, W. F. “Improved Wastewater Vapor Compression Distillation Technology,” Paper No. 77-ENAs-20 Intersociety Conference on Environmental Systems San Francisco, CA July 1977
- Putnam, D. F. “Chemical Aspects of Urine Distillation,” Paper No. 65-AV-24 Aviation and Space Conference Los Angeles, CA March 1965
- Roebelen, G. J., Jr. Dehner, G. F. Winkler, H. E. “Thermoelectric Integrated Membrane Evaporation Water Recovery Technology,” Paper No. 820849 Intersociety Conference on Environmental Systems San Diego, CA July 1982
- Winkler, H. E. Roebelen, G. J., Jr. “Development of Preprototype Thermoelectric Integrated Membrane Evaporation Subsystem for Water Recovery,” Paper No. 8-ENAs-46 Intersociety Conference on Environmental Systems San Diego, CA July 1980
- Trusch, R. B. Roebelen, G. J., Jr. “A Thermoelectric Integrated Membrane Evaporation System,” Paper No. 78-ENAs-19 Intersociety Conference on Environmental Systems San Diego, CA July 1978
- Brouillet, A. O. Boynton, C. K., Jr. “Applications of the Thermoelectrically Integrated Membrane Evaporator Subsystem,” Paper No. 79-ENAs-48 Intersociety Conference on Environmental Systems San Francisco, CA July 1979