This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Re-refined Base Oil Characterization and Consistency Monitoring
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
RE-REFINED LUBRICATING BASE OILS are base oils derived from reprocessing of used lubricating oils to remove contaminants, oxidized products, and additives. Early studies suggested that the basic molecular structures of the hydrocarbons were not altered in use, and there were no systematic variations in either contaminants or compositions in the used oils from geographical or seasonal variations [1]*. Various processing technologies are available to remove the contaminants from used oil, most notably the acid/clay process. The acid/clay process has long been used throughout the world and was the dominant process in 1976 when National Bureau of Standards (NBS) initiated its Recycled Oil Program. Due to the environmental problems associated with the disposal of acid sludge, the acid/clay process is rapidly being displaced by new ones: e.g. hydrogenation, vacuum distillation, shortpath distillation, solvent extraction. Host new processes have some pretreatment steps to remove sludge, water, and additive metals. Re-refined base oils are primarily in the 200–400 neutral range. The light ends in the original base oils are lost through evaporation during the use cycle. The very heavy ends are usually removed during re-refining.
Under the Energy Policy and Conservation Act (1975) the National Bureau of Standards is required to study re-refined lubricating base oils and develop test procedures to assess the substantial equivalency between re-refined and virgin oil products. In order to help fulfill this responsibility, a detailed study was made of the comparison between the re-refined and virgin base oil. Seventeen lubricating base oils were selected for detailed characterization in these studies, ten re-refined and seven virgin base oils. These base oils represent a cross-section of available processing technologies, crude sources, and viscosity grades. This paper describes the detailed characterization of these seventeen oils and discusses the various aspects of quality and consistency associated with re-refined base oils. Based on these results, a tentative set of test procedures is recommended for monitoring the quality and consistency of re-refined base oils for automotive applications.
Recommended Content
Authors
Citation
Hsu, S., Ku, C., and Becker, D., "Re-refined Base Oil Characterization and Consistency Monitoring," SAE Technical Paper 821240, 1982, https://doi.org/10.4271/821240.Also In
References
- Whisman, M.L., et al., “A Summary of Composition Variations Among 30 Used Lubricating Oils Selected for Seasonal and Geographical Significance,” ERDA BERC reseearch report 76/4 1976
- “Waste Oil Study,” EPA report to the Congress,” April 1974
- Bowen, T.C. “DOD Experiences in Testing Lube Oils,” NBS SP. 488 1977
- Frame, E.A. Bowen, T.C. “U.S. Army/EPA Re-refined Engine Oil Program,” AFLRL report Ho. 98 U.S. Army Mobility Equipment Research and Development Command Fort Bel voir, Va 1978
- Ulrichson, D.L. Vake, D.E. “Iowa Re-refined Oil Fleet Test,” Report No. ISU-ERI-AMES-78310 Iowa State University Ames, Iowa 1978
- Frame E.A. “Inspection of Police Cruiser Engines Operated Using Re-refined and Virgin Based Crankcase Lubricants,” AFLRL Report No. 92 U.S. Army MERADCOM Fort Belvior, Va. 1977
- Armstrong, J. Strigner, P.L. “A Field and Laboratory Comparison of a Re-refined and a Virgin Automotive Engine Oil,” SAE International Fuels and Lubricants Meeting Oct. 18–21 1982 Toronto, Canada 821239
- Linnard, R. “PROP Re-refined Oil Engine Test performance,” NBS SP 584 69 1980
- Sands, T.P. “Comments on Additive Response to Different Base Oils,” NBS SP 488 61 1977
- Hsu, S.M. Becker, D.A. “Status Report on the Characterization of Re-refined Lubricating Base Oils,” SAE paper 801382 1980
- Hsu, S.M., et al., “Physical and Chemical Test Methods for Re-refined Base Oils,” 1983
- Hsu, S.M. Ku, C.S. Lin R.S. “Relationship Between Lubricating Basestock Composition and the Effects of Additives on Oxidation Stability,” SAE International Fuels and Lubricants Meeting Oct. 18–21 1982 Toronto, Canada 821237
- Hsu, S.M. Ku, C.S. Lin, R.S. “Effects of Base Oil Composition on Additive Response in Oxidation Stability,” 1983
- Becker, D.A. “ASTM/NBS Basestock Consistency Study: Preliminary Compilation of Data and Results,” Recycled Oil Program, National Bureau of Standards Washington, DC June 1982
- Espey, D. “Comments from a Producer of Virgin Base Oil,” NBS SP 584 139 1980
- ASTM D-2007 Method description ASTM Annual Book of ASTM Standards 169 1981
- Ku, C.S. Pei, P., Hsu, S.M., “Evaluation of ASTM D2007 Method for the Determination of Lubricating Oil Composition,” presented at the Fourth Conference on Measurements and Standards for Recycled Oil Sept. 14–16 1982 National Bureau of Standards Washington, DC, 20234
- Pel, P., Britton, J. Jr., Hsu, S.H., “Hydrocarbon Type Separation of Lubricating Base Oil in Multigram Quantity by Preparative HPLC,”
- Pel, P. Hsu, S.M. “Re-refined Base Oil Characterization Using Liquid Chromatographic Techniques,” presented at the Fourth Conference on Measurements and Standards for Recycled Oil Sept. 14–16 1982 National Bureau of Standards Washington, DC, 20234
- Klaus, E.E., Shah, P. Krishnamachar, V. “Development and Use of the Micro-Oxidation Test with Crankcase Oils,” presented at the Fourth Conference on Measurements and Standards for Recycled Oil Sept. 14–16 1982 National Bureau of Standards Washington, DC, 20234
- Hsu, S.M. “Review of Laboratory Bench Tests in Assessing the Performance of Automotive Crankcase Oils,” Lubrication Engineering 37 12 722 1981
- Gates, R.S. Hsu, S.M. “Development of a Four-Ball Wear Test Procedure to Evaluate Automotive Lubricating Oils,” ASLE preprint 82-AM-6A-4 Cincinnati, Ohio May 10–13 1982
- Ku, C.S. Hsu, S.M. “A Thin-Film Oxygen Uptake Test for the Evaluation of Automotive Crankcase Lubricants,”; ASLE preprint 82-LC-1D-1 Washington, DC Oct 5–7 1982
- ASTM D-2272 method description ASTM Annual Book of ASTM Standards 289 1981
- Mahoney, L.R. Korcek, S. Hoffman, S. Willermet, P.A. “Determination of the Antioxidant Capacity of New and Used Lubricants; Method and Applications,” Ind. & Eng. Chem., Prod. Res. & Devel. 17 250 1978
- BMDP Statistical Software Department of Biomathematics, University of California, Los Angeles University of California Press 1981
- Ku, C.S. Weeks, S.J. Hsu, S.M. “Thin-Film Oxidation Test: Relationship Between Chemical Composition and Additive Response for Re-refined Oils,” presented at the Fourth Conference on Measurements and Standards for Recycled Oil Sept. 14–16 1982 National Bureau of Standards Washington, DC, 20234
- Frassa, K “ASTM/NBS Base Stock Consistency Study,” NBS SP 584 105 1980
- Starr, W.C. “Consistency of Base Stock Production; An ASTM/NBS Study,” Proceedings of the Fourth International Conference on Used Oil Recovery and Reuse Las Vegas, Nevada Sept. 28 1981