This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
A Model and the Methodology for Determining Wear Particle Generation Rate and Filter Efficiency in a Diesel Engine Using Ferrography
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published February 01, 1982 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
Monitoring of the wear rate of a diesel engine will yield valuable information regarding the wear mechanism within a diesel engine and ultimately will improve the predictions of failing engines and/or their components to allow preventive maintenance which will prolong the life of the engine.
A mathematical model was developed that describes the wear particle concentration as a function of time in a diesel engine. This model contains engine and lubrication system parameters that determine the concentration of wear particles in the engine sump. These variables are the oil system volume, oil flow rate, particle generation rate, filtering efficiency and the initial particle concentration. The model has been employed to study the wear particle concentrations in the sump and the mass of particles in the filter for the Cummins VT-903 diesel engine. In addition, the model was used to develop a testing methodology for determining wear particle generation rates and filter efficiencies from used oil analysis. This testing methodology uses ferrography together with computer programs to yield accurate statistical information on the data as curve fit to the model. The test set up incorporated a remote controlled sampling system that enabled the accurate and periodic taking of oil samples over an approximate five hour engine test.
Results of this research indicate that equilibrium wear particle concentrations increase with an increase in engine speed and load. The wear particle generation rate and filter efficiency as determined by the test methodology were found to decrease with an increase in engine speed and load. After oil and filter changes, the wear particle generation rate and filter efficiency continually increased with cumulative engine time up to approximately 11 hours. The test methods used to obtain the results above were found to be repeatable to within ±15% and could conceivably be employed to determine wear parameters on other diesel engines as well as the effects of other engine variables such as lubricants, oil temperature, coolant temperature and engine components have on the wear parameters.
CitationHubert, C., Beck, J., and Johnson, J., "A Model and the Methodology for Determining Wear Particle Generation Rate and Filter Efficiency in a Diesel Engine Using Ferrography," SAE Technical Paper 821195, 1982, https://doi.org/10.4271/821195.
- Anderson, D. N. “The Application of a High Gradient Magnetic Separator to the Study of Diesel Engine Wear and Filtration Using Ferrography,” M. S. Thesis Mechanical Engineering -Engineering Mechanics Department, Michigan Technological University 1979
- Hofman, M. V. “The Development and Application of Ferrography to the Study of Diesel Engine Wear,” Master’s Thesis Mechanical Engineering - Engineering Mechanics Department, Michigan Technological University 1977
- Hofman, M. V. Johnson, J. H. “The Development and Application of Ferrography to the Study of Diesel Engine Wear,” SAE Paper No. 780181 , Presented at the SAE congress and Exposition February 27–March 3 1978
- Scott, D. Seifert, W. W. Westcott, V. C. “The Particles of Wear,” Scientific American May 1974 88 97
- Seifert, W. W. Westcott, V. C. “A Method for the Study of Wear Particles in Lubricating Oil,” Wear 21 1972 27 42
- Hofman, M. V. Johnson, J. H. “The Development of Ferrography as a Laboratory Wear Measurement Method for the Study of Engine Operating Conditions on Diesel Engine wear,” Wear 44 1977 183 199
- Anderson, D. N. Hubert, C. J. Johnson, J. H. “Advances in Quantitative Analytical Ferrography and the Evaluation of a High Gradient Magnetic Separator for the Study of Diesel Engine Wear” SAE Paper no. 821194 , Presented at the SAB Fuels and Lubricants Meeting, Toronto, Ontario October 18–21 1982
- Pocock. G. “Wear Debris Analysis for Machinery Health Monitoring,” Presented at the Annual Conference of the Institute Birmingham September 1978
- Tessman, R. K. “Monitoring Wear in Hydraulic Systems,” Presented at the International Conference on Fundamentals of Tribology Massachusetts Institute of Technology June 19–22 1978
- Fodor, S. “Improving Utilization of potential I. C. Engine Life by Filtration,” Tribology International June 1979
- Hudgens, R. D. Feldhaus, L. B. “Diesel Engine Lube Filter Life Related to Oil Chemistry,” SAE Paper No. 780974 , Presented at the International Fuels & Lubricants Meeting, Royal York, Toronto November 13–16 1978
- Pocock, G. Gadd, P. “The Relationship Between the Ferrograrn Entry Deposit and the Iron Content of Used Lubricating oils,” Wear 39 1976 161 165
- Fodor, J. “personal Conversations During a Visit to Michigan Technological University.”
- Obert, E. F. “Internal Combustion Engines and Air Pollution,” Intext Educational publishers New York 1973 Library of Congress Catalog
- Thomas, G. E. “Injested Dust, Filters, and Diesel Engine Ring wear,” SAE Paper No. 680536 , West Coast Meeting San Francisco, California August 12–15 1968
- Fodor, J. Tribodiagnostics in Internal Combustion Engines Using Gamma-Ray Spectrometry of Wear,” I Mech E 1978 91 95
- Sailer, S. “Wear Measurement With Radionuclides,” Metal Progress April 1981 64 67
- Pocock, G. Courtney, S. J. “Some Quantitative Aspects of Ferrography,” Wear 67 287 301 1981
- Phillips, O. H. Lane, P. D. Shaddy, M. C. “Diesel Engine Wear with Spin-On By-Pass Lube Oil Filters,” SAE Paper No. 790089 , Presented at the SAE Congress and Exposition February 26–March 2 1979
- “Non Linear Regression Routines,” Academic Computing Center, The University of Wisconsin-Madison
- Pfeifer, P. E. Finnigan, F. T. “Oil Filtration and Lifter Wear,” Society of Automotive Engineers” SAE Transactions 74 No. 3 1965 912 921
- Lowther, H. V. Letter received from Mobil Research and Development Corporation August 1981
- McClellard, J. E. Billett, S. M. “Filter Life Versus Engine wear,” Society of Automotive Engineers” SAE Transactions 74 No. 3 1965 922 936
- Rabinowicz, E. “Friction and Wear Materials,” John Wiley and Sons, Inc. New York, New York 1965 Library of Congress