This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Comparison of Gasoline and Diesel Automobile Fuel Economy as Seen by the Consumer
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
A number of different and perhaps conflicting claims have been made about the fuel-economy benefits of Diesel-fueled automobiles versus their gasoline-fueled counterparts. While a “traditional” figure of a 25 percent fuel-economy gain with Diesels is often used, this figure has varied due to differences in vehicle performance, driving conditions, fuel Btu content, and advances In engine design (particularly in spark-ignition engines). This paper looks at fuel economy, in the broad sense of the term, from the consumer's perspective. The analysis is based on EPA-measured fuel economy in model year 1980, actual on-road fuel economy for 1975-1980 automobiles, and recent fuel price data for gasoline and Diesel fuel. Comparisons of gasoline and Diesel fuel economy that account for these three variables are presented. Also considered is the way that gasoline and Diesel fuel economy comparisons may change in the future with changes in fuel prices, emission standards, and engine design.
Recommended Content
Authors
Topic
Citation
McNutt, B., "Comparison of Gasoline and Diesel Automobile Fuel Economy as Seen by the Consumer," SAE Technical Paper 810387, 1981, https://doi.org/10.4271/810387.Also In
References
- Office of Environmental Assessments, DOE “Issues Concerning the Light Duty Diesel An Update” September 1980 130
- Schultz W. J. et al “Comparison of Diesel Over Gasoline Fuel Economy Claims by Association” SAE Paper 760047 February 1976
- McNutt B. et al “Comparison of EPA and Inuse Fuel Economy of 1974-1978 Automobiles,” SAE Paper 790932 October 1979
- Murrell J. D. Foster J. Bristor B. “Passenger Car and Light Truck Fuel Economy Trends Through 1980,” SAE Paper 800853 June 1980
- McNutt B. et al “A Comparison of Fuel Economy Results from EPA Tests and Actual In-use Experience, 1974-1977 Model Year Cars,” SAE Paper 780037 February 1978
- Energy and Environmental Analysis, Inc. “The Light Duty Vehicle Fuel Consumption Model -First Quarterly Report,” June 12 1980
- Fisher T. M. General Motors Corp., Letter to B. McNutt, DOE February 8 1979 Schneider R. October 3 1979 SAE Meeting, Houston, Texas
- LaPointe Clay Ford Motor Company, Oral Presentation at October 3 1979 SAE Meetings Houston, Texas
- U.S. EPA “Passenger Car fuel Economy: EPA and Road,” September 1980 231 Report #460/3-80-010.
- U.S. DOE Energy Information Administration “Monthly Energy Review,” October 1980 73
- DOE/EIA, op.cit 79
- Energy and Environmental Analysis, Inc. “The Light Duty Vehicle Fuel Consumption Model - Addendum to the Second Quarterly Report,” November 5 1980
- Ostrouchov N. “Effect of Cold Weather on Motor Vehicle Emissions and Fuel Consumption II,” SAE Paper 790229 February 1979
- U.S. Department of Energy Information Administration “Annual Report to Congress 1979” 114
- DOE/EIA, op.cit 115
- DOE/EIA, op.cit 95
- Shearer H. A. Wagner T. O. “Economics of Manufacturing Automotive Diesel Fuel,” API Preprint No. 09-77 May 10 1977
- Lawrence D. K. et al. “Automotive Fuels - Refinery Energy and Economics,” SAE Paper 800225 February 1980
- Lundberg Dan Publisher, Lundtberg Letter VII 39 October 3 1980
- Energy and Environmental Analysis, Inc. “Medium and Heavy Duty Truck Fuel Demand Module - Final Report,” Prepared for U.S. DOE May 28 1980
- DeKany John P. “Methodology for Calculation of Diesel Fuel to Gasoline Fuel Economy Equivalence Factors,” U.S. EPA January 1976 May 1976
- “Potential Passenger Car Demand for Diesel Fuel and Refinery Implications,” Barry E.G. et al Mobil Research and Development Corporation SAE Paper No. 700315 February 1977
- “Economics of Manufacturing Automotive Diesel Fuel,” Wagner T. O. et al. Amoco Oil Company Paper No. 09-77, API Refining Department, 42nd Midyear Meeting May 1977
- “Automotive Fuel Requirements with Increasing Diesel Car Population and Implications to Refining Operations,” Balasubramanian M. Jenkins R. TRW, Prepared for U.S. DOE February 1978
- “The Impact of Increased Diesel Fuel Use on the Petroleum Refining Industry and on Crude Oil Consumption,” Sabotka and Company, Inc. Prepared for U.S. DOE November 1979
- “Critique of EPA Methodology for Calculating Diesel Fuel Equivalency Factor,” Attachment to Letter from Galbreath T. J. Ford Motor Company to Mr. Charles Gray, EPA November 28 1979
- “Automotive Fuels - Lawrence D. K. et al. Amoco Oil Company SAE Paper No. 800225 February 1980
- “An Analysis of Potential for Upgrading Domestic Refining Capacity,” Purvin and Gertz, Inc. Prepared for American Gas Association March 1980
- “Annual Report to Congress - Volume Three,” U.S. DOE/Energy Information Administration 1980
- Lawrence D. K. Amoco Oil Company to W. Johnson, Sabotka and Company October 31 1980
- “Review of Diesel Equivalency Factors,” Sabotka and Company, Prepared for U.S. EPA December 5 1980